Senior Investigative Reporter
shaliza.hassanali@guardian.co.tt
International relations expert Prof Andy Knight is warning Trinidad and Tobago against becoming “collateral” in a US-China race for artificial intelligence investment, after US President Donald Trump threatened to impose a “tremendous tax” on American companies that build data centres overseas.
“If Washington is going to tax its own companies for building abroad, Port-of-Spain needs to know for certain, before it gives away power and water, whether those U.S. companies will be there at all,” Knight told Guardian Media yesterday, hours after Trump made the threat during a press conference.
Speaking at the White House, Trump said he wanted to keep AI investment in the United States as it competes with China.
“We’re not going to allow our (US) companies to build data centres outside of our country ... we’re going to put a tremendous tax on them” because “China will take all of them,” Trump said.
As of yesterday, Trump had not announced a tax rate, start date or details of the legal authority he would use.
Knight said Trump’s remarks had created uncertainty.
“This was Trump being Trump... unprepared, undiplomatic, and clearly incoherent... not well thought through. This matters for Trinidad & Tobago because in July the Persad-Bissessar government signed MOUs with US firm, Ernst & Young, for a 300megawatts centre and Hummingbird AI Holdings for a 150 megawatts facility to be built in T&T. This was presented to the Government of Trinidad and Tobago as over US$5 billion in investment and potentially creating 5,000 jobs.”
Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar did not respond to questions from Guardian Media yesterday.
Public Administration and Artificial Intelligence Minister Dominic Smith said in a WhatsApp message that Trinidad and Tobago “must position itself to participate meaningfully in the global AI economy”.
Smith said his ministry was focused on “advancing the digital infrastructure, partnerships and investment opportunities necessary to support technological advancement, economic diversification and national development.” He said the Government would continue to work in the best interests of citizens.
On July 10, the Government signed three memoranda of understanding, including two for proposed data centres and AI infrastructure. One was with Ernst & Young LLP to partner with third parties on a 300-megawatt data centre. The other was with Hummingbird AI Holdings for a proposed 150-megawatt centre, with the capacity to scale up by another 500 megawatts.
In August, Energy Minister Dr Roodal Moonilal confirmed that the UNC had approved a data centre in Golconda.
Knight said the memoranda were preliminary and non-binding.
“But they put T&T squarely in the middle of a US-China fight it did not start. If Washington penalises US firms for building abroad, small states that bet their energy, water and industrial policy on that build-out are the first to feel the whiplash,” he said.
Knight urged the Government not to panic or “double down”, but to focus on diversifying the economy and ensuring transparency about water and power use and ownership.
“The T&T government should begin to think seriously about diversification. It should demand full transparency on water, power and ownership, and insist that any data centre deal serves T&T first; not just Washington’s AI race with Beijing.”
Knight said Trump’s press conference was “a bunch of musings” and did not set out a concrete policy. He said only Congress could impose a federal tax and predicted that US policy could change after the midterm elections, with Democrats taking control of the House and Senate.
He also pointed to a separate measure from the US Commerce Department, which he said had moved towards requiring licences for data centres that rent large amounts of US-chip computing power to Chinese firms.
“It is Trump being Trump. The licensing rule is the actual policy. As I have said several times before, the real challenge for Trinidad and Tobago is that the UNC government has positioned itself as a strong supporter of the Trump administration, and its office said the US government played a role in facilitating the July deals.”
Knight said the Government had presented its relationship with the Trump administration as an advantage, but warned that close alignment could limit Trinidad and Tobago’s room to manoeuvre as US policy changes and Caricom partners take different positions on Cuba, the International Criminal Court and Venezuela.
He called it a “huge mistake” for Persad-Bissessar to align so closely with Trump, adding: “And that mistake will be increasingly obvious during Trump’s next two years as a lame duck President.”
Knight said the two proposed AI centres could require about 800 megawatts combined if fully built, roughly one-third of Trinidad and Tobago’s total generation capacity of about 2.4 gigawatts.
“We know that T&T already has chronic water shortages. There was a petition demanding independent environmental, water and infrastructure assessments before approval. That petition garnered over 13,000 signatures in 24 hours in July. Trump’s statement doesn’t settle those questions. It makes them even more urgent: T&T should not lock-in power and water commitments until it knows for sure whether the US partner can even legally build. And, given the uncertainty and incoherence of president Trump’s recent statements, it is not certain that those US AI centres will be built in T&T.”
