Andrea Perez-Sobers
Senior Reporter
andrea.perez-sobers@guardian.co.tt
Trinidad and Tobago’s handling of the security situation in Maloney could influence how international investors assess the country’s stability, its ability to protect economic activity and the Government’s capacity to balance public safety with civil liberties.
Three international relations experts have offered differing perspectives on the implications of the nightly 9 pm to 5 am curfew, with concerns ranging from the country’s international reputation and its ability to attract foreign capital to the potential benefits of limiting the intervention to one community.
Professor Andy Knight warned that the restrictions could reinforce perceptions of instability and raise questions about the Government’s approach to crime. Dr Mark Kirton cautioned that the manner in which the security measures are implemented could prompt investors to reconsider entering the market. Professor Ivelaw Lloyd Griffith, however, argued that the limited geographical scope of the curfew could be interpreted as a positive development.
The three experts spoke to Guardian Business on Monday as the country continued to grapple with the implications of the measures imposed following a shooting in Maloney earlier this month, which left five people injured.
While the immediate objective is to contain violence, the debate has widened to include the country’s economic prospects, particularly as T&T is seeking investors for the proposed restart of the Pointe-a-Pierre Refinery.
For Knight, the concern extends beyond the impact on Maloney. It is also about the message the country sends to the international community when the authorities resort to restrictive measures to address criminal activity.
“It’s very troubling for me to hear this because it seems as though certain people are being targeted by this sort of thing. They’re targeting a specific type of community, right?”
Knight argued that the Government’s response to crime must address the underlying conditions contributing to violence rather than rely primarily on security interventions.
He questioned whether successive administrations had made sufficient progress in tackling the causes of criminal activity, warning that the problem could persist if those issues remained unresolved.
“Obviously, the government has not been able to address the crime problem in Trinidad,” he stressed.
He also cautioned against treating the Maloney restrictions as an isolated domestic security matter. From an international relations perspective, the way a country manages public disorder can influence perceptions among investors, tourists and people considering travelling there.
“When you have this kind of lockdown, it is not the same as a state of emergency, but it has the same kind of effect,” Knight explained.
“It would have negative impacts on investment. It would have negative impacts on tourism. It would have negative impacts on people just travelling back and forth to T&T.”
His concern is that repeated security interventions could contribute to an image of a country struggling to maintain order, creating additional uncertainty for businesses considering long-term commitments.
“It doesn’t look good from, you know, it looks as though the country is not stable. You get the impression that the country is not being stable because that’s the impression that’s given by these lockdowns.”
Security measures and the investor test
Knight’s concerns come at a time when this country is attempting to attract significant investment into its energy sector, including the proposed revival of refining operations at Pointe-a-Pierre.
The refinery project has the potential to generate employment, stimulate economic activity and strengthen the country’s position in the regional energy market. However, investors assessing such a project must consider more than the commercial prospects of the facility.
Dr Mark Kirton shared concerns about the possible consequences of the curfew, arguing that investors would assess both the security challenges facing the country and the Government’s response.
He acknowledged that public safety and security are essential considerations for businesses evaluating investment destinations. However, he cautioned that restrictive measures could create a different set of concerns if they give the impression that authorities are struggling to contain the situation.
“Stability, local stability, public safety and security are key components of any investor’s thinking on a country,” Kirton told Guardian Business.
“But at the same time, that type of draconian engagement with people doesn’t necessarily augur well for short-term investment in the country.”
Kirton described the situation as a mixed picture. While governments must demonstrate that they can protect citizens and maintain public order, the approach taken must also provide investors with confidence that the business environment remains predictable.
He questioned whether the decision to identify one community for such restrictive measures could create concerns about the possibility of similar interventions elsewhere.
For an international company considering a regional investment, the issue is not necessarily whether crime exists, but whether the operating environment is likely to become more uncertain.
“Why are we going into an area or to a country that could emerge as a regional Caribbean hotspot?” he questioned.
Kirton warned that investors could take another look at their plans before committing capital, with possible consequences for employment and wider economic activity.
“I would say immediately that investors may take a second look at what is taking place before they come into the country,” he told Guardian Business.
He also connected the security situation to the refinery proposal, arguing that the potential investment should be viewed within the context of regional energy security.
A successful restart could create opportunities for joint ventures and crude supplies from countries including Ghana and Suriname, helping to support refining operations and provide benefits beyond T&T.
Kirton argued that investment in Pointe-a-Pierre could contribute to a more stable regional energy environment, particularly for smaller Caribbean states that depend on secure energy supplies.
“If you get investors into Petrotrin, and then you can have the Caribbean support that with crude and joint venture activity, crude oil and crude joint venture activity, then that might go well for the future of Caribbean energy security.”
For that reason, he argued, the Government must consider the wider economic implications of its security policies.
Kirton also stressed that crime is not unique to Trinidad and Tobago. Other Caribbean countries face challenges involving organised crime, drug trafficking, firearms and human smuggling.
However, he argued that the region needs stronger cooperation rather than relying solely on individual national responses.
“There has to be political will among the leadership to have strong, unified regional approaches to transnational organised crime and drug trafficking and gun smuggling, people smuggling, etc.”
Griffith rejects the alarm over investment
Professor Ivelaw Lloyd Griffith offered a markedly different assessment, arguing that international investors and members of the Trinidad and Tobago diaspora could view the Maloney curfew more favourably than Knight and Kirton suggested.
His assessment rests largely on the fact that the previous nationwide state of emergency, which ran from March to September, has ended and the current curfew is restricted to Maloney.
Griffith argued that investors would distinguish between a country under nationwide emergency restrictions and one where security measures are confined to a specific comunity.
“International investors and Trinis in the diaspora, in my view, will see that as more positive than negative,” he told Guardian Business.
He acknowledged that the country’s problems with crime, gang activity and violence had not been resolved. However, he argued that the end of the state of emergency demonstrated progress, even if the country still had considerable work to do.
“The fact that the curfew is just with the Maloney Community. It’s not throughout Tunapuna, it’s not island-wide, I think that augurs well.”
Griffith also rejected the suggestion that the curfew would necessarily discourage potential investors, pointing out that many operate in countries with serious criminality.
“All the possible investors in Trinidad would be in countries that have criminality. Some just as bad as Trinidad or some worse than Trinidad.”
He argued that investors would assess the country’s circumstances in a broader context, considering whether conditions were improving or deteriorating rather than treating every security intervention as evidence of instability.
He also pointed to the end of the state of emergency and the decline in the murder rate as considerations that could influence perceptions positively.
Griffith acknowledged that the possibility of extending the curfew to other communities could cause apprehension. However, he stressed that the measure had not been extended beyond Maloney.
His position is that investors could accept a targeted security intervention while expecting the authorities to prevent it from becoming a wider restriction
“We hope that this doesn’t get worse, but I don’t see any negative, overall negative implications of the 9 pm-5 am curfew,” he added.
