Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
The Court of Appeal has adjusted the sentences imposed on a man convicted of attempting to bring US$138,015 in concealed cash into the country in 2010.
Appellate judges Geoffrey Henderson and Eleanor Donaldson-Honeywell made the decision late last week while determining an appeal brought by Customs and Excise Officer Michael Murphy against Jesse Orlando Vanterpool.
According to the evidence, Vanterpool was arrested on December 28, 2010, after arriving on a flight from the British Virgin Islands via Antigua.
Vanterpool submitted an Immigration/Customs Declaration form stating that he did not have more than US$5,000 to declare. A search of his suitcase uncovered a large quantity of cash concealed in its inner lining.
He was charged under the Customs Act with making a false declaration and attempting to deceive Customs officials by concealing the cash.
Vanterpool pleaded guilty to making the false declaration but denied the second charge. He was later found guilty of that offence after a trial before a magistrate.
The magistrate imposed a $125,000 fine for the false declaration, the maximum penalty under the legislation. She reprimanded and discharged Vanterpool for the second offence.
Murphy appealed the sentence for the second offence, while Vanterpool challenged the severity of the fine for making the false declaration.
In determining the appeal, Justice Henderson found that the magistrate was wrong to impose the maximum sentence after Vanterpool pleaded guilty.
“The Magistrate’s imposition without reasons, of the maximum possible sentence on the Defendant and her failure to explain why she deviated from the practice of giving a discount for his guilty plea, was in these circumstances plainly wrong,” he said.
On the second offence, Justice Henderson noted that the sentence under Section 71(1)(b) of the Summary Courts Act could not be applied, given the serious nature of the offence and the severe penalties prescribed by Parliament.
“In my judgment, neither was there anything advanced on behalf of the Defendant at his plea in mitigation nor was anything said by the magistrate in her decision that is capable of supporting the conclusion that the Magistrate properly exercised her discretion when she applied Section 71(1)(b),” he said.
Justice Henderson imposed a nominal fine of $840 for the false declaration and a $12,000 fine for the second offence. He also ordered that the seized cash be forfeited to the State.
Murphy was represented by Shirley Sheppard, while Joseph Sookoo and Kevin Chan represented Vanterpool.
