Orin Gordon
The sounding I got from Caribbean diplomats and ministers in Antigua and Barbuda for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting—which overlapped with the US midterm elections on November 3—is that we shouldn’t expect to see much movement on the parts of US foreign policy that affect them. They include third-country deportees and visa restrictions.
The general read is cautious. President Trump retains considerable clout through the presidential veto, which would require 67 votes (two-thirds) of a full sitting of the 100-seat Senate for an override.
Trump has also not been shy to use executive orders—limited presidential powers to create statutes without Congressional approval—even if they’ve tended to test the limits of what is constitutional. Some, such as tariffs, have been struck down by the courts.
Besides, some of the pain points of US foreign policy require bilateral engagement. Third-country deportees and visas do not affect every country equally. Trinidad and Tobago, whose prime minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar has been outspoken in support of Trump’s foreign policy, has not been made to swallow the frogs that other Caribbean countries have.
Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio have been adept at picking off and fracturing the Caribbean bloc. The State Department has weaponised visas and travel to keep individual countries in line… directly, when it comes to third-country deportees, Cuba (on medical provision and on the longstanding US embargo) and the International Criminal Court (ICC).
Israeli military and settler excesses towards Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank are an area that bears watching, particularly on the question of how T&T will vote on the Security Council when it takes up its seat in January.
T&T is representing the 33-member Latin American and Caribbean Group (GRULAC). However, the T&T government’s fealty to the Trump administration has been absolute, and it’s probably optimistic to expect that T&T’s votes would reflect the position of the majority of GRULAC’s membership.
One important wrinkle on the Palestinian question is that there hasn’t been enough distance between the Democratic congressional leadership of Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries and the Biden and Trump administrations. Independent United Nations commissions and human rights officials have concluded that the Israeli authorities and military forces committed war crimes, crimes against humanity, and acts of genocide in Gaza.
Both US administrations abetted those actions. Schumer’s and Jeffries’ inaction in holding either to account fuelled a mini-rebellion by left-leaning Democratic voters against their continued leadership, even before the clock struck midnight on election night.
Jeffries is currently unopposed for Speaker of the House. Schumer is facing a challenge from Maryland senator Chris Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader. Even members on Jeffries’ left flank—Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Pramila Jayapal and Ro Khanna—have either said they’d vote for him, or that he will be elected Speaker. He’d become the first black person to hold the position.
Disqualifying Schumer and Jeffries on the basis of their Israeli/Gaza policy is a sound point of principle. On the other hand, the Democratic left—the caucus of the perpetually miserable—shows greater energy fighting people in their tent than holding Trump to account for far worse policy decisions.
The Democratic caucus leaders led the party to its biggest electoral success in half a century. Generally, people who lead in achieving generational wins are not then immediately shoved aside. The job of the head coach of the New York Knicks—which both men support—is safe. Mike Brown led the Knicks to their first National Basketball Association championship in 53 years.
Whoever wins will pick committee chairs and members to oversee hearings and investigations into the Trump administration’s lawbreaking. That includes the execution of at least 244 people they labelled as high-seas drug traffickers, without evidence or trials. Two T&T citizens were victims of the aerial strikes in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific.
Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth, the self-styled Secretary of War, will face impeachment from the Democratic majority when its members are seated in January.
Some lawmakers saw a video of the US Navy executing two shipwreck survivors on September 2, 2025, and were sickened by it. They have a duty to compel its public release, and that of the US Justice Department’s legal brief for a policy that clearly violates international law.
