High Court judge Peter Rajkumar has ruled that Investment Note Certificates (INCs) which were issued by cash-strapped Clico Investment Bank (CIB) are deposits and not investments. Rajkumar made the ruling yesterday while giving his oral judgment over a lawsuit brought by National Insurance Board (NIB) against CIB in a bid to recover almost $700 million, deposited in the bank. The classification of the INCs as deposits was crucial to NIB's claim before Rajkumar, presiding in the Port-of-Spain High Court. NIB was seeking this classification of the INC as part of its bid to block wind-up proceedings of the now state-operated institution currently before High Court judge Ronnie Boodoosingh. These wind-up proceedings are expected to continue in the Port-of-Spain High Court in October.
During the trial of the matter in July, this year, NIB's attorney, Senior Counsel Deborah Peake, told the court that the total sum held in CIB was made through 15 multi-million dollar deposits during the period September 2008 to January 2009. Senior Counsel Reginald Armour who represented CIB in the matter thanked Rajkumar for his patience during the matter which he described as difficult. Delivering his judgment, Rajkumar ordered that interest be paid on the sums held in CIB for the period of maturity to the judgment at a rate of six per cent. Rajkumar dismissed submissions by Armour that an order under his judgment might be contrary to the separation of powers between Parliament and the judiciary.
Rajkumar said the six per cent rate was within his judicial discretion. Rajkumar noted that the interest rate could be adjusted by negotiation or agreement by both parties. Rajkumar said his full written judgment for the matter would be forthcoming.
INCs are short-term "investments" that attract investors with higher than average market rate returns.
The T&T Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) which regulates securities and other financial instruments in T&T was also listed as a party in the matter. During the week-long trial, Inspector of Financial Institutions and CIB interim manager Carl Hiralal was the subject of intense cross-examination from Peake. Hiralal was quizzed about his understanding of the CIB's INC portfolio and instances where securities were not issued for bank's INCs although promised in its one-page INC certificate. Deputy inspector of financial institutions Wendy Ho Sing, also testified during the trial. Before the merchant bank's collapse in 2009, it held more than $1.9 billion in INCs for almost 100 investors. NIB's legal team included attorney Kerwyn Garcia while the SEC was represented by Terrence Bharath.
