bloodlsandy@gmail.com
The current pro vice-chancellor and campus principal of The University of the West Indies Five Islands Campus in Antigua and Barbuda, Professor C Justin Robinson, said that when the Mighty Sparrow died, the tributes rightly called him the Calypso King of the World. However, his passing affected him much more than he had expected.
“My reaction to the death made me wonder, but what struck me was perhaps I was mourning something larger than a man; however large the man, I was mourning a habit of mind.”
The Mighty Sparrow, born Slinger Francisco, died in New York on September 27.
“For part of the 20th century, Trinidad and Tobago (T&T) did something few societies manage. It held a national conversation about itself, every year, in song, in public, with the whole country listening. The T&T national conversation became the model across the English-speaking Caribbean, integrating the region in a manner few institutions could.
Education, Chauffeur Wanted, The Sinking Ship, Sea Water and Sand and Die with My Dignity, among many other songs, became metaphors and anthems across the region.
Robinson said Sparrow’s passing made him ask the question: what happened to that conversation? Beneath it lies the harder question: what happened to us as a people and as a region?
1980 as a convenient starting point
“The Doc, Eric Williams, was alive, larger than life, the oil boom was at its height, money was no problem and the official mood was that the country had arrived. Progress and modernity were the order of the day. Into that moment walked a humble man from Laventille with a small, sweet voice.
“That man was King Austin, with the classic Progress, written by Winsford ‘Joker’ Devine. The song asked a question few were asking: if this is progress, how long will it last? He sang of a land less bountiful than it had been, and of a price paid by nature and by people.
“The song won six encores on its first night in the tent, and he placed second in the Monarch final. King Austin’s song was an environmental scan no modern strategy consultant can match: ‘rivers run dry, how long will it last’. In three years, the boom had turned to bust, the question had answered itself, and the narrative shifted to ‘Money is No Problem, the Problem is No Money’.”
1984
“By 1984, the calypso diagnosis had moved from the national accounts to the front doors of ordinary citizens. Penguin won the crown with We Living in Jail, a song about burglar-proofing, about a people locking themselves behind iron in their own homes.
“The story goes that a newcomer to Trinidad that year later said that she knew no one in Caroni with burglar-proofing, so she took the song for mere cleverness. What she missed was the diagnostic power of calypso, with Penguin foreshadowing the current crime crisis long before any policymaker.
“On the same stage that night stood Johnny King, a retired policeman, with Nature’s Plan and Foul Play. Nature’s Plan, with its tacit acceptance that might is right and that it was just the way of the world—nature’s plan, as he called it—was a shocking calypso for me as someone nurtured in the Caribbean’s Black Power and revolutionary tradition.
“His words, ‘Destruction of the weak is nature’s plan, the humble and the weak must understand’, cut me to the core. I urge you to listen to any speech by Marco Rubio or Stephen Miller today and then listen to ‘Nature’s Plan’. Same tune to a much cruder beat,” Professor Robinson advised.
The narrative and public discourse across the Caribbean
“It was shaped by songs that asked us to look at how we lived and what we were becoming. The calypso tents and Calypso Monarch competitions were parliaments without Speakers, the Caribbean’s authentic version of London’s Speakers’ Corner in Hyde Park.
“Before today’s daily diet, or daily diatribe, of talk radio, before social media, our countries argued with themselves and each other in rhyme, and everyone could follow the argument. The argument was fierce, but it was wrapped in wit, and the wit kept it civil enough to keep it going,” he explained.
The 1990s
“The Washington Consensus took hold, capitalism went mad, and the market became king. We bought into the notion that the only worthwhile things were those from which local capitalists could profit or that consumers in the Global North were willing to pay for.
“As commercial priorities became the order of the day, the two halves of the music went their separate ways. Fuelled by capitalism, soca became an industry, and a successful one at that. The private money went into soca, and calypso, the reflective, argumentative, five-verse kind, was left to a shrinking tent audience and became deeply mired in political tribalism.”
The commercialisation of Carnival
“The calypso tent was turned into a niche product while sponsors poured money into fetes and road music. The market led to the Calypso Monarch competition being reduced to one song per finalist for a period of time.
“The diaspora market became all-important, and soca, as party music, was more appealing to that market than a calypso about local conditions. Political tribalism and changes in generational taste did the rest.”
Self-examination
“The reflective song has not died, but it is no longer at the centre of national and regional life. Our young people know the Soca Monarch and Road March, while few can tell you what last year’s Calypso Monarch was singing about.
“Alongside the undeniable benefits, the socio-economic cost of that adjustment has been high. Caribbean societies have lost a shared space for self-examination, but problems persist and we have simply stopped naming and debating them in public. The loss of reflective calypso, our authentic space for public debate and self-examination, is part of the crisis of modern Caribbean society.”
The final, painful detail
“When King Austin died in 2016, the then president, Anthony Carmona, recalled Progress and Who Is Guarding the Guards. He confessed his regret ‘that this great calypsonian had died in a kind of destitution that should shame the nation.’
“Perhaps that is the answer to ‘what happened to us’. We stopped valuing the people who told us the truth, and we stopped hearing the truth told in our own idiom.
“However, the reflective songs are still there. Progress is only a click away on YouTube, and the question it asks is still open. Maybe the best way to honour Sparrow is to start listening again and attending the tents.”
