JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Tuesday, July 22, 2025

Medics want lawyers present

by

20140425

Two doc­tors in­volved in the death of ba­by Sime­on are re­luc­tant to come for­ward be­fore the in­ves­tiga­tive team with­out their at­tor­neys be­ing present.The team for­mer­ly be­gan the probe on Thurs­day.This was re­vealed by re­tired Ap­peal Court judge Mustapha Ibrahim who is a mem­ber of the team.Ibrahim was speak­ing at a press con­fer­ence held a the of­fice of the At­tor­ney Gen­er­al at Ca­bil­do Cham­bers, Port-of-Spain yes­ter­day.

Al­so present were con­sul­tant ob­ste­tri­cian/gy­nae­col­o­gist of the Uni­ver­si­ty Col­lege of Lon­don Hos­pi­tals Dr Melanie Clare Davies and Dr Petronel­la Man­ning-Al­leyne, neona­tol­o­gist and for­mer head of the Neona­tal Unit at the Port-of-Spain Gen­er­al Hos­pi­tal who are al­so mem­bers of the team.Ba­by Sime­on bled to death af­ter his head was slashed from ear to ear as his moth­er Quel­ly Ann Cot­tle was un­der­go­ing a Cae­sar­i­an-sec­tion at the Er­ic Williams Med­ical Sci­ences Com­plex, Mt Hope on Car­ni­val Sat­ur­day.

Ibrahim, Davies and Man­ning-Al­leyne were for­mer­ly in­tro­duced to mem­bers of the me­dia by At­tor­ney Gen­er­al Anand Ram­lo­gan.Ibrahim was re­spond­ing to a ques­tion on whether doc­tors, in par­tic­u­lar those as­signed to the Fac­ul­ty of Med­ical Sci­ences of the Uni­ver­si­ty of the West In­dies were co­op­er­at­ing in the probe.He said all the oth­er doc­tors have com­plied and came for­ward will­ing­ly to be ques­tioned by the team.

On a time frame of when the probe is ex­pect­ed to be com­plet­ed Ibrahim said this was dif­fi­cult to say as a large num­ber of wit­ness­es were ex­pect­ed to be called."We have to ex­am­ine them oral­ly. We have to con­sid­er what our du­ties of care are and what are the du­ties of care which ex­ist in T&T and whether they are suf­fi­cient or whether they should be im­proved," Ibrahim said.He said Davies would be leav­ing T&T short­ly to at­tend an in­ter­na­tion­al con­fer­ence.

Al­though there was these con­straints the probe would be com­plet­ed with­in the short­est pos­si­ble time.Re­gard­ing neg­li­gence, Ibrahim said this was a civ­il claim which was out­side the re­mit of the team.He said if there was ev­i­dence that crim­i­nal charges ought to be laid then that would be the case."But we have not yet com­plet­ed the in­quiry so we can't give any opin­ion at this point in time as to the facts we have be­fore us if we are sure that crim­i­nal charges or civ­il charges or a breech of du­ty have oc­curred.

"We have to look at all the ev­i­dence, weigh the ev­i­dence very care­ful­ly and them make up our minds with re­spect to rec­om­men­da­tions," Ibrahim said.He said the AG told the team to present a com­pre­hen­sive re­port deal­ing with all the mat­ters and cir­cum­stances in­clud­ing whether du­ties of care were bro­ken on the day ba­by Sime­on died.De­scrib­ing the mat­ter as a nov­el case Ibrahim said the team had to be very care­ful as to how it pro­ceed­ed.

One of the is­sues which would be ex­am­ined ex­ten­sive­ly was how to im­prove the neona­tal sys­tem.Ram­lo­gan said be­cause the med­ical pro­fes­sion was so close knit there was a great re­luc­tance on the part of doc­tors to tes­ti­fy against their col­leagues.He said T&T would be look­ing to im­ple­ment a med­ical com­plaints coun­cil as such was the case in Eng­land.

Moth­er in­ter­viewed

Con­tact­ed yes­ter­day Cot­tle said she ap­peared be­fore the team on Thurs­day and was asked to give a ball by ball ac­count of what tran­spired on the day ba­by Sime­on died.Say­ing it was dif­fi­cult Cot­tle said she cried a bit but kept her com­po­sure."They in­ter­viewed me yes­ter­day (Thurs­day) and it went fair­ly ok. But hon­est­ly speak­ing I have lit­tle con­fi­dence would get some jus­tice. I am very scep­ti­cal of what is go­ing on," Cot­tle said.

She said she told the team what was need­ed were se­vere penal­ties for doc­tors who were found cul­pa­ble as too many in­no­cent lives were be­ing lost.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored