Senior Reporter
elizabeth.gonzales@guardian.co.tt
More than two months after the state of emergency ended, men awaiting trial remain at Teteron Barracks, a military base designated as a prison without an expiry date. Their families say they have been unable to contact them for months, and court challenges are now testing whether the authorities can lawfully keep prisoners there.
One of those men is Earl Richards, who is awaiting trial for the 2014 murder of Senior Counsel Dana Seetahal. Transferred from the Maximum Security Prison on July 18, 2025, he remains at Teteron, according to information provided to Guardian Media, despite the latest state of emergency ending on September 17.
His wife says she has not spoken directly with him since the transfer. “I don’t want him to die down there,” she said. “Every day I have to cry and ask when this will be over.”
The legal and political questions surrounding the transfers are also mounting. The Prisons Commissioner missed a High Court deadline to defend Richards’ transfer, while Homeland Security Minister Roger Alexander has denied ordering that a murder accused be kept hooded, with a bag over his head, at the military facility.
Richards and fellow prisoner Nefta Felix are pursuing separate High Court challenges over their placement at Teteron. Neither court has ruled that the transfers or disputed visiting conditions were unlawful. Felix’s habeas corpus case will consider whether his continued detention specifically at Teteron is supported by lawful authority, even though he remains on remand under a criminal court order.
Some were transferred there from the Maximum Security Prison in July 2025, after the Government cited intelligence about planned attacks on judges, police officers and other officials. Since then, families have complained that they cannot contact their relatives, while two prisoners have taken the State to court over their placement and treatment.
The Prisons Commissioner has now missed a High Court deadline to defend one of the transfers. Homeland Security Minister Roger Alexander has also denied ordering that a murder accused be kept hooded, with a bag over his head, at the military facility.
The cases concern Earl Richards, who is awaiting trial for the 2014 murder of Senior Counsel Dana Seetahal. Richards was transferred to Teteron on July 18, 2025. He remains there, according to information provided to Guardian Media, despite the latest state of emergency ending on September 17.
The Commissioner’s lawyer has attributed the late court response to leadership changes and staff shortages.
Guardian Media has received no response to questions about how many prisoners remain at the two Chaguaramas facilities, whether the restrictions have been reviewed, or how families can visit, call or write to the men.
Defence attorney Criston J Williams told Guardian Media this week that some of his clients with cases before the courts remained at Teteron. He said prison officials were relying on the Commissioner’s power to transfer prisoners.
“That decision has been called into question in the courts,” he said.
Williams distinguished between remand prisoners at Teteron, whose criminal cases remain before the courts, and people detained solely under emergency powers, who may now sue the State.
One of the prisoners, murder accused Nefta Felix, has also continued a separate habeas corpus challenge. On September 30, Justice Nadia Kangaloo refused to strike out his case. The court will consider whether the authorities can justify holding him specifically at Teteron, even though he remains on remand under a criminal court order.
Families left asking
The greatest fear for Richards’ wife is that she may never see him again.
In an interview with Guardian Media arranged through Williams, she said she had not spoken directly with her husband since he was moved to Teteron.
“I don’t want him to die down there,” she said. “Every day I have to cry and ask when this will be over.”
Asked how long she had gone without contact, she said: “I haven’t spoken to my husband over a year and some months.”
She said she relies on lawyers for information. She has also been asked to put money into the prison canteen without being told how much her husband has available or whether he has received the money relatives send.
Richards’ father died recently, she said. She passed a message to prison officials but did not know whether it reached her husband.
“I don’t even know if Earl knew his father died,” she said.
She last visited Richards the day before his transfer in July 2025 and said he was in good spirits. Months later, she saw him in a video and was alarmed by his appearance. She said Richards has diabetes and questioned whether his diet and other needs were being met.
She also raised concerns about fresh clothes and bedding, saying the family had previously been asked to provide three jerseys and three pairs of trousers.
Richards has been in custody for years, she said, leaving her to raise their five children. The move to the Chaguaramas base has made it harder to maintain family contact. She wants him transferred to a regular prison where ordinary visiting arrangements apply.
“In a prison you can carry things. You can visit. You can change clothes,” she said. “If it’s a prison, give them the rights to see their family.”
Guardian Media reported similar concerns in February, when Tricia James, identified as Richards’ wife, and Stacy Griffith, the wife of fellow murder accused Rajaee Ali, said they had gone six months without contact with their husbands.
James said she had been told her husband was in hospital but had not been given an explanation.
“It’s six months now. I don’t even know what going on with my husband. The last thing I heard was that he was in the hospital, and I still don’t even know what he was in the hospital for,” she said at the time.
Griffith said she had been told to deposit money for her husband at the prison canteen, although she could not speak to him to let him know.
“They don’t know they have money in the canteen, because they have no communication with us or their attorneys,” she told Guardian Media in February.
The published Prison Rules ordinarily allow prisoners awaiting trial two 15-minute visits a week and two letters a week. Prison officials can regulate those arrangements under the applicable rules. However, the Prison Service’s public visiting guide lists other prisons without setting out visiting arrangements for Teteron or Staubles Bay. (See Table on Page 8)
What the court papers
say about conditions
The allegations go beyond missed visits.
In a judicial review application filed in August 2025, Felix sought 41 forms of relief over his treatment and the prison authorities’ alleged failure to follow the Prison Rules. His lawyers asked for orders requiring compliance with the rules, declarations concerning his rights and monetary compensation.
In an August 14, 2025, pre-action letter exhibited to the court, Felix’s lawyers reported what he had told them during a video consultation two days earlier. The letter said he was “not allowed any toilet facilities in his cell and has to defecate in a bag and place it outside his cell”. It also said he was “not facilitated any airing time” and could not access food, clothing or bedding. These are Felix’s allegations; they are not findings by the court.
The letter described Felix as being “in a cell that is newly painted with no ventilation” and complained of paint fumes. It also said he was “denied access to his religious material (it was taken away from him)”.
His lawyers alleged that guards watched him bathe and that one made an unwelcome remark about his body. Lewis’s affidavit also referred to difficulty obtaining a Quran, educational material and access to the library.
Felix further alleged that he was denied prison privileges to which he was entitled and was not told about disciplinary offences against him. The court papers say a copy of the Prison Rules was not displayed for prisoners. These allegations, made on Felix’s instructions, have not been determined as facts by the High Court.
His lawyers sent the pre-action letter to the Prisons Commissioner on August 14, asking whether the military facility complied with the Defence Act, which Prison Rules applied and how an in-person legal visit could be arranged.
Lewis’s affidavit says prison authorities asked for seven days to respond. The complaints were, therefore, formally raised with the Prison Service within weeks of the transfers, rather than for the first time after the state of emergency ended.
A deadline missed
Richards and Felix are pursuing separate High Court challenges over the authority to place them at Teteron. Their cases also raise questions about access to lawyers. Neither court has ruled that their placement or the disputed visiting conditions were unlawful.
In Richards’ case, the Prisons Commissioner and Attorney General missed an October 7 deadline to file evidence. At a November 17 hearing, the High Court gave the Commissioner until December 16, Guardian Media was told.
The Commissioner’s lawyer cited leadership changes and a shortage of staff. Richards’ lawyers opposed the extension, referring to the conditions in which he is held.
Alexander’s affidavit was filed on November 17 as part of the State’s late response. The Attorney General’s lawyers gave a separate explanation for their delay.
In a sworn statement, attorney Jared Jagroo said the State had been “inundated with several matters of national importance”. He referred to the end of the state of emergency, the October budget, the Special Operations Bill and the Maloney Buildings designation. Jagroo said outstanding instructions were received on November 16, a day before the hearing.
Guardian Media was told that Richards’ legal team did not oppose the Attorney General’s application to file late. The lawyers intend to seek permission to cross-examine Alexander and the person who files the Commissioner’s affidavit.
Richards’ reply is due January 18, 2027. Applications for cross-examination are due by February 15.
State tried to stop habeas corpus challenge
Felix’s second case has a different purpose.
He was transferred from the Maximum Security Prison to Teteron on August 10, 2025, several weeks after Richards. He began judicial review proceedings over his transfer and conditions later that month. On April 8, 2026, while that case was pending, he separately sought a writ of habeas corpus—a court procedure that requires those holding a person to establish lawful authority for the detention.
The State asked the High Court to strike out the habeas corpus proceedings. Its lawyers argued that the new case duplicated Felix’s judicial review challenge and amounted to an abuse of the court’s process.
Justice Kangaloo acknowledged substantial overlap but wrote: “I do not, however, consider that this requires the habeas corpus application to be struck out in its entirety.”
In her September 30 judgment, she limited the habeas corpus case to one issue: “whether the Applicant’s present and continued detention at Teteron Barracks is supported by lawful authority”.
Wider complaints about prison administration, conditions and the decisions behind Felix’s placement must be dealt with in the judicial review proceedings. The two matters have been consolidated.
The judge drew a distinction between a court order requiring Felix to remain in custody and the authority to detain him at Teteron.
“The fact that a subsisting remand order may require the Applicant to remain in custody even if that question is answered in his favour bears materially upon the relief ultimately available,” she wrote.
The existence of the remand order does not, by itself, resolve whether Teteron is a lawful place of detention. What remedy could follow remains undecided.
The habeas corpus case continues against the Commissioner of Prisons and the Minister of Defence. Kangaloo dismissed the application against the Attorney General.
“The Attorney General does not have custody of the Applicant and is not the person capable of producing him pursuant to the writ,” she wrote.
Costs on that dismissal were reserved. No court has ordered Felix’s release or transfer.
