Tobago Correspondent
Relatives of Angelica Jogie are suing for almost $3 million following her tragic death in Tobago on April 8.
The former San Fernando TML student was struck and killed by a jet ski while bathing at Pigeon Point beach.
The claim, which was filed on Wednesday, alleged negligence on behalf of jet ski operator Ashworth Burnett, the Tobago House of Assembly (THA) and Pigeon Point Heritage Park.
The matter will be heard by Justice Sherlanne Pierre, who earlier this year granted an injunction to the THA after it filed a lawsuit complaining about reckless jet-ski operations continuing at the beach after her death.
In the 40-page lawsuit, the medical records of Angelica’s parents, Arnold and Salisha Narine-Jogie, were disclosed, revealing they have been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Other psychological effects on both parents include depression, heightened anxiety, persistent guilt, sleep disturbance, impaired concentration and a phobia of the ocean and similar environments.
Angelica’s sister, Angelina, is also named in the lawsuit, revealing she suffers from trauma associated with recollections of the accident and the aftermath, profound sadness and longing for her sister.
The Jogie family is being represented by Freedom Law Chambers, headed by Anand Ramlogan, SC.
Ramlogan confirmed a breakdown of the legal claim as follows: Salisha Narine-Jogie ($650,000), Arnold Jogie ($550,000), Angelina Jogie ($300,000), estate of Angelica Jogie ($300,00), aggravated and exemplary damages ($200,000) and special damages/proven loss of earnings ($887,000).
On aggravated damages, the lawsuit noted statements by THA officials that the tragedy was preventable and there was a need for “better safety measures” to protect bathers.
However, the THA’s refusal to accept liability, attorneys said, has caused the Jogie family “further distress, frustration and feelings of helplessness.”
Responding to the lawsuit, Chief Secretary Farley Augustine insisted that the THA has done its due diligence with respect to safety in the marine spaces.
In a September media release, the THA said Burnett was wholly responsible for the fatal accident.
Asked about recent measures to enhance safety after Jogie’s death, including revising the Tobago Marine Parks Bill and installing oil booms and buoys, Augustine said, “Let me correct you, the THA has been taking steps, meaning it is continuous. The THA took steps prior to this incident—meaning past tense; the THA took steps while this incident occurred; the THA took steps post this incident.”
Augustine added he was restrained from commenting further as the matter was before the court.
However, he assured the THA’s lawyers are prepared to defend its position.
But Ramlogan said the frequency of marine tragedies this year exposes a gap in regulations that must be addressed.
Ramlogan is also representing the families of the six people who died on November 8 during a horrific boat accident in Chaguaramas.
He is also seeking the interests of nine people, including foreign nationals, who were badly injured during another head-on collision of boats at Pigeon Point in September.
He recalled a 2007 accident—also at Pigeon Point—in which a teenager was paralysed and his Spanish girlfriend maimed after they were struck by a pirogue. The THA was successfully sued by the victims for that incident.
Ramlogan argued that authorities should have recognised a deficiency in marine regulations and intervened to avoid further casualties.
He said, “Such tragedies remain a blot on the legal system and conscience of our nation. No one was arrested and no criminal charges have been laid to date as a result of that incident.
“The culprits continue to escape with impunity and continue to enjoy their lives while the victims of their reckless and dangerous conduct are forced to live with the life-threatening consequences of their actions.”
While acknowledging Burnett is currently charged with manslaughter over Angelica’s death, Ramlogan noted the trial has yet to begin. He appealed for the matter to be expedited.
On the deaths of the six people in Chaguaramas, the former attorney general called on the police commissioner to prioritise the investigation by assigning a special team to probe the matter within a specific timeframe.
“The nation is in shock and disbelief, and an anxious, angry and frustrated public stands together with the grieving families, waiting to exhale. The truth must be told, and no one must be above the law.”
