For decades, Trinidad and Tobago has taken pride in producing lawyers capable of excelling at the highest levels of the Commonwealth legal system. Yet public records from 2011 to November 2026 reveal a striking contradiction. Successive governments, state enterprises and commissions of enquiry have repeatedly turned to London’s Bar to handle some of the nation’s most important matters, at an estimated cost of between 23 million and 33 million pounds sterling.
That figure represents only what can be documented through public disclosures, parliamentary records and court proceedings. The true cost is almost certainly higher, given the limited transparency surrounding international arbitrations and some state-enterprise litigation.
The practice has been most visible in commissions of enquiry. The Colman Enquiry into the collapse of CL Financial, Clico and the Hindu Credit Union generated millions of pounds sterling in fees for foreign commissioners, counsel and advisers. Other inquiries have similarly relied on British legal talent, albeit at varying levels of expense. State enterprises, including the Estate Management and Business Development Company and the National Gas Company, have also engaged London-based counsel in significant commercial disputes.
Nor is the trend fading. Over the past 18 months, the Office of the Attorney General has retained leading British barristers in matters ranging from State of Emergency litigation to procurement disputes and civil recovery proceedings.
Most recently, Attorney General John Jeremie retained Lord David Pannick, KC, to represent the State in the constitutional challenge to the Special Operations Act. Whatever the merits of the case, taxpayers are entitled to ask why overseas counsel was considered necessary and whether qualified local alternatives were seriously evaluated.
This question is particularly relevant in light of this week’s Privy Council ruling on the 2011 State of Emergency detentions. That matter featured some of Trinidad and Tobago’s most accomplished advocates, including former attorneys general Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj and Anand Ramlogan. The case served as a reminder that this country possesses a deep pool of legal talent capable of handling complex constitutional litigation.
There will always be circumstances in which external expertise is justified. Conflicts of interest, specialised technical issues or the need for clear independence may warrant looking beyond local counsel. But such decisions should not be automatic, nor should London be the default destination.
The Caribbean itself offers a strong alternative. Senior lawyers across Barbados, Jamaica, Guyana and the Eastern Caribbean share similar constitutional traditions, legal frameworks and jurisprudence. Their expertise is relevant, their independence can be assured and their fees are often far more competitive than those associated with leading London chambers.
The issue is not protectionism. The State must be free to secure the best representation available when circumstances require it. The issue is accountability. When tens of millions of pounds sterling in public funds are being spent on foreign legal services, citizens deserve clear explanations for those decisions.
The Ministry of the Attorney General and state boards should therefore publish an annual register identifying every foreign counsel retained, the purpose of each engagement, the fees paid and the reasons local or regional alternatives were not selected.
Transparency would not restrict government. It would simply allow taxpayers to determine whether these costly appointments are truly necessary and whether Trinidad and Tobago has sufficient confidence in the legal expertise it has spent decades cultivating.
