Dr Winford James
Max Albert and I continue our discussions on the Tobago Autonomy Question.
We will not apologise for demanding fair treatment for Tobago. Nor should Tobago’s leaders confuse gratitude to God with acceptance of a financial settlement they considered inadequate. A thanksgiving service cannot establish that a contested allocation is fair, or turn a legitimate objection into something requiring repentance.
TTT’s November 10 report attributes to Finance Secretary Petal-Ann Roberts the statement that “the Chief Secretary and I had to repent”. She referred to global turmoil and the possibility that circumstances could have been worse. Those remarks require an answer, especially because she included the Chief Secretary in her account of this supposed change of heart.
Until Farley Augustine speaks for himself, we do not accept her statement as establishing that he has repented of his objection. We are not calling her a liar. We are insisting that his position be established by his own words. His attendance at the service does not settle the matter.
The religious setting makes precision more necessary. A public official remains accountable for statements about public policy wherever they are delivered. We respect thanksgiving. We reject any suggestion that Tobagonians should feel morally chastened for questioning the distribution of national resources. We can give thanks for life while demanding justice in government.
Global economic difficulties affect national revenue and expenditure. But they do not explain how competing claims were weighed. Which programmes elsewhere were reduced? Which commitments were protected? What alternatives were considered before Tobago’s development capacity was diminished? The world situation cannot substitute for answers about decisions made here.
Neither can the observation that matters might have been worse. Almost any inadequate settlement can be defended against an imagined catastrophe. Tobago’s proper benchmark is its responsibilities, its development needs, and an equitable distribution of national resources. Salaries do not establish development capacity.
Her language recalls the accommodation we criticised in Orville London’s assurances that he was comfortable, or not uncomfortable, with allocations. Personal comfort did not establish public adequacy then. Repentance does not establish it now. Whether the administration is PNM or UNC, Tobago deserves representatives who press its case, rather than become apologists for its disappointment.
We must now hear from the Chief Secretary himself. Does he endorse the Finance Secretary’s declaration, or does he maintain his objection to Tobago’s allocation? This cannot be allowed to drift into acceptance through repetition. Tobago deserves his answer post haste.
And what of all 15 elected Assembly members? Are they all repentant? Have they collectively retreated from the position that Tobago deserved better? Or has one Secretary presumed to describe a change of position that others have neither authorised nor expressed? Each must say where he or she stands. Silence leaves their constituents guessing.
Section 44 of the THA Act makes the question more pointed. It provides a route to the Dispute Resolution Commission where the Assembly is dissatisfied with its allocation or any part thereof. Has that route been considered? Is a referral being pursued? If not, why not? The existence of a statutory remedy does not guarantee success, but it demands a serious explanation of the Assembly’s chosen course.
Have we become a laughing stock now? The PNM must be rolling in glee. What is this new standard? Tobago demands adequate resources, protests the outcome, and then hears that its leaders needed to repent for their disappointment. Have they thought through the humiliation that message invites? Why should the national Government take Tobago’s objections seriously if its own leadership appears ready to recast them as faults requiring forgiveness?
If the Chief Secretary and his colleagues endorse this retreat, our criticism cannot stop at Sampson and Thomas. The question would extend to the Assembly’s leadership itself. If they do not endorse it, they must correct the impression immediately. Tobago must not be backed into a shameless corner where defending its needs becomes something embarrassing to acknowledge.
The repentance kangkatang must end. The Chief Secretary must speak, and every elected member must account for his or her position. We demand an answer, not another comforting explanation of why Tobago should expect less.
Our Silk Cotton System would give that demand institutional force. A people’s chamber would examine major island budgets and publish findings. The island Executive would have a defined duty to answer publicly. Elected representatives would retain their final judgement, but the people would receive reasons they could examine. Accountability would apply to the Assembly’s leadership as firmly as to anyone else.
Our political forebears left a different standard: Tobago’s case deserved to be advanced even when independence carried consequences. Their inheritance demands more than ceremonial praise. It demands courage when accommodation would be easier.
We owe no apology for demanding fairness. Those entrusted with Tobago’s cause owe us the honesty to explain where they stand and the resolve to defend the people whose interests they were elected to serve.
Dr Winford James is a retired UWI lecturer who has been analysing issues in education, language, development and politics in Trinidad and Tobago and the wider Caribbean on radio and TV since the 1970s. He has also written thousands of columns for all major newspapers in the country.
