JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, July 20, 2025

Prize money stifles creativity

by

20130113

Cre­ative­ly speak­ing, the worst thing to hap­pen to ca­lyp­so is gov­ern­ment-spon­sored Car­ni­val ca­lyp­so com­pe­ti­tions. Any time I make this state­ment, peo­ple ar­gue with me as though I have said some­thing sac­ri­le­gious, oxy­moron­ic as that seems. But it's true, and I have known this ever since I read a book en­ti­tled Chang­ing the World: A Frame­work for the Study of Cre­ativ­i­ty writ­ten by David Hen­ry Feld­man, Mi­haly Csik­szent­mi­ha­lyi and Howard Gard­ner.

For the au­thors, cre­ativ­i­ty meant "the achieve­ment of some­thing re­mark­able and new, some­thing which trans­forms and changes a field of en­deav­our in a sig­nif­i­cant way." They con­clud­ed that true cre­ativ­i­ty stems from in­trin­sic mo­ti­va­tion–the need to pro­duce for its own sake rather than some ex­ter­nal re­ward, is as­so­ci­at­ed more with cre­ative in­di­vid­u­als, and that in­tel­li­gence and ed­u­ca­tion were on­ly "mod­est­ly" re­lat­ed to re­al cre­ativ­i­ty.

Psy­chol­o­gists study­ing cre­ativ­i­ty re­alised that cer­tain so­cial and his­tor­i­cal con­di­tions sup­port an en­vi­ron­ment for cre­ativ­i­ty. In­jus­tice, for ex­am­ple, in­spires cre­ativ­i­ty. That is how we get the Ma­hat­ma Gand­his, Mar­tin Luther Kings, Vic­tor Hu­gos and the Charles Dick­ens­es of this world. The au­thors al­so note the feel­ing among most cre­ative peo­ple that they are mar­gin­alised from so­ci­ety.

They see them­selves on the pe­riph­ery of so­ci­ety–on the out­side look­ing in–and they want to ef­fect some type of change. Feel­ings of mar­gin­al­i­ty re­sult in cre­ative peo­ple want­i­ng to prove them­selves. They want so­ci­ety to know they have worth and their ideas have worth. Cre­ativ­i­ty can­not take place if an in­di­vid­ual is in har­mo­ny with his en­vi­ron­ment.

There must be dis­cord some­where in one of three realms: the fam­i­ly, the so­ci­ety, or the cul­ture where the so­ci­ety re­flects so­cial net­works and the cul­ture rep­re­sents be­lief sys­tems. A brief ex­am­i­na­tion of mile­stones in ca­lyp­so mu­sic seem to sup­port this the­o­ry of dishar­mo­ny in one of three realms as well as the no­tion that true cre­ativ­i­ty can on­ly come from peo­ple who have an in­ner de­sire to cre­ate change.

Piles of mon­ey of­fered as prizes can­not in­spire cre­ativ­i­ty. In­stead, prize mon­ey seems to do the op­po­site. It sup­ports mun­dane mu­sic that falls with­in a cer­tain ac­cept­able realm so that it is el­i­gi­ble to win those prizes. When I think about how this re­search on cre­ativ­i­ty re­lates to ca­lyp­so, I think of these ca­lyp­so­ni­ans:

1. The Mighty Spar­row. Spar­row's up­tem­po ca­lyp­soes ush­ered in the mod­ern age of ca­lyp­so as well as the mod­ern age of ca­lyp­so per­for­mance with his Jean and Di­nah. His wild stage per­sona chal­lenged the mores of so­ci­ety, the British mod­el of prop­er be­hav­iour. Spar­row was a rebel mu­si­cal­ly and so­cial­ly who qual­i­fies as a ground-break­ing, cre­ative per­former. Most of Spar­row's ca­reer has been ded­i­cat­ed to fight­ing the sta­tus quo.

His an­ti-colo­nial stand evolved in­to his an­ti-Gov­ern­ment stand which was voiced through his mu­sic. When Spar­row fought for bet­ter prize mon­ey for ca­lyp­so­ni­ans, it was a no­ble cause.

2. Lord Shorty. Twice in his ca­reer, Lord Shorty re-de­fined ca­lyp­so mu­sic. He crossed cul­tur­al and so­cial bound­aries by blend­ing In­di­an and African rhythms with Om Shan­ti Om, and he ush­ered in the so­ca age along with Mae­stro and Shad­ow.

Lat­er in his ca­reer, as Ras Shorty I, he fused re­li­gion with so­ca to cre­ate Jah­moo mu­sic with clas­sics like Watch Out My Chil­dren.

3. Shad­ow. Shad­ow's scin­til­lat­ing bass lines, first de­fined by his Bass­man, helped to de­fine the dri­ve and rhythm of so­ca mu­sic in its in­fant stages.

No ca­lyp­son­ian was ever so un­der-ap­pre­ci­at­ed for his orig­i­nal con­tri­bu­tion to mu­sic. Ca­lyp­so judges re­fused to give him the ca­lyp­so monarch crown that he de­served in his ear­ly ca­reer. Shad­ow is a vivid ex­am­ple of a tal­ent­ed singer who chal­lenged what was mu­si­cal­ly ac­cept­able. For most of his ca­reer, Shad­ow was a mu­si­cal rebel on the out­side look­ing in.

4. Lord Kitch­en­er. In many ways, Kitch­en­er har­nessed the cre­ative en­er­gy of pan and so­ci­ety's bad boys to make a mu­si­cal state­ment that earned him a place as the all-time road march king.

5. Blue Boy. Austin Lyons was an­oth­er per­former on the pe­riph­ery of so­ci­ety who bat­tled his way to the top, mu­si­cal­ly speak­ing, by syn­the­sis­ing and pop­u­lar­is­ing Bap­tist rhythms used through­out ca­lyp­so's his­to­ry. As an un­known fish­er­man from Point Fortin, Blue Boy tried and failed to get in­to a ca­lyp­so tent un­til Shad­ow recog­nised his tal­ent and took him in­to the Mas­ter's Den in 1980 to sing So­ca Bap­tist. He rev­o­lu­tioned so­ca once again a decade lat­er with Get Some­thing and Wave.

6. David Rud­der blurred Car­ni­val cul­tur­al bound­aries by step­ping out of the fete zone and en­ter­ing the tra­di­tion­al ca­lyp­so realm with his as His Bap­tist-in­fused Bahia Gyul and trib­ute to the late Rudolph Charles in 1986. Don't get me wrong, I'm not ad­vo­cat­ing the sing-for-a-bot­tle-of-rum days of ca­lyp­so. Ca­lyp­so­ni­ans should be well-paid. The prob­lem comes when the point of mu­sic is win­ning a con­test.

Yes, ca­lyp­so com­pe­ti­tion is a na­tion­al tra­di­tion, but it just might have kept ca­lyp­so mu­sic from reach­ing the heights of oth­er mu­sic like reg­gae. Worse yet is hav­ing a ca­lyp­so con­test spon­sored by the Gov­ern­ment. This lim­its cre­ativ­i­ty.

�2 Next week: Three so­ca singers who could be on the verge of re­al cre­ativ­i­ty.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored