JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Sunday, July 6, 2025

Bail hiccup keeps Marlene in custody

by

Shaliza Hassanali
2153 days ago
20190813
Marlene McDonald

Marlene McDonald

Port-of-Spain South MP Mar­lene Mc­Don­ald re­mained un­der po­lice guard on Tues­day at the St Clair Med­ical Cen­tre for a sec­ond day as she was un­able to post her $2 mil­lion bail bond on sev­en crim­i­nal charges.

Her at­tor­ney, Pamela El­der SC, de­scribed as “slow, te­dious and an­ti­quat­ed.”

Mc­Don­ald’s com­plained of feel­ing un­well on Mon­day hours af­ter be­ing charged with cor­rup­tion-re­lat­ed of­fences and did not ap­pear in court along­side her com­pan­ion and three oth­er men charged with sim­i­lar of­fences.

Mc­Don­ald was fired for a third time as a gov­ern­ment min­is­ter af­ter she was charged and sacked of her po­si­tion as deputy po­lit­i­cal leader of the PNM yes­ter­day.

El­der in a tele­phone in­ter­view with Guardian Me­dia re­fused to dis­close de­tails of Mc­Don­ald’s health con­di­tion or when she would be dis­charged from hos­pi­tal

“I am not com­ment­ing on Ms Mc­Don­ald’s health at all.”

Hav­ing vis­it­ed Mc­Don­ald for a few min­utes at the pri­vate hos­pi­tal where she con­tin­ues to be un­der po­lice cus­tody, El­der said “We are look­ing at the le­gal is­sues and that is the bail is­sue. It is be­ing processed. That is as far as I know. It is a slow, te­dious and an­ti­quat­ed sys­tem we have for pro­cess­ing bail.”

This sys­tem, El­der said our “leg­is­la­ture” needs to look at.

The de­lay in ob­tain­ing bail her for the 61-year-old client has no way, frus­trat­ed El­der.

“I am an ex­pe­ri­enced crim­i­nal at­tor­ney. I know all the prob­lems in the sys­tem.”

How­ev­er, El­der said the slow process was caus­ing Mc­Don­ald un­due stress.

“Any­one who is in po­lice cus­tody it is a stress­ful sit­u­a­tion.”

In the six days Mc­Don­ald has been de­tained, El­der said her client did all that was re­quired of her.

“She has been in­ter­viewed, charged and hos­pi­talised so things are tak­ing place.”

On Mon­day, El­der had com­plained that Mc­Don­ald’s con­sti­tu­tion­al rights to rea­son­able bail and to be brought be­fore a ju­di­cial of­fi­cer af­ter be­ing charged were de­nied.

Asked if she in­tends to pen a let­ter to Chief Jus­tice Ivor Archie on these she high­light­ed, El­der an­swered “the CJ should be aware of it. He should have con­struc­tive knowl­edge of it. This was the func­tion of the leg­is­la­ture.”

She said it makes no sense grant­i­ng a per­son bail “and he or she has to go through a very lengthy pro­ce­dure. It is a mock­ery of the sys­tem. You are en­ti­tled to rea­son­able bail. You get bail and then you have this in­or­di­nate time for it to take place.”

El­der who al­so rep­re­sents Mc­Don­ald’s hus­band Michael Carew who was al­so charged with fraud and mon­ey laun­der­ing said he too had not been re­leased on bail.

“As far as I am aware he is still in prison,” El­der said.

Carew, Edgar Zephyrine and Vic­tor An­tho­ny re­mained locked be­hind bars last night.

Crim­i­nal at­tor­ney Fa­reed Ali last night agreed with his law col­league Pamela El­der that the sys­tem in ob­tain­ing bail was an­ti­quat­ed.

Ali out­lined steps a per­son who has been charged has to go through in ac­quir­ing bail.

Step 1) The court must as­cer­tain whether the bailor law­ful­ly owns the prop­er­ty.

Step 2) To as­cer­tain if the par­tic­u­lar prop­er­ty is be­ing used for any oth­er pur­pose col­lat­er­al­ly for bail.

Step 3) The prop­er­ty must show that it car­ries no risks. Fol­low­ing which bail can be ac­cessed.

Ali said that three way process does not take 15 min­utes.

“This process can last from two weeks to a month. If Ms Mc­Don­ald has $2 mil­lion in prop­er­ty she can use, the Clerk of the Peace or the Reg­is­trar of the High Court has to ex­am­ine the doc­u­ments that re­flects own­er­ship of the prop­er­ty. That process means that the Clerk of the Peace and the Reg­is­trar have to call all the courts in T&T to de­ter­mine whether that prop­er­ty/prop­er­ties be­longs to the per­son/peo­ple and is/are cur­rent­ly be­ing used for bail.”

Ali said this re­sults in pro­tract­ed de­lays in the sys­tem.

“Our sys­tem is an­ti­quat­ed in that re­gard.”


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored