Lead Editor - Newsgathering
kejan.haynes@guardian.co.tt
Opposition MP Marvin Gonzales is calling on the Police Service Commission (PSC) to secure an independent audit of crime statistics published by the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service (TTPS), questioning its decision to compare this year’s murder figures with those of 2024 rather than 2025.
Gonzales made the call in a statement issued yesterday, a day after the TTPS reported a 46.2 per cent reduction in murders between January 1 and November 16, 2026, compared with the corresponding period in 2024.
Gonzales is calling on the PSC to intervene by exercising its constitutional oversight responsibilities and pursuing the appropriate lawful mechanism to secure an independent audit, with the findings made public.
Speaking outside Parliament yesterday, the Arouca/Lopinot MP questioned the basis for the comparison, arguing that the figures presented a misleading picture of the country’s murder rate.
He said the TTPS’ own figures showed 296 murders for the period in 2026, compared with 325 during the corresponding period in 2025, representing a reduction of 8.9 per cent.
“Why has the TTPS chosen 2024 as its headline benchmark instead of 2025, the immediately preceding year?”
Gonzales said 2024 was a period in which the country recorded a high murder rate and should not be used as the benchmark to measure current crime trends.
He also questioned the omission of the impact of states of emergency, arguing that the police had access to extraordinary powers of arrest, search and detention during substantial portions of 2025 and almost all of 2026.
“The information being peddled and being put out by the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service on the issue of murders and other serious crimes is very misleading,” he said.
Gonzales further alleged that the presentation of the figures appeared politically motivated, suggesting that the police release was consistent with the Government’s narrative.
Gonzales questions “unclassified deaths”
He also raised concerns about 39 deaths which remain unclassified, arguing that the TTPS had not adequately explained why they had not been classified.
He said the figure was higher than the 29-murder difference between the corresponding periods in 2025 and 2026.
Gonzales stressed that he was not suggesting all 39 deaths were murders, but said the public should be told how many were suspected homicides and how the figure compared with previous years.
He argued that if 29 of those deaths were eventually classified as murders, the reported year-on-year reduction would be erased, while the classification of 30 would increase, assuming the 2025 figures remained unchanged.
“Because the TTPS has not explained the reason for having 39 unclassified deaths on its books. And that might be possibly an area in which the murder rate is being manipulated for political purposes,” he said.
The Opposition MP also questioned the decline in the murder detection rate, from 24 per cent in 2025 to 22 per cent in 2026.
According to the figures he cited, only 65 of the 296 murders recorded this year had been detected.
Gonzales said he welcomed any genuine reduction in crime, but insisted that statistics must be credible and independently verifiable.
He has asked the PSC to examine the accuracy and consistency of murder figures for 2024, 2025 and 2026, the methodology used to present crime trends, the 39 unclassified deaths, the procedures governing the classification and reclassification of suspicious deaths, and the accuracy of murder detection statistics.
“The independence and credibility of the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service are too important to be compromised by any suspicion of political interference or statistical manipulation,” he said.
