JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Judge knocks down Central Bank Act again

by

20140114

For the sec­ond time in less than two months, a High Court judge has ruled that the Cen­tral Bank Amend­ment Act of 2011, which pro­tects the cash-strapped CL Fi­nan­cial and its sub­sidiaries from le­gal ac­tion, is un­con­sti­tu­tion­al and void.In a 62-page judg­ment de­liv­ered in the Port-of-Spain High Court yes­ter­day, Jus­tice Ricky Rahim ruled that the leg­is­la­tion, which was passed two years af­ter Gov­ern­ment's takeover of the trou­bled fi­nan­cial in­sti­tu­tion in 2009, breached the sep­a­ra­tion of pow­ers.

Rahim said the leg­is­la­tion was in breach of the fun­da­men­tal con­sti­tu­tion­al prin­ci­ple as it gives the Cen­tral Bank the ju­di­cial func­tion of stay­ing le­gal pro­ceed­ings, by pre­vent­ing claims be­ing filed against the com­pa­nies by its pol­i­cy­hold­ers and cred­i­tors, while the com­pa­nies re­main un­der the con­trol of the bank.

"The court has the pow­er and the du­ty to re­view the ac­tions of the leg­is­la­ture and ex­ec­u­tive to de­ter­mine whether they are in con­for­mi­ty with the Con­sti­tu­tion. In or­der to do so, the court must be able to ex­er­cise its pow­er free from in­flu­ence from the leg­is­la­ture and the ex­ec­u­tive," Rahim said.

The judg­ment stems from a case brought by two Cli­co in­sur­ance agents–My­ron Rud­der and Bar­bara Kan­hai–who were at­tempt­ing to re­coup the com­mis­sions and bonus­es owed to them by the com­pa­ny, which amount­ed to al­most $1.9 mil­lion.

On No­vem­ber 28, Rahim's col­league Jus­tice Ron­nie Boodoos­ingh de­liv­ered a sim­i­lar judg­ment in a law­suit brought against Cli­co by Stone Street Cap­i­tal, the pri­vate com­pa­ny of for­mer CL Fi­nan­cial ex­ec­u­tive An­dre Mon­teil.While, like Rahim, Boodoos­ingh ruled the leg­is­la­tion was un­con­sti­tu­tion­al, he went a step fur­ther to strike it out in its en­tire­ty, open­ing the door for lit­i­gants to file law­suits to re­cov­er monies lost as a re­sult of the col­lapse of the CL Fi­nan­cial con­glom­er­ate. Boodoos­ingh's judg­ment is be­ing ap­pealed.

In his judg­ment, Rahim said he dis­agreed with the scope of Boodoos­ingh's judg­ment and said his rul­ing on the un­con­sti­tu­tion­al­i­ty of the act would on­ly ap­ply to in­di­vid­u­als who filed law­suits be­fore the leg­is­la­tion was passed in Sep­tem­ber 2011.

"The court is there­fore of the view that once a claim has been in­sti­tut­ed, a stay on that claim or in re­spect of the ex­e­cu­tion of judg­ment of that claim can on­ly be grant­ed by the court and any at­tempt by the leg­is­la­ture to aver un­to it­self such pow­er breach­es the doc­trine of the sep­a­ra­tion of pow­ers," Rahim said.Be­cause Rud­der and Kan­hai filed their law­suits in 2012, Rahim ruled that they would not stand to ben­e­fit from his con­sti­tu­tion­al rul­ing.

In their law­suit, the agents both claimed that in ad­di­tion to breach­ing the sep­a­ra­tion of pow­ers, the amend­ment al­so blocked their rights to ac­cess to the court.In re­sponse, the State's le­gal team re­lied on an af­fi­davit from for­mer Fi­nance Min­is­ter Win­ston Dook­er­an, who said: "The amend­ment did not de­prive cit­i­zens of their rights to ac­cess the ju­di­cial process, but sim­ply sus­pend­ed it un­til the stay is lift­ed."

The lawyers claimed at the time the leg­is­la­tion was passed there was a re­al­is­tic dan­ger of the col­lapse of the en­tire fi­nan­cial sys­tem and the ob­jec­tive of the act was to "main­tain the in­tegri­ty and sta­bil­i­ty of the fi­nan­cial sys­tem of T&T and to pro­tect those whose in­ter­est are af­fect­ed by it."The agents al­so al­leged that the leg­is­la­tion con­tra­vened their con­sti­tu­tion­al rights to prop­er­ty, equal­i­ty be­fore the law, a fair hear­ing and pro­ce­dur­al pro­vi­sions. Rahim re­ject­ed these claims.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored

Today's
Guardian

Publications

A model in a costume from The Lost Tribe’s 2026 presentation Island Circus

A model in a costume from The Lost Tribe’s 2026 presentation Island Circus

KERWIN PIERRE

A model in a costume from The Lost Tribe’s 2026 presentation Island Circus

A model in a costume from The Lost Tribe’s 2026 presentation Island Circus

KERWIN PIERRE

Ringmasters of the Road: Crowds flock to Tribe’s circus-themed band launch

22 hours ago
Students, principal and staff of St David’s RC Primary, along with the UWTT and Scotiabank Foundation teams at the handover of steelpans at the school.

Students, principal and staff of St David’s RC Primary, along with the UWTT and Scotiabank Foundation teams at the handover of steelpans at the school.

Students, principal and staff of St David’s RC Primary, along with the UWTT and Scotiabank Foundation teams at the handover of steelpans at the school.

Students, principal and staff of St David’s RC Primary, along with the UWTT and Scotiabank Foundation teams at the handover of steelpans at the school.

Scotiabank Foundation, United Way donate steelpans

22 hours ago
The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

The Executive of the National Parang Association 2025-27. Back row, from left: Kervin Preudhomme, assistant secretary; Shaquille Headley, committee member; Cheriese Pierre, committee member; Lisa Lee, trustee; Joanne Briggs, PRO; Yarelis Touissant, committee member; William Calliste, trustee. Front row, from left: Jenais Carter, secretary; Alicia Jaggasar, president; Henrietta Carter, vice president; Joseph Bertrand, youth officer. Missing: Kerrylee Chee Chow, treasurer; Chevone Pierre, committee member.

Jaggasar returns as National Parang president

Yesterday
Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Charles Town junior drummers and dancers take to the stage

Jamaican Maroons celebrate, question land rights

Yesterday