JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Monday, May 26, 2025

Choosing the right water & wastewater disinfectant

by

Dr Kiran Tota-Maharaj
2081 days ago
20190914
Kiran Tota-Maharaj

Kiran Tota-Maharaj

Mark Thomas

In the mid-to-late 1800s, chlo­rine had been used spo­rad­i­cal­ly to help con­trol wa­ter­borne ill­ness­es and pol­lu­tants in drink­ing wa­ter. This al­so prompt­ed util­i­ties across the world to be­gin large-scale fil­tra­tion of wa­ter sup­plies and waste­water treat­ment. How­ev­er, back then fil­tra­tion alone was in­ad­e­quate to re­duce wide­spread ill­ness­es and dis­in­fec­tion with chlo­ri­na­tion vir­tu­al­ly elim­i­nat­ing wa­ter­borne epi­demics, in­creas­ing life ex­pectan­cy by 50 per cent.

Con­ven­tion­al wa­ter and waste­water treat­ment fa­cil­i­ties use var­i­ous dis­in­fec­tion process­es at the head of the treat­ment work with the aim of not cre­at­ing chlo­rine byprod­ucts, there­after chlo­rine is ap­plied to the ef­flu­ent or fin­ished wa­ter prod­uct to main­tain a resid­ual through­out the wa­ter dis­tri­b­u­tion sys­tem. With in­creas­ing wa­ter pol­lu­tion and strin­gent en­vi­ron­men­tal reg­u­la­tions, it is be­com­ing more dif­fi­cult to achieve all of the re­quire­ments for safe Wa­ter and Waste­water dis­in­fec­tion with one treat­ment alone. To­day, a more lay­ered ap­proach for dis­in­fec­tion with mul­ti­ple tech­nolo­gies used to­geth­er is of­ten nec­es­sary. Some of the most re­li­able dis­in­fec­tants and dis­in­fec­tion process­es used in in­dus­try to­day in­clude:

(I) Chlo­rine gas

Used in wa­ter treat­ment plants since the ear­ly 1900s, it is es­sen­tial­ly pure chlo­rine, typ­i­cal­ly de­liv­ered in pres­surised cylin­ders. It is gen­er­al­ly the most cost-ef­fec­tive, ef­fi­cient, and eas­i­est to main­tain the method of dis­in­fect­ing with chlo­rine. Chlo­rine diox­ide is gen­er­at­ed by mix­ing acid or chlo­rine gas and sodi­um chlo­rite then mixed with ejec­tor wa­ter as an en­trained gas to form a so­lu­tion that is ap­plied to the process. Be­cause it can­not be com­pressed and liq­ue­fied for trans­porta­tion, it is of­ten gen­er­at­ed on-site close to its in­tend­ed use. It is a strong ox­i­dant and a very pop­u­lar dis­in­fec­tant across a wide pH range for both wa­ter and waste­water. It does not re­act with am­mo­nia to be­come a weak­er dis­in­fec­tant, im­por­tant for wa­ter and waste­water treat­ment plants where the wa­ter has a high am­mo­nia con­tent, of­ten re­sult­ing in low­er op­er­at­ing costs. Chlo­rine diox­ide is fre­quent­ly used in wa­ter treat­ment plants as a pri­ma­ry dis­in­fec­tant ear­ly in the treat­ment process to pre­vent the for­ma­tion of Tri­halomethanes (THMs) which en­vi­ron­men­tal pol­lu­tants, and many are con­sid­ered car­cino­genic.

(II) Sodi­um Hypochlo­rite

Man­u­fac­tured at ap­prox­i­mate­ly 12 to 15 per cent chlo­rine by weight with a pH greater than 11. De­liv­ery sys­tems of this liq­uid dis­in­fec­tion in­clude stor­age tanks, chem­i­cal dos­ing pump­ing sys­tems with as­so­ci­at­ed valves and pip­ing, and a con­trol method such as flow con­trol, resid­ual con­trol or com­pound loop (flow + resid­ual). Al­though more ex­pen­sive com­mer­cial­ly than chlo­rine gas it is con­sid­ered sim­pler to main­tain and op­er­ate with on-site gen­er­a­tion. Bulk sodi­um hypochlo­rite con­cen­tra­tion de­cays over time and high­er vol­umes are re­quired to achieve the same re­sult.

(III) On-site hypochlo­rite gen­er­a­tion (OS­HG)

An On-site hypochlo­rite gen­er­a­tion (OS­HG) sys­tem us­es elec­trol­y­sis to gen­er­ate a nom­i­nal so­lu­tion of hypochlo­rite on-site as need­ed. A brine so­lu­tion pass­es through an elec­trolyt­ic cell, con­vert­ing the chlo­ride ions from salt to hypochlo­rite. The process typ­i­cal­ly us­es three pounds of salt, two kW hours of elec­tric­i­ty and 15 gal­lons of wa­ter to pro­duce a pound of chlo­rine in 15 gal­lons of so­lu­tion, the equiv­a­lent of the ac­tive chlo­rine present in one gal­lon of 12.5 per cent bulk hypochlo­rite or one pound of chlo­rine gas. OS­HG sys­tems have mod­er­ate main­te­nance re­quire­ments and are con­sid­ered safer than trans­port­ing chlo­rine gas un­der pres­sure.

(IV) On-site chlo­rine gen­er­a­tion (OS­CG)

Sim­i­lar to OS­HG, an On-site chlo­rine gen­er­a­tion (OS­CG) sys­tem us­es brine so­lu­tions and mem­brane elec­trol­y­sis to pro­duce high­er con­cen­tra­tions of hypochlo­rite up to 12 per cent of chlo­rine gas. On-site chlo­rine gen­er­a­tion re­duces trans­porta­tion and de­liv­ery haz­ards as­so­ci­at­ed with ship­ping com­mer­cial hypochlo­rite and elim­i­nates trans­porta­tion safe­ty con­cerns of chlo­rine gas de­liv­ered in liq­uid (bulk) con­tain­ers.

(V) Cal­ci­um hypochlo­rite

A sol­id tablet, cal­ci­um hypochlo­rite is typ­i­cal­ly 60 per cent avail­able chlo­rine de­liv­ered via a di­lu­tion tank or tablet feed sys­tem where­by the cal­ci­um hypochlo­rite is dis­solved in­to so­lu­tion then dosed with a me­ter­ing pump. It is com­mon­ly used in swim­ming pools. Be­cause cal­ci­um hypochlo­rite is ex­pen­sive per pound of chlo­rine and is dif­fi­cult to ac­cu­rate­ly dose when it is oc­ca­sion­al­ly used for wa­ter and waste­water treat­ment, it is typ­i­cal for small­er re­mote plants or treat­ment works where oth­er meth­ods of chlo­rine feed are not fea­si­ble.

(VI) Chlo­ramines

In the pres­ence of am­mo­nia, chlo­rine com­bines with the am­mo­nia to form ei­ther mono-chlo­ramine, di-chlo­ramine or tri-chlo­ramine de­pend­ing on the am­mo­nia-to-chlo­rine ra­tio. Mono-chlo­ramine is a rel­a­tive­ly weak dis­in­fec­tant but main­tains a very sta­ble long-last­ing resid­ual in wa­ter and is there­fore of­ten used as a sec­ondary dis­in­fec­tion method in sys­tems with a long wa­ter age. Chlo­ramine sys­tems can be chal­leng­ing to con­trol and wa­ter and waste­water op­er­a­tors and en­gi­neers must care­ful­ly mon­i­tor and main­tain their dos­ing sys­tems for max­i­mum ac­cu­ra­cy.

(VII) Ozone

Com­priss­ing three oxy­gen atoms (O3), ozone is a very strong ox­i­dant. It de­te­ri­o­rates rapid­ly to oxy­gen and is usu­al­ly gen­er­at­ed on-site us­ing ei­ther air or pure oxy­gen. Ozone does not pro­duce dis­in­fec­tion byprod­ucts (DBPs) and can be used as a pri­ma­ry dis­in­fec­tant for wa­ter treat­ment to re­duce THMs and DBPs. Ozone al­so is used for taste, odour and colour con­trol in potable wa­ter treat­ment, as well as Iron-Man­ganese (Fe/Mn) re­moval when THMs are a con­cern. Ozone can al­so be used to re­move mi­cro-pol­lu­tants in­clud­ing pes­ti­cides at dis­in­fec­tion dosages. Ozona­tion is typ­i­cal­ly not used for pri­ma­ry dis­in­fec­tion of waste­water ef­flu­ent with high lev­els of sus­pend­ed solids (SS), bio­chem­i­cal oxy­gen de­mand (BOD), chem­i­cal oxy­gen de­mand (COD), or to­tal or­gan­ic car­bon (TOC) since the cost of treat­ment can be rel­a­tive­ly high in cap­i­tal and in pow­er in­ten­sive­ness.

(VI­II) Ul­tra­vi­o­let Light (UV ra­di­a­tion)

Ul­tra­vi­o­let light en­er­gy at 254 nm wave­length is ab­sorbed by the DNA of a mi­croor­gan­ism, stop­ping the re­pro­duc­tive process and ren­der­ing it non-in­fec­tive and mi­cro­bi­o­log­i­cal­ly dead. UV sys­tems op­er­ate at vary­ing pres­sure and out­put, de­pend­ing on ap­pli­ca­tion, tar­get pathogens and wa­ter qual­i­ty in­volved. UV has most re­cent­ly been used to treat waste­water ef­flu­ent since en­vi­ron­men­tal reg­u­la­tions glob­al­ly re­quire more strin­gent chlo­rine dis­charge lim­its for var­i­ous re­ceiv­ing streams. UV is ef­fec­tive in re­mov­ing chlo­rine-re­sis­tant pathogens from drink­ing wa­ter in­clud­ing Cryp­tosporid­i­um, Gi­a­r­dia and var­i­ous virus­es that have proven to be re­sis­tant to tra­di­tion­al dis­in­fec­tion meth­ods such as chlo­rine and fil­tra­tion.

(IX) Per­acetic Acid (PAA)

Per­acetic acid (CH3CO3—al­so known as per­ox­y­acetic acid, or PAA—is a liq­uid that func­tions as a strong ox­i­dis­ing agent, has an acrid odour and can al­so be used as a dis­in­fec­tant. PAA is gen­er­al­ly com­mer­cial­ly avail­able as an equi­lib­ri­um mix­ture of 12-15 per cent per­acetic acid and 18-23 per cent hy­dro­gen per­ox­ide. PAA is avail­able in gal­lon con­tain­ers and in bulk, re­quires stain­less steel pip­ing, and is ad­min­is­tered us­ing a me­ter­ing pump. Since PAA is a high­ly ef­fec­tive bac­te­ri­cide, does not form dis­in­fec­tion by-prod­ucts (DBPs), has min­i­mal de­pen­den­cy on pH and does not leave a resid­ual, it has re­ceived sig­nif­i­cant con­sid­er­a­tion for the dis­in­fec­tion of waste­water ef­flu­ent.

With a well-de­fined wa­ter and waste­water treat­ment process goals and ex­pe­ri­ence, knowl­edge­able part­ners work­ing to­geth­er, de­vel­op­ing the most ef­fec­tive, sim­ple and bud­get-con­scious wa­ter and waste­water dis­in­fec­tion plan should be a sim­ple, sus­tain­able and eco­nom­i­cal process.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored