JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Saturday, July 19, 2025

Contractor seeks to strike out $200m cartel claim

by

2290 days ago
20190411

SHIRLEY BAHADUR

One of the five con­trac­tors named in the Gov­ern­ment’s $200 mil­lion car­tel claim, over con­tracts award­ed in the run-up to the 2015 gen­er­al elec­tion, is seek­ing to have the case against them struck out be­fore it even goes to tri­al.

Lawyers rep­re­sent­ing Na­mal­co on Thurs­day be­gan pre­sent­ing sub­mis­sions in the law­suit ini­ti­at­ed by the Es­tate Man­age­ment and Busi­ness De­vel­op­ment Com­pa­ny Ltd (EM­BD).

Four oth­er con­trac­tors, three of the com­pa­ny’s for­mer of­fi­cials and for­mer Hous­ing Min­is­ter Dr Roodal Mooni­lal are al­so named in the law­suit.

In his sub­mis­sions, British Queen’s Coun­sel Si­mon Hugh­es re­peat­ed­ly de­scribed the case as spec­u­la­tive as he claimed that High Court judge James Aboud was be­ing asked to in­fer im­pro­pri­ety by the par­ties in the ab­sence of any con­crete ev­i­dence.

“It is com­plete­ly fan­ci­ful and lacks any sort of re­al­i­ty,” Hugh­es said.

Re­fer­ring to the as­pects of the law­suit, which claims that the par­ties con­spired to rig EM­BD’s ten­der­ing process, Hugh­es said there was no ev­i­dence which point­ed to the fact that his client was di­rect­ly in­volved in the al­leged plot in­clud­ing in the dozens of text mes­sages which form part of the ev­i­dence in the case.

Deal­ing with the al­le­ga­tion that his client par­tic­i­pat­ed in a process to in­flate bids, Hugh­es said it could be ar­gued that they were en­gaged in cov­er pric­ing.

Hugh­es ex­plained that with cov­er pric­ing, con­trac­tors would over­bid on con­tracts which they did not want or ex­pect to re­ceive in an ef­fort to pre­vent them from be­ing de-reg­is­tered as a pre­ferred con­trac­tor.

“Our ev­i­dence in­di­cates that there are oth­er plau­si­ble and in­no­cent rea­sons why this pric­ing oc­curs,” Hugh­es said, as he not­ed that all the con­tracts be­ing analysed in the case were award­ed to the low­est bid­der.

Hugh­es al­so re­ferred to the ev­i­dence of EM­BD’s ac­count­ing ex­pert who ad­mit­ted that pat­terns in the bids sub­mit­ted by the con­trac­tors could not di­rect­ly prove col­lu­sion be­tween them.

The car­tel claim cen­tres around 10 con­tracts for re­ha­bil­i­ta­tion of roads on lands be­long­ing to the for­mer Ca­roni (1975) Ltd, which were grant­ed to five con­trac­tors in Sep­tem­ber 2015.

Be­sides Na­mal­co, the oth­er con­trac­tors list­ed Fides, TN Ram­nauth and Com­pa­ny Ltd (TN Ram­nauth), Mooti­lal Ramhit and Sons Con­tract­ing Ltd (Ramhit) and Kall Com­pa­ny Ltd (Kall­co).

Mooni­lal, for­mer EM­BD CEO Gary Par­mas­sar, for­mer di­vi­sion­al man­agers Mad­hoo Bal­roop and An­drew Walk­er are list­ed as par­ties to the claim along with the con­trac­tors.

The claim was filed in Oc­to­ber 2017, af­ter Na­mal­co sued EM­BD over its fail­ure to com­pen­sate the com­pa­ny for six con­tracts, val­ued at $1.3 bn, in­clud­ing two of which fell un­der car­tel claim.

Na­mal­co’s law­suit was split in two—its claim over the two car­tel con­tracts were stayed while its claims for pay­ment for four oth­er con­tracts con­tin­u­ing be­fore Jus­tice Ricky Rahim.

The sub­stan­tive law­suit of the car­tel claim is ex­pect­ed to go to tri­al af­ter Aboud de­ter­mines Na­mal­co’s pre­lim­i­nary ap­pli­ca­tion. EM­BD’s lawyers are ex­pect­ed to re­spond to the ap­pli­ca­tion on Friday.

Na­mal­co is one of the con­trac­tors who were re­cent­ly award­ed con­tracts for the com­ple­tion of the Solomon Ho­choy High­way ex­ten­sion to Point Fortin.

Na­mal­co is al­so be­ing rep­re­sent­ed Dereck Bal­li­ram and Raphael Mor­ton-Git­tens, while EM­BD is be­ing rep­re­sent­ed by David Phillips, QC, and Ja­son Mootoo.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored