Political analyst Dr Winford James believes Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley acted fairly in his approach to calls by the Law Association of T&T (LATT) for the impeachment of Chief Justice Ivor Archie.
James told Guardian Media yesterday that in seeking advice from a Queen’s Counsel not based in Trinidad and Tobago, Rowley did “the proper thing.”
Asked whether he agrees with Rowley’s statement that the issue of Archie’s impeachment had become a political charade, James said the public must accept that Rowley is a politician and his statements will be politically motivated.
Speaking during a press conference on Tuesday, Rowley told the media that the LATT’s decision to seek legal review of his decision not to invoke Section 137 of the Constitution against Archie will only result in millions of dollars in costs to taxpayers, since he was not going to be paying the legal bill from his own pocket.
Yesterday, James posed his own query, asking, “Let’s suppose the High Court rules the advice the PM received was insufficient, what then?”
He said while the LATT may disagree with Rowley’s decision not to invoke Section 137 proceedings against Archie, they must also take into account that he is the only officeholder authorised to make such a decision.
“It is not simply the expense to the public. The question is: if I have a discretion in law, you can disagree but you can’t take away the discretion,” he said.
However, James said he believes it is wrong that taxpayers will have to bear the costs of this lawsuit.
Political scientist Dr Bishnu Ragoonath, on the other hand, said he wants to see how far the lawsuit will reach.
Ragoonath said there was some degree of interest to see how much power the Prime Minister wields, especially since the court recently ruled against British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s decision to suspend Parliament.
“If the Privy Council could rule in England as to the powers the executive has, it could also have impacts for us here in the Caribbean,” Ragoonath said.
He said while he accepts that the lawsuit will cost taxpayers, the issues surrounding CJ Archie need to be clarified.
