DAREECE POLO
Senior Reporter
dareece.polo@guardian.co.tt
The Opposition is defending the police’s conduct during the 2011 State of Emergency, following the Privy Council’s upholding of the constitutionality of the regulations.
In a ruling delivered in London yesterday, the Privy Council dismissed an appeal challenging the legality of the State of Emergency (SoE), which was declared by the former People’s Partnership government.
The appeal was brought by Assistant Commissioner of Police Earle Elie, Ashmeed Mohammed and Dominic Pitilal, who were detained during the SoE over an alleged plot to kill government ministers. All three were released when the SoE ended without being charged.
Speaking with Guardian Media outside Parliament yesterday, Opposition Senator Dr Amery Browne said responsibility for the operations rested with the then People’s Partnership administration, arguing that the court’s decision should not be interpreted as an indictment of the police.
“I don’t buy this angle where we’re now blaming the police for actions that were really instigated, envisioned, planned and implemented under a then-UNC government. So, as you would see, it’s not a carte blanche that was given by the Privy Council, and it is clear that the rights of the individuals who were detained, and let’s be clear, the action that was brought before the courts at that time was not on behalf of any political party. These were individuals who were actually detained, were never charged, were granted certain sums by the courts, which will come from the pockets of the taxpayers of this country, and that was reaffirmed by the Privy Council.”
Browne said the significance of the ruling extends beyond the constitutionality of the emergency regulations to the manner in which they were enforced.
He recalled the scale of the detentions and the treatment of those taken into custody, saying the resulting compensation claims have left taxpayers bearing the financial consequences.
“You remember, thousands of people were herded like cattle into trucks, the backs of open trucks, and thrown into jail, never charged, and huge amounts of money have now been expended to settle those matters. So, that’s not a badge of honour for any government,” he said.
Drawing a comparison with the current special operations in Maloney, Browne said the restrictions imposed on one community are even more troubling because they are not part of a nationwide emergency.
“What’s happening now is even worse, because it’s not on a national scale. A particular community, without justification, without particulars, without details, has been selected by the Prime Minister and her team, and as we stand here in the hot sun, are being treated in a manner different to other communities, some of which have even greater concerns with respect to violent crime. How can that be accepted in a modern democracy? It can’t,” he said.
