The Government has been very keen to trumpet, on the occasion of World Press Freedom Day, its abolition of Section 9 of the libel and defamation law.This is touted as a commitment to press freedom in Trinidad and Tobago and the amendment itself, an important indicator of official endorsement of that principle.
Both Allison Bethel-McKenzie, director of the International Press Institute, and president of the Association of Caribbean Media Workers Wesley Gibbings were present to lend weight to the import of the announcement.It was just a year ago that Ms Bethel-McKenzie was in T&T for the 60th International Press Institute (IPI) World Congress and Conference held in June 2012 at the Hyatt Regency.
The IPI was then expressing concern about the adversarial position that the Government had fomented with media practitioners. That was also a year in which the nation managed to drop a whopping 20 places on the World Press Freedom Index and T&T described as a country "scarred by a case of government spying on journalists."By the time of the IPI Congress in 2012, the Government was eager to demonstrate just how committed it was to principles of press freedom and the hounds of intimidation were muzzled.
Ms Bethel-McKenzie made it her business to return to T&T for World Press Freedom Day last week and the Government made sure to deliver on its promise to the IPI to address its libel laws.
Section 9 of the Libel and Defamation Act levied criminal charges and prosecution for malicious publication of defamatory libel. Over the 167 years that the act has been on T&T law books, it has never been invoked, but its removal is an overdue acknowledgement by the Government of the chilling effect that unnecessary legislation can have on the reporting process. Under Section 8, citizens can still seek redress for the knowing and malicious publication of libellous information.
The removal of Section 9 doesn't exempt journalists, or anyone taking on the role of reporter or commentator in nontraditional media, from prosecution if it can be proven that they have engaged in knowing and deliberate defamation.Kiran Maharaj, president of the T&T Publishers and Broadcasters Association, noted that the decision to amend the law "is proof we can get it done."
The successful removal of Section 9 shouldn't distract media managers and practitioners from the need to keep pressing the Government on amendments that are needed for a Data Protection Act that doesn't limit journalistic freedoms and the need for whistle-blower legislation to protect both those willing to inform and those with whom that information is shared.
Both are required to ensure the practical preservation of the freedom of the press that Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar so enthusiastically trumpeted on World Press Freedom Day as an appealing and powerful characteristic of T&T society.
A free press is not measured by the number of media houses working in this country, but by the degree to which reporters are able to find the truth of their stories unimpeded by laws and legal screens which favour a lack of accountability and transparency in public office and private enterprise.
