Chief Justice Ivor Archie has refused to reverse his decision to transfer High Court Judge Carol Gobin to head the Judiciary’s new Family Court in Tobago.
Archie communicated the decision to Gobin yesterday, in a lengthy letter which was sent in response to correspondence sent to him and all other judges in the Judiciary, by Gobin, last week.
In the letter, Archie sought to justify his decision and state why it should stand.
“I have perused and considered the full list of judges in the civil jurisdiction who may be assigned to the Family Court and your background of strong family practice at the Bar places you in the position of being an eminently suitable judge to start the family court in Tobago,” Archie said.
“For obvious reasons including the present focus on the ongoing changes in criminal procedure, it was not prudent for me to select a Criminal Court judge,” he added.
Archie dismissed Gobin’s claims on the impact of the transfer on her family life including on her husband, who she claimed needed medical treatment and aftercare at their home.
Archie said she would be provided with suitable accommodation and her husband was free to join her.
“Happily, unlike some of your colleagues, you have no minor children whose schooling and social connections would be disrupted by a move to Tobago, at least so far as I am aware,” he said.
Archie also questioned Gobin’s claim over the need for consultation before effecting the transfer as he stated that he was unaware of any “settled or unvarying practice” of such.
“As a High Court Judge I was often assigned without prior consultation and understood that my duty to the Judiciary, which I accepted on appointment, was to work wherever I was assigned,” Archie said.
“I am aware that any particular assignment is often not necessarily one that a judge would prefer for personal reasons but the Chief Justice has a duty to assign judges for the most efficient discharge of the work of the Judiciary and I have genuinely done so,” he added.
In the letter, Archie directly addressed Gobin’s claims that his decision was based on her criticism of him in the past.
“ I assure you that I take my responsibility seriously and honestly. In doing my work, including assigning judges, I do not take into account your view of me. As a matter of fact, it does not trouble me at all,” Archie said.
Archie also claimed that he anticipated Gobin’s hesitant response but claimed that he could not let it dissuade him from making a decision in the best interest of the Judiciary.
“For this reason, I too would have preferred to avoid any distastefulness which may have been occasioned by my having to choose you for this assignment. However, my duty comes first and despite the possibility of attracting your ire, I did my duty fairly without bias, fear or favour, affection or ill-will,” Archie said.
Archie claimed that he grudgingly forwarded his response to all other judges in the Judiciary as that has been Gobin’s practice when discussing issues within the organisation including her proposed transfer.
“I wish to put on record that I do not like this method of communicating and I would like it to end. It is not good for the organisation,” Archie said.
He claimed that Gobin’s letter, which reported on, was met with negative reviews from Tobagonians.
“Tobagonian stakeholders were disappointed to hear that you consider the opportunity to spearhead this important initiative to be a “sanction”,” he said.
Since the misconduct allegations were levelled against Archie in October 2017, Gobin has repeatedly advocated for Archie to meet with her and her colleagues to clear the air on the issues. However, he has repeatedly declined the requests which are usually made in email threads sent to all judges.
In March, Gobin raised concerns over a decision taken to appoint a former law enforcement officer, who is being investigated in an alleged plot to assassinate a former friend of Archie, to a senior position within the Judiciary.
Archie’s decision to transfer Gobin came days after Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley announced that he would not follow the Law Association’s advice to institute impeachment proceedings to investigate the claims against Archie.
