JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, July 25, 2025

Changes to WI selection panel show promise

by

20140817

Se­lect­ing any crick­et team any­where is very dif­fi­cult. When it comes to West In­di­an teams, the process be­comes so fraught with in­sin­u­a­tions, in­nu­en­does, even in­sid­er pol­i­tics, that an al­ready thank­less job be­comes al­most im­pos­si­ble. What­ev­er se­lec­tors do, they will nev­er please every­one every­where.

Like pre­dict­ing stock mar­kets, se­lec­tors should fol­low their in­tu­ition and re­liance on sit­u­a­tions which are not al­ways ob­vi­ous or even ex­is­tent. They have to take bold chances and choic­es, most­ly be­liev­ing heads more than hearts, us­ing fore­sight, very hard tasks in­deed.But the changes pub­lished by West In­dies Crick­et Board (WICB) that for­mer WI cap­tain Clive Lloyd will head a re­vamped WICB se­lec­tion pan­el, as I had pre­dict­ed, is cause for re­served hope.

That pan­el will al­so in­clude two for­mer WI open­ing bowlers Court­ney Walsh and El­dine Bap­tiste, vast­ly ex­pe­ri­enced cam­paign­ers, along with re­tained for­mer wick­et-keep­er Court­ney Brown, which gives a tan­ta­lis­ing taste that the process will be han­dled much dif­fer­ent­ly than has tran­spired over re­cent years.It al­so shows that fast bowlers are not as dumb as many think. Those spin­ner se­lec­tors were ter­ri­ble.

Head coach Ot­tis Gib­son, al­so a for­mer fast bowler, has a vote on this pan­el, while team cap­tains will con­tribute opin­ions but no ac­tu­al vote. That lat­ter part of that equa­tion is se­ri­ous­ly flawed, back­wards even. Cap­tains must have a vote too.Crick­et is not like foot­ball, where a coach alone se­lects teams, send­ing them out with nom­i­nal cap­tains, out­field play­ers do­ing their on­ly job, kick­ing balls around, noth­ing sig­nif­i­cant­ly dif­fer­ent by any of them.Like on­ly goal-keep­ers, crick­et is a game of in­di­vid­ual spe­cial­ists. Each bowler is unique, bats­men's func­tion­al­i­ty all-to­geth­er dif­fer­ent, while all-rounders can do both. Wick­et-keep­ers, like goal-keep­ers, are a breed apart.

Nec­es­sary bowl­ing changes can on­ly come from cap­tains on the field, not coach­es on side­lines. Since ac­tive sub­sti­tu­tions are not yet al­lowed in crick­et, crick­et coach­es' jobs are su­per­flu­ous; that is ex­pend­able.Mean­while, crick­et cap­tains al­ways lead from the front.On­ly crick­et cap­tains on the field could use those un­ex­plain­able in­ner feel­ings, based on present as­sess­ments, to ma­nip­u­late and make ap­pro­pri­ate bowl­ing changes to se­cure wick­ets, hope­ful­ly, ul­ti­mate­ly, gain­ing suc­cess.

There­fore, cap­tains must have much more than just an in­put. They must have ac­tive votes on play­ers they want as com­pa­ny on the field, with the un­der­stand­ing that con­fi­dence in, and chem­istry with es­pe­cial­ly bowlers, make tremen­dous al­lies in get­ting the best per­for­mances out of those who trun­dle.Iron­i­cal­ly, it was Lloyd him­self, ap­point­ed WI cap­tain for 1974/5's tour to In­dia, who brought that neo-mod­ern be­lief that cap­tains must have fi­nal words as to whom should be se­lect­ed. Al­so, there is no doubt­ing Lloyd's ex­cel­lent eye for un­her­ald­ed tal­ent.

His first out-of-the-box se­lec­tions, on his first tour as cap­tain, were young, ag­gres­sive, un­tried bats­men Sir Vi­vian Richards and Gor­don Greenidge, now bat­ting leg­ends in our crick­et­ing fir­ma­ment. Greenidge made 93 and 107 on de­but, Richards made 192 not out in his sec­ond Test, his­to­ry even­tu­al­ly con­firm­ing Lloyd's bril­liant vi­sion on that duo.Lloyd, sin­gu­lar­ly fo­cused as cap­tain-cum-se­lec­tor, al­so saw a young, speedy, rel­a­tive­ly raw Sir Andy Roberts emerge. Roberts had played on­ly one Test be­fore some­how bowl­ing so quick­ly and so well that he got 32 wick­ets in five Tests, in In­dia 1974/75; a stu­pen­dous sta­tis­tic!

With ma­tur­ing cap­tain­cy, Lloyd un­der­stood that he need­ed play­ers he could de­pend on to al­ways give 100 per­cent, that ar­mor and am­mu­ni­tion nec­es­sary to win. Luck­i­ly, he got those too. He un­earthed the di­a­bol­i­cal pace of 21 year old Michael Hold­ing, on­ly three First Class match­es for WI's tour to Aus­tralia 1975/6. West In­dies lost that se­ries bad­ly but not be­fore cool "Mr T" had shown his bud­ding great­ness, im­me­di­ate­ly com­bin­ing with "Fruit T" Roberts to form half of a great pace quar­tet.

The skip­per was re­spon­si­ble for the oth­er half of that still talked about quar­tet too, with in­clu­sions and emer­gence of Joel "Big Bird" Gar­ner, af­ter three First Class match­es and my­self nick­named "Bomber", af­ter four First Class match­es, com­plet­ing "The Four Horse­men of the Apoc­a­lypse", the best pace at­tack ever. Ob­vi­ous­ly, with those su­perla­tive se­lec­tions, Lloyd knows tal­ent when he sees it. One hopes that he is al­lowed to par­lay with present play­ers, on­ly as head se­lec­tor, as was done when he was al­so cap­tain.

How­ev­er, his biggest prob­lem in this mod­ern era is not if there are enough crick­eters play­ing the game here, for there are thou­sands more now ply­ing their game in the Caribbean than 35-40 years ago.The prob­lem is that, most­ly, our re­gion­al crick­eters have been or­di­nary, with few lu­mi­nes­cent slags suf­fi­cient­ly strik­ing enough, right now, to war­rant sug­ges­tions that they will be­come supreme.

Know­ing our ma­nip­u­la­tive Caribbean, that gnaw­ing gut al­so feel­ing re­mains that this ap­point­ment is slight­ly more po­lit­i­cal­ly adroit than meets the eye; pi­geon-holed, sil­hou­et­ted shad­ows for the fu­ture.It is ob­vi­ous that, hav­ing pre­vi­ous­ly had am­bi­tions to be pres­i­dent of WICB, Lloyd ex­pects, per­haps even de­serves more clout in WI crick­et than this ap­point­ment of be­ing just chair­man of se­lec­tors al­lows.So, we shall see how things go these next two years of the ap­point­ments. It will not be easy! En­joy!


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored