Senior Reporter
sascha.wilson@guardian.co.tt
While the Special Operations Act gives the Government additional powers to tackle crime, safeguards must be in place to ensure citizens’ constitutional rights are protected.
That is the view of Dr Randy Seepersad, who was commenting on the constitutional challenge brought by social activist Wendell Eversley through attorney Stuart Young, arguing that the legislation infringes on several rights guaranteed under the Constitution.
Seepersad noted that the legality of the legislation and its constitutionality were two separate issues, warning that the use of extraordinary powers could result in citizens’ rights, including freedom of movement and freedom of speech, being contravened.
He said proper procedures and checks and balances were therefore necessary to ensure those rights were protected.
Seepersad pointed to provisions for judicial review and body-worn cameras as safeguards under the Act. However, he raised concerns about a potential loophole in the body-camera provision, which he said could allow officers not to use the equipment when it was unavailable.
“One of the things that really jumped out at me in my read of the Act is that emergency health professionals are not simply permitted to enter and leave areas that are, so to speak, cordoned off under this particular Act. And that immediately creates a problem,” he said.
Seepersad warned that requiring medical personnel to obtain permission from the Commissioner of Police before entering such areas could result in dangerous delays during medical emergencies.
Commenting on the Privy Council’s ruling upholding the legality of the 2011 State of Emergency, Seepersad said emergency measures could be effective to an extent but could not resolve the underlying causes of crime.
Meanwhile, commenting on the constitutional challenge to the Special Operations Act, political scientist Dr Bishnu Ragoonath said citizens in a democratic society have the right to challenge any law they believe to be unconstitutional. However, he believes the legal battle could be a lengthy one and may eventually reach the Privy Council.
“I would not doubt at this point in time that this matter may reach all the way up to the Privy Council. But the point about it is simply that I think the Attorney General had said when the Bill was being debated in Parliament that it could be tested in the courts. So, we wait and see the results therein,” he said.
Reflecting on the Privy Council’s ruling on the 2011 State of Emergency, Ragoonath said it affirmed the State’s authority to impose such measures on security grounds. While unsure whether that ruling would have any bearing on the current challenge, he said it demonstrated that the State has the right to use the law and Constitution to restrict citizens’ rights under certain circumstances.
