Senior Multimedia Reporter
radhica.sookraj@guardian.co.tt
Jineal Chichester was halfway across the Atlantic, standing aboard an aircraft carrier bound for Africa as a young naval officer in the Trinidad and Tobago Coast Guard, when a single question changed the course of her life.
“What are you doing here?”
The answer surprised her.
It was not the sea she was thinking about, nor the military career she had worked hard to build after earning a double major in History and Psychology at The University of the West Indies.
It was cheesecake.
“I realised then that cheesecake was my love,” Chichester recalled. “I decided, you know what, the sky’s the limit. Let me push the limit and do something different.”
Today, that decision has transformed a small university side hustle into Cheesecake House, one of Trinidad and Tobago’s best-known dessert brands, boasting an astonishing 186 flavours inspired by local fruits and culture.
On Thursday, Chichester will celebrate World Cheesecake Day by thanking the loyal customers who have stood with her throughout the journey.
Her story, however, began long before the business had a name.
From textbooks to cheesecakes
Speaking to Guardian Media, Chichester said that while studying at The UWI, she needed money to buy textbooks.
Coming from a family of chefs, she had always been surrounded by baking, so she decided to bake and sell cheesecakes.
“I started the cheesecake business driving around my neighbourhood selling cakes, going onto campus and talking to my lecturers. My first experience in entrepreneurship was actually on campus selling cheesecakes,” she recalled.
After graduating, Chichester joined the Coast Guard and pursued her dream of becoming a naval officer.
While she enjoyed military life, Chichester said that whenever she had free time, she found herself in the ship’s galley helping to make cheesecakes.
“I couldn’t tell anybody that I was helping them make cheesecake because I was a young officer and wasn’t really supposed to be doing that,” she said with a laugh.
The experience convinced her that baking, rather than the military, was where her future lay.
Returning home, she registered the business and gradually built Cheesecake House from her own home.
“Everybody started calling my home Cheesecake House before it was even officially registered because everybody knew they could come here and get cheesecake,” she explained.
Weekends were spent selling at markets and events while building a reputation for birthday cakes, anniversary celebrations and desserts for special occasions.
When setbacks
become opportunities
But Chichester’s journey was not without setbacks.
While operating a food cart at Cross Crossing, San Fernando, a vehicle crashed into it, destroying the business.
Instead of walking away, Chichester chose to focus entirely on the one product customers kept asking for.
“Everybody wanted the cheesecake anyhow, so I pushed the cheesecake to the front.”
That decision helped shape the business into what it is today.
Chichester said that unlike traditional cheesecake makers, she refused to limit herself to familiar strawberry or cherry toppings.
As a child, she had visited New York and marvelled at the dozens of flavours offered at the famous Junior’s restaurant.
When she returned home, she realised Trinidad and Tobago’s own produce offered even greater possibilities.
“We have fruits in Trinidad that are not being showcased. Why don’t I put that in a cheesecake?”
The experiments began.
Mango and passion fruit came first, followed by barbadine, soursop, pumpkin spice, avocado paired with white chocolate and coconut blended with chocolate.
“Every fruit we have, I have combined it and made it into a cheesecake,” she said. “As crazy as it might sound, it works.”
Today, the menu has expanded to 186 flavours.
Whenever possible, Chichester said, she sources local products, including Trinidadian chocolate.
A slice for everyone
Recognising Trinidad and Tobago’s multicultural society, Chichester said she wanted everyone to enjoy her desserts, regardless of dietary restrictions or religious beliefs.
That thinking led Cheesecake House to develop eggless recipes before introducing sugar-free and gluten-free options, allowing customers with different dietary needs to enjoy the desserts.
She even pays close attention to ingredients that many customers may never think about.
“We ensure the vanilla extract doesn’t have alcohol in it so my Muslim customers could enjoy it as well. My Hindu customers could enjoy it because they don’t have the eggs.”
For customers who worry about desserts and healthy living, Chichester encourages moderation rather than guilt.
“Everybody deserves, even if it’s just for five minutes, a moment of bliss.”
She believes quality matters more than quantity.
“If you’re going to enjoy dessert, make it something truly worth enjoying.”
And for Chichester, that philosophy extends beyond the cheesecake itself.
What began as a way to pay for university textbooks has become a business built on creativity, resilience and a distinctly Trinidad and Tobago flavour.
From a Coast Guard ship crossing the Atlantic to a kitchen filled with the aroma of freshly baked cheesecake, Chichester has found her calling, and turned it into 186 different reasons for customers to indulge.
