Senior Reporter
dareece.polo@guardian.co.tt
A British King’s Counsel who has represented successive Trinidad and Tobago governments says the country should make greater use of its local legal talent, arguing that while overseas attorneys can provide an independent perspective, more legal work should remain in local hands.
Peter Knox, KC, says there are legitimate reasons for governments to seek advice from foreign lawyers, particularly when an impartial assessment is needed on contentious matters or when legislation is being modelled on another jurisdiction.
However, speaking exclusively with Guardian Media following a legal seminar hosted by 3 Hare Court Chambers in Port-of-Spain, Knox said Trinidad and Tobago has plenty of capable attorneys.
“There are plenty of really good lawyers here. The only thing I would say is sometimes it can be easy to get a completely neutral, dispassionate view from someone who has no involvement at all in local politics.
“I, myself, from time to time, but only occasionally, have been asked to be a second pair of eyes on something, and I think that’s perfectly justifiable. I would think it’s justifiable in any jurisdiction, to be justifiable in England, to go maybe to somewhere else to say ‘we would like you, a lawyer from a different jurisdiction, to consider this legislation because we are copying your legislation’ and things like that. But broadly, I think the more you can keep it local, the better.”
Former attorney general Garvin Nicholas also questioned the need to routinely engage foreign King’s Counsel, arguing that local attorneys have the expertise to handle major state briefs.
Nicholas said he believed there should be greater reliance on local counsel unless a matter is proceeding to the Privy Council or the opposing party has retained comparable overseas representation.
He also raised concerns about legal fees, recalling that he had previously asked the Permanent Secretary to review and reduce the amounts being charged during his tenure as AG.
Nicholas added that his experience practising in the UK had exposed him to a stricter system governing legal fees and suggested T&T consider introducing tighter regulation following consultations between Parliament and the Law Association.
“So yes, I am a bit flabbergasted by fees. I have no problem with people getting properly paid for good work. But I think that we are at a situation where, going forward, we need to have those fees regulated more tightly.”
The debate over the use of foreign and local counsel has intensified following questions about more than $3 million in fees requisitioned by attorneys Gerald Ramdeen and Dayadai Harripaul representing the State in the case involving businessman Dominic Hadeed, his wife Genevieve and her aunt, Star Sabga.
No requisitioned fees were provided for the English KCs.
Knox also addressed the Government’s engagement with British constitutional barrister Lord David Pannick, KC, to represent the State against a legal challenge to the Special Operations Act, 2026, following the declaration of Maloney Gardens as a closed area.
A report by the UK newspaper, The Guardian, puts Pannick’s hourly rate at about £5,000, or approximately TT$44,650.
While Knox said he was unfamiliar with the Government’s overall expenditure on English lawyers, he questioned whether the difference between the fees charged by leading British and local counsel was as significant as some might assume.
Asked whether replacing the Privy Council with the Caribbean Court of Justice as T&T’s final court of appeal would reduce legal costs, Knox said he did not believe it would.
“I’m not sure that would get any smaller, in fact... You’d still have lawyers and — from my knowledge, they don’t think they charge £5,000 an hour — but certainly, from bills that I’ve seen, there is not necessarily a big difference between what is charged by your top silks, your top senior counsel and most of the leading counsel in England.”
“So that might be a bit of a red herring,” he said.
While he acknowledged the CCJ’s capabilities, Knox said the Privy Council continued to command considerable respect for its experience in constitutional matters.
Knox, who represented the State in the Privy Council challenge brought by Earl Elie, Ashmeed Mohammed and Dominic Pitilal over the constitutionality of the 2011 State of Emergency, said the ruling largely favoured the State on the central constitutional issues. However, the court reinstated $50,000 compensation each for Elie and Pitilal after finding that their constitutional rights to access legal representation had been breached.
“I wasn’t that surprised that they upheld it.”
However, he acknowledged the potential for governments to misuse emergency powers, given the additional authority they provide.
“I think, in the end, and I can see there is always a temptation for any government to overuse the state of emergency because it gives them more power. And that is something I think the Privy Council is very conscious of. But in that particular case, I think it was okay.”
On the ongoing special operations in Maloney Gardens, Knox said decisions about balancing individual rights against public order were largely matters of political judgment, rather than legal ones.
He said courts were unlikely to intervene unless the State acted outside the powers permitted by the Constitution or there was a serious failure to properly balance competing considerations.
