Derek Achong
Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
Former attorney general Ramesh Lawrence Maharaj, SC, has stated that a recent Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) ruling on the constitutionality of a State of Emergency (SoE) in 2011 would provide guidance on the legality of three subsequent SoEs declared by successive governments since late 2024.
In a statement issued after five Law Lords mostly dismissed his three clients’ case over the 2011 SoE, Maharaj noted that the judgment should not be interpreted as validating subsequent SoEs.
“The frequency and duration of the recent States of Emergency raises additional constitutional questions which are to be considered in light of the principles endorsed by the JCPC in the appeal of Earl Elie and others, which include that a State of Emergency should be short-lived, the restrictions on fundamental rights must be temporary (not indefinite) and ought not to be used to address problems arising from ongoing problems of inadequate resourcing or lax enforcement of the ordinary criminal law,” Maharaj said.
“The judgment given by the JCPC is however of great public importance because they establish the governing principles which Courts would now apply to determine the lawfulness of public emergencies based on criminal activities and criminal actions of individuals and/or groups,” he added.
In a separate statement, current Attorney General John Jeremie accepted that the judgment had important implications for SoEs declared by his Government in July 2025 and March 2026 and corresponding regulations affecting the constitutional rights of citizens.
He noted that in upholding the 2011 SoE, the Privy Council gave deference to the justification provided by the then-government for declaring it.
“This decision reaffirms the cardinal principle that the decision whether a public emergency exists is primarily a decision for the executive, with the approval of Parliament, in respect of which the courts will accord due weight to the judgment of the executive and the legislature,” Jeremie said.
“In determining any challenge to these decisions, the Court is to afford considerable weight to the assessment of the executive and senior members of the security and police services who are tasked with gathering and assessing threats and risk to public safety,” Jeremie added.
Jeremie stated that the current government would continue to take decisive action to address national security threats.
“This decision confirms that in times of Emergency, when our democracy is tested, your Government has the responsibility and power under the Constitution to take all steps that are necessary to guarantee public safety, and to protect our citizens,” Jeremie said.
“This Government now commits to supporting under the Constitution all actions taken by the security forces to stabilise and secure the lives of the law-abiding citizens of Trinidad,” he added.
In a separate statement, former attorney general Anand Ramlogan, SC, under whose tenure the 2011 SoE was declared, noted that the JCPC vindicated the actions of Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar and her then-People’s Partnership Government to declare the SoE.
“As AG when the challenged State of Emergency was declared, I recall the relentless political attacks upon PM Persad-Bissessar and our administration,” Ramlogan said.
“We were confronted with brutal killings, escalating gang violence and intelligence pointing to an immediate threat to public safety. We chose to act. Today, our country’s highest court has upheld the constitutional foundation of that action,” he added.
Ramlogan stated that the judgment was relevant to the current government’s attempt to tackle the scourge of violent crime affecting the country.
“The Government is developing and implementing innovative legal measures to restore safety to communities where ordinary families live under the shadow of criminal violence,” Ramlogan said.
“It is high time that we unite in the fight against crime to save our beloved country. Far too many put political advantage ahead of constructive cooperation in the fight against crime,” he added.
