Former prime minister Basdeo Panday says the office of the President in its current form is useless.
Furthermore, Panday wants constitutional reform to create an executive presidency, where every eligible citizen would be able to cast a ballot to elect a President.
His comments come just weeks before the Electoral College is expected to meet to appoint a President on January 20th.
In an interview with Guardian Media yesterday, Panday said there needs to be a greater separation of powers in T&T.
“It is not a question of the President and the powers or anything, it is a question of constitutional reform which separates the Parliament, the legislative from the executive, once that happens, all our problems are over,” Panday said.
He has been advocating for constitutional reform for years but said his calls have been ignored.
Panday wants citizens to have a say in electing a President, creating an executive Presidency.
“There should be a president, an executive president, elected by the entire electorate on the basis of one man, one vote.
“The President should be the head of the executive arm of the country and the Parliament should be in charge of the electoral arm, the legislative arm, but you have to separate those two powers,” he said.
Panday said there was “absolutely not enough” separation of powers, as the ruling party gets to have their pick by way of their majority vote for the President’s office.
He said if the People’s National Movement (PNM) Government and the Opposition United National Congress (UNC) worked together, constitutional reform could happen “overnight.”
Asked if he believes that is possible, given the current political landscape, Panday replied, “No I don’t.”
Panday refused to make any suggestions about suitable candidates for the President’s office in its current form, saying the office holder is not important.
“It’s (President’s office) meaningless under this Constitution, so what is the point?” he asked.
Asked if he would consider taking up the position if nominated, Panday said, “No, not under the present system.”
But political analyst Dr Indira Rampersad disagreed with Panday’s assessment.
She said the Office of the President was critically important to T&T governance, as the President was responsible for appointing several independent bodies, including the Equal Opportunities Commission, Integrity Commission and the Police Service Commission.
“These are some of the very important portfolios that the President holds, so this is why it is critical that the presidency or the President be an independent person and the Office of the President be independent,” she said.
“These things should not be politicised,” she added.
However, while she does agree with Panday’s method, Rampersad said she wants a change in how a President is appointed.
She said she is yet to find an alternative system that can work in T&T, as she does not believe an executive presidency is a good option.
Referencing political unrest after allegations of election fraud in Guyana in 2020, Rampersad said, “Proportional representation has not worked in Guyana, they tried it, they’ve experimented, they have an executive president. And we saw what happened when the (David) Granger government refused to step down.”
But she made it clear that above all, the President’s office must be independent.
Rampersad said no politicians, past or present, should be considered for the post.
“I do not support politicians becoming president because they carry in a political bias with them, an obvious, visible, political bias, so whether they say they’re going to be fair, when they get into those portfolios, how can they be fair when they have been sitting and support a political party for all this time?” she asked.
Rampersad said an unbiased, independent presidential nominee will likely come from the Judiciary, as judges are by the nature of their jobs, independent.
She sent out a call to the politicians who make up the Electoral College.
“They are the ones in charge of the process and that they should act wisely, reasonably, fairly, with integrity, and in the best interest of the people in their nominations and appointment of a president, a president that is independent and I will use those adjectives again, unbiased, fair and neutral,” she said.
