Trinidad and Tobago’s manufacturers must become more aggressive in pursuing regional trade and investment opportunities or risk losing ground to competitors in the Dominican Republic, where larger-scale production and a strong export strategy are giving businesses a competitive advantage.
Associated Brands Ltd chairman Nicholas Lok Jack and LabelHouse Group owner Richard Lewis are urging the private sector to take greater control of trade and investment, build stronger regional alliances and establish a greater presence in the Dominican Republic.
They warned that Caricom businesses cannot compete effectively while governments and private sector organisations remain divided over trade policy, fail to enforce existing agreements and allow longstanding barriers to remain unresolved.
The concerns emerged during a panel discussion last Wednesday at the launch of a study assessing the Caricom-Dominican Republic Free Trade Agreement at the Trinidad and Tobago Chamber of Industry and Commerce’s offices in Westmoorings.
The discussion highlighted the growing competitive pressure on regional manufacturers and the need for Caricom to make better use of an agreement that offers access to a market of approximately 11.7 million people.
Lok Jack pointed to an international snack manufacturer operating in the Dominican Republic whose products compete directly with Associated Brands in every market the Trinidad and Tobago company serves.
He argued that the Dominican Republic had developed an overarching export strategy, with trade agreements forming part of a wider effort to support international competitiveness.
“If you’re serious about export, you’re serious about competing globally. And that’s a fundamental tenet that we have to get over, I think,” Lok Jack said.
Understanding
the market
Lok Jack urged local businesses to look beyond the Dominican Republic’s headline economic indicators and understand the differences between its individual markets.
He cautioned against treating the country as one uniform market, pointing to the economic differences between Santo Domingo and other areas. Its geographical size also meant that travelling between locations could involve a 10-hour drive.
Businesses therefore needed to identify the particular customers and markets they intend to pursue.
Associated Brands has spent considerable time operating in the Dominican Republic, experiencing both losses and gains, he explained. The company continued to approach it as it did other markets, recognising that doing business internationally involved navigating different regulatory and commercial challenges.
He acknowledged concerns surrounding Law 173, which governs certain commercial agency and distributorship relationships in the Dominican Republic, but cautioned against allowing it to prevent otherwise viable business arrangements.
“It’s a pain point, but certainly not an incentive to terminate business,” he said.
Lok Jack recalled a Dell case in the early 2000s that he estimated had cost the company US$200 million.
He also pointed to the cost of meeting regulatory requirements in other jurisdictions. Last year, Associated Brands spent €500,000 retrofitting its factory to meet European Union disability-access requirements.
He argued that businesses should not expect overseas markets to be free of challenges.
“We have to embrace the Dominican Republic agreement and utilise it,” he said, urging private sector representatives to put boots on the ground, explore opportunities and develop a proper understanding of the market.
ANSA McAL Group chief legal and external affairs officer, Frances Bain-Cumberbatch, also identified the Dominican Republic as a significant commercial opportunity.
ANSA McAL already has a solar investment with a joint partner in the country and exports glass bottles there, providing a source of revenue. The group is also looking to advance chlorine exports to the market.
However, Bain-Cumberbatch cautioned that regional businesses could not expect to compete on price alone.
He noted that the Dominican Republic’s manufacturing scale, export incentives and supporting infrastructure made direct price competition difficult, particularly for T&T companies facing production and logistics costs.
Instead, businesses needed to identify their strengths in areas such as branding and quality.
“We have to lean into our strengths as Caricom businesses to see where we can differentiate ourselves in this vast market that is price sensitive,” she said.
She also raised concerns about the gap between trade policy, legislation and enforcement, questioning whether rules of origin were being properly verified and whether the actual sources of goods entering the region were being monitored.
Stronger enforcement and policy adjustments were necessary to ensure Caricom businesses benefited from the opportunities available under the agreement.
Private sector
must lead
Lewis was critical of the region’s approach to trade negotiations, arguing that the private sector had become too reactive and surrendered too much responsibility for trade and investment to governments.
He recalled the late 1990s, when businesses were actively consulted on proposed free trade agreements, including arrangements involving Chile and other countries.
However, he argued that private sector engagement had weakened considerably.
“The private sector in Caricom fell asleep and is still sleeping because all we do is come to the table when it’s one company or one sector that has problems,” Lewis said.
He called for a private sector task force bringing together manufacturers, importers, exporters and other business interests to develop a coordinated regional trade and investment agenda.
Lewis also pointed to the Ministry of Foreign and Caricom Affairs’ establishment of a commercial diplomacy division as an opportunity to strengthen collaboration between government and business.
He urged companies to work with the division and other agencies to ensure the country’s foreign policy advances commercial interests.
He cautioned against assuming that establishing manufacturing operations in the Dominican Republic would be an easy solution.
The country already has substantial domestic production capacity, with manufacturers operating at a scale many times larger than their Caribbean counterparts. Established business interests and ownership concentration also created challenges for new entrants.
For T&T, he warned, the consequences of losing manufacturing capacity would extend beyond individual companies.
“T&T is the one country in the Caribbean that if manufacturing fails, has no other option other than oil and gas,” Lewis said.
He also called for a broader relationship with Dominican businesses, moving beyond the buying and selling of goods towards investment, joint ventures and services.
Dominican investors should be encouraged to establish operations in T&T and use the country as a base to supply Caricom and international markets.
Treaty reform and implementation
Permanent Secretary in the Ministry of Foreign and Caricom Affairs, Randall Karim, pointed to export concentration as one of the study’s significant findings.
The Dominican Republic’s top ten exports accounted for less than 30 per cent of its exports to the relevant markets, while Caricom’s top ten exports to the Dominican Republic represented approximately 80 per cent.
The figures underscored the need for Caricom to diversify its exports and develop a wider range of products for the Dominican market.
Karim also identified the treatment of goods produced in special economic zones as an example of outdated regional policy undermining competitiveness.
Caricom rules currently restrict goods produced in special economic zones from qualifying for Community treatment. The restriction originated in concerns about goods passing through these zones rather than being manufactured there.
He argued that the rule needed to change to allow goods genuinely produced in special economic zones to qualify for duty-free treatment.
Karim also called for closer government and private sector coordination, with foreign policy being used more deliberately to advance trade and investment.
CEO of the Caricom Private Sector Organisation (CPSO) Dr Patrick Antoine outlined four priorities for the agreement’s mandatory review, which was expected to be scheduled at the end of November.
These include establishing a timeframe for addressing special economic zones, creating a private sector quick-consultation mechanism between Dominican Republic and Caricom customs authorities to resolve concerns over rules of origin, and addressing the longstanding difficulties surrounding Law 173.
A fourth priority involves discussions on existing agricultural concessions, particularly the agreement to reduce extra-regional imports of certain agricultural products by 25 per cent by 2025, with the arrangement extending over the subsequent five years.
Antoine argued that Caricom should explore exchanging concessions in areas where regional small and medium-sized businesses have concerns rather than allowing disagreements to undermine the wider trading relationship.
He also stressed that Caricom needed to address its own weaknesses before entering further discussions with the Dominican Republic.
Lewis reinforced the importance of implementation, arguing that Caricom had repeatedly discussed trade commitments without ensuring they were carried out.
He cited outstanding issues in the cement industry, where the failure to implement existing treaty provisions had prevented manufacturers from achieving more competitive costs and expanding exports.
He warned that regional obligations could not continue to be ignored without consequences.
Antoine challenged the suggestion that the agreement had simply worked better for the Dominican Republic, arguing that Caricom had failed to use it effectively and had not acted collectively to lobby for changes or enforce reciprocal trade provisions.
