Insufficient evidence has led to a couple, an attorney and a teacher being freed of arranging the illegal adoption of a Venezuelan baby after almost three years before a court.
Caribbean Airlines pilot Patrick Borel, his Italian wife Daniela Parinello, attorney Kijana and teacher Adrianna Ragbir were freed of the charge under Section 9 of the Adoption of Children Act, on Thursday, after Magistrate Wendy Dougdeen-Bally upheld no case submissions presented by their attorneys.
In the submissions, the attorneys claimed that State prosecutors failed to prove essential elements of the offence as its witnesses’ evidence was manifestly unreliable.
According to the evidence in the case, the group came under investigation from the Counter Trafficking Unit after the child’s mother made a report to this country’s consulate in Caracas, Venezuela in late 2018.
The woman allegedly claimed that she was brought to Trinidad to give birth and was coerced to assign “temporary guardianship” to the couple in exchange for US$20,000.
Attorney Annabelle Sooklal was initially charged alongside the four others, but the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) discontinued the charge against her in 2019.
According to the legislation, under which the group was charged, only the Children’s Authority has the power to make arrangements for adoptions.
The offence carries a maximum penalty of a $10,000 fine and two years in prison.
After the group was charged, the child was returned to the mother. The mother was also allowed to return to Trinidad to testify in the case, which was heard virtually.
The couple was represented by Sean Cazabon, while Sophia Chote, SC, Keith Scotland, Sparkle Kirk, and Jenna Mapp represented Da Silva. Subhas Panday represented Ragbir.
