Senior Reporter
dareece.polo@guardian.co.tt
The Opposition is maintaining its call for Housing Minister David Lee to be removed from Cabinet while criminal proceedings against him remain before the courts.
An independent senator, however, says Lee should not be forced to resign while he is presumed innocent.
Lee is facing charges arising from the alleged misuse of a parliamentary vehicle tax exemption to import a luxury Mercedes-Benz G63 AMG.
He and businessman Hugh Leong Poi were first charged in September 2022 with conspiring to defraud the State of approximately $1.4 million in taxes.
The prosecution alleged that Lee falsely claimed ownership of the vehicle to benefit from tax concessions available to Members of Parliament.
On April 7, 2025, Acting Chief Magistrate Christine Charles dismissed the charges after upholding no-case submissions by the defence.
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions subsequently secured the reinstatement of the charges.
Lee and Leong Poi were re-arrested and charged again in October 2025.
The latest legal development came earlier this month, when High Court Judge Westmin James dismissed a separate challenge by Lee to the DPP’s decision to revive the proceedings.
Speaking outside Parliament yesterday, Opposition Senator Dr Amery Browne said Lee should be removed from Cabinet.
“Absolutely. Absolutely. There is no justification for the Prime Minister retaining someone in a cabinet with the clouds over his head by way of formal charges, such as her Minister of Housing. I’m also aware that there are members even within the UNC who are very anxious for a place to be opened up within the cabinet. So, pay close attention to that as well.”
Independent Senator and Senior Counsel Anthony Vieira took a different position.
He said a minister facing criminal charges should not be compelled to resign before the courts determine the matter.
“I wanna give my answer without reference to any particular person, but as a matter of principle. Anybody can make an allegation. Anybody could bring a charge. That is why there is a presumption of innocence. Now, there is a tradition that sometimes people feel well, okay, you know, I’m called into question and I will resign as a matter of principle. That’s a matter of choice, but I don’t think that there’s any real justification for demanding his resignation. He’s presumed innocent until proven guilty.”
Independent Senator and Senior Counsel Sophia Chote declined to comment, saying the matter was one for the Prime Minister.
Independent Senator Francis Lewis also declined to comment.
