The Office of the Attorney General says a ruling by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council has vindicated former prime minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar’s decision to declare a State of Emergency in August 2011.
In a statement following Tuesday’s judgment, the office welcomed the dismissal of appeals by Dominic Pitilal, Earl Elie and Ashmeed Mohammed, who had challenged the constitutionality of the emergency declaration and the regulations introduced during that period.
The Attorney General’s Office said the emergency was declared in response to an unprecedented escalation in murders, serious violence and lawlessness, including a plot to assassinate the then prime minister.
It said Persad-Bissessar had acted to protect public safety and restore law and order.
The statement said the Privy Council recognised the severity of the circumstances, noting that the evidence pointed to “a threat to the life of the nation in a very literal way”.
The office said the ruling also had important implications for the more recent States of Emergency declared by the Government in July 2025 and March 2026, as the circumstances were similar and the regulations were materially the same as those enacted in 2011.
It said the judgment reaffirmed that determining whether a public emergency exists is primarily a decision for the executive, with Parliament’s approval, and that courts should give considerable weight to assessments made by the Government and senior security officials.
The Attorney General’s Office also argued that elected officials must be able to act on intelligence that cannot always be made public or disclosed in Parliament when responding to threats to national security.
It said the judgment recognised the responsibility placed on elected officials to use the powers granted under the Constitution to protect public safety and democracy.
The Government pledged to continue supporting actions taken by the security forces to stabilise the country and protect citizens.
However, while the Privy Council upheld the constitutionality of the 2011 emergency declaration and regulations, it also ruled in favour of Elie and Pitilal on their complaints about being denied access to legal representation, restoring compensation of $50,000 each.
