Opposition Leader Pennelope Beckles and Opposition Senate Leader Dr Amery Browne have raised concerns about the imposition of a Special Operations closed zone and curfew in the Maloney Housing Development, questioning the restrictions on residents’ constitutional rights and the Government’s justification for the measures.
Browne yesterday unsuccessfully sought to have the Senate debate the matter as one of urgent national importance.
In a written request under Standing Order 16(2), Browne asked for leave to move the adjournment of the Senate to discuss the “disproportionate and discriminatory imposition of a Special Operations Zone, a closed area, and a curfew in the Maloney Housing Development on November 10 2026, and the resulting restrictions on the constitutional rights of residents”.
However, the request was not approved and the matter was not placed on the Senate agenda for debate.
In his letter, Browne said the matter was definite because it concerned specific restrictive measures imposed in an identifiable community and their direct effect on residents’ constitutional rights.
“The Government has not provided clear and sufficient justification for keeping the measures in force and has given residents no timetable or criteria for lifting them,” Browne said.
Browne said the matter was also of public importance because the exercise of powers restricting constitutional rights across an entire community warranted parliamentary scrutiny.
Meanwhile, speaking to Guardian Media after the PNM Tobago convention in John Dial on Monday, Beckles called on the Commissioner of Police to explain why the Special Operations Act was necessary to address last week’s shootings in Maloney.
She said she had observed a disproportionate approach to violence in certain communities, pointing to two killings in Claxton Bay and a shooting in Oropouche.
“Yesterday you had two killings in Claxton Bay. You also had a (shooting) situation in Oropouche. Are they also gonna implement the legislation in those places?” she asked.
“In Maloney, yes, you had shootings, but the police must tell us what it is in terms of normal policing that they were not able to do to address that situation, that it required them to put in place this drastic measure that impacts on freedom of movement.”
Beckles said Maloney’s business community continued to suffer a drop in sales.
PNM Tobago Council leader Shamfa Cudjoe-Lewis warned that Tobago could also be declared a closed area under the legislation.
“What is happening in Maloney would get to Tobago one day. What we are seeing there is an experiment, and they are looking at how they can do this throughout the rest of Trinidad, and very soon this could get to Tobago,” she said.
Cudjoe-Lewis urged Tobagonians to be aware of the situation, adding that “injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.”
