Senior Reporter
kay-marie.fletcher@guardian.co.tt
With Maloney under curfew at night and heavily armed police on patrol by day, questions are mounting over police accountability and the use of body-worn cameras during special operations.
However, the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service (TTPS) has disclosed that it has no audits or assessments of its body-camera programme, despite a 2023 departmental order requiring camera use, deployment and malfunctions to be tracked and analysed.
The disclosure was made in a 12-page Freedom of Information (FOI) response dated November 18. It followed an application submitted on September 17 by attorney Keron Ramkhalwhan on behalf of Vishal Persad.
Persad requested copies of audits, reviews, reports, memoranda or assessments concerning officers’ compliance with the programme, reasons for non-compliance, equipment functionality and whether the Service had enough cameras.
The TTPS responded: “Your request is refused on the basis that the requested information does not exist.”
The Service also revealed that no disciplinary proceedings were instituted against an officer for failing to wear, activate or operate a body camera between January 2020 and September 2026.
The admission comes nearly three years after then commissioner of police Erla Harewood-Christopher issued Departmental Order No. 167 of 2023, establishing guidelines for the use and management of body-worn cameras.
Dated December 28, 2023, the order requires the TTPS to compile and analyse statistics to monitor the programme’s implementation and effectiveness. These include monthly records of camera assignments by division and shift, daily usage time for individual cameras, equipment malfunctions, and instances where recordings were used as evidence in serious criminal investigations or complaints against police officers.
The order also assigns the TTPS Information Technology Department responsibility for supplying monthly camera-usage data. The FOI response provided no statistics and did not explain why corresponding audits, reviews or assessments had not been done.
Section 21 of the Special Operations legislation also requires police officers and members of the Defence Force to use body-worn cameras during special operations within a closed area, as far as possible, having regard to available resources.
The FOI response further revealed problems with body cameras acquired by the TTPS at a combined cost of $5,443,739 between 2021 and 2023. The Service said 1,192 cameras were purchased during that period, with hundreds now unserviceable or lacking the technical support needed for use.
This includes 250 Dahua cameras bought from Ginamco Caribbean Limited in February 2021 for $987,500, which are now unserviceable.
Another 192 cameras, acquired from Diamond Systems and Supplies Limited in June 2023 for $996,864, are part of a pilot project. The TTPS said it does not have the platform needed to support them.
The Service said the use of 750 Getac cameras acquired from Amalgamated Security Services Limited in February 2021 for $3,459,375, including software and licensing, has been terminated. Outstanding licensing costs are now the subject of legal proceedings involving Amalgamated Security Services Limited, the TTPS and the Attorney General.
Speaking to reporters in September, Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro said just over 100 body cameras were operational across the TTPS. He said the working devices had been assigned to frontline officers but had limited battery life, lasting about an hour and a half to two hours before needing a recharge.
Guevarro also expressed concern that officers could manually switch the devices on and off during operations, saying interruptions to recordings could raise questions about their integrity.
Former commissioner of police Gary Griffith, who oversaw the acquisition of 1,000 cameras in 2021, rejected Guevarro’s explanations, calling them “excuses”.
Speaking to Guardian Media yesterday, Griffith said the cameras were new and operational when acquired and that there were enough to meet the Service’s needs.
“The lies and the miscommunication coming out from the hierarchy of the police service to justify their cheap excuses not to utilize body cameras, it is becoming sickening now,” he said.
Griffith defended the purchases made during his tenure, saying the procurement process involved several TTPS departments, including administration, legal and finance, as well as senior officers and civilian employees. He questioned why the current administration had not resolved the equipment problems, particularly the outstanding licensing arrangements.
Griffith also rejected Guevarro’s concerns about officers being able to switch cameras on and off. He said officers must be able to control recordings to preserve battery life and respond appropriately in sensitive situations, including interactions with confidential informants.
He said procedures introduced during his tenure required officers to sign out cameras before duty, wear them during patrols and operations, and return them afterwards.
“Any police officer who’s on a patrol, a roadblock, an exercise, a warrant, an operation must sign for the body camera. It must be worn and it is returned and we check to verify if it was used to increase public trust and confidence,” he said.
Griffith claimed the cameras helped improve public confidence in the Police Service, which he said rose from 14 per cent when he assumed office to 59 per cent during his tenure. He also questioned why additional cameras had not been acquired if the existing equipment was no longer suitable.
“If he claims that these body cameras were not good, I got these body cameras in two months, you’re telling me he’s going into two years as a Commissioner and he can’t get one extra body camera? He continues to find excuses,” Griffith said.
He accused the current police leadership of failing to prioritise body-camera use, particularly during special operations.
Guardian Media contacted Guevarro and Harewood-Christopher for responses to the FOI findings and Griffith’s criticism. Neither had responded up to press time.
