JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, July 25, 2025

Rethinking confrontation

by

Wendell A Mottley
1147 days ago
20220605
Wendell A Mottley.

Wendell A Mottley.

The flash­ing turn sig­nal was first used in the 1938 Buick mo­tor car. Yet, to pass the T&T Dri­ver’s Test in 2022, the stu­dent dri­ver must roll down the win­dow and demon­strate com­pe­tence in hand sig­nalling. I use this as a metaphor for the long-out­mod­ed sys­tems em­ployed in our T&T pub­lic ad­min­is­tra­tion, with re­sul­tant low pro­duc­tiv­i­ty and cit­i­zen con­sumer dis­sat­is­fac­tion. This mat­ters be­cause ul­ti­mate­ly pub­lic sec­tor com­pen­sa­tion can­not be sep­a­rat­ed from is­sues of pro­duc­tiv­i­ty. It is es­pe­cial­ly rel­e­vant now as pub­lic ser­vants are un­der­stand­ably and right­ful­ly seek­ing a liv­ing wage. They ex­pect busi­ness as usu­al in wage ne­go­ti­a­tions, that is, an in­crease high­er than the rate of in­fla­tion dur­ing the pe­ri­od cov­ered by the col­lec­tive agree­ment. The world, in­clud­ing Trinidad & To­ba­go, has en­tered a pe­ri­od of high in­fla­tion not ex­pe­ri­enced for 40 years, es­ti­mat­ed lo­cal­ly at ap­prox­i­mate­ly sev­en per cent per an­num. Any wage in­creas­es less than that, say pub­lic ser­vants and their unions, would amount to a salary cut!

For many decades, T&T’s high­ly pro­duc­tive en­er­gy sec­tor fund­ed dis­pro­por­tion­ate­ly high stan­dards of liv­ing in its non-en­er­gy sec­tors, in­clud­ing the pub­lic ser­vice. How­ev­er, pro­duc­tion in the en­er­gy sec­tor has been in de­cline since 2010, masked tem­porar­i­ly by ex­tra­or­di­nary re­cent in­creas­es in en­er­gy prices. Nat­ur­al gas prices have shot up from pre-pan­dem­ic $2.50 mcf to $8 mcf to­day. The re­sul­tant fis­cal wind­fall has many claimants. For ex­am­ple, ne­glect­ed road re­pair, debt re­pay­ment in­clud­ing VAT re­funds; cook­ing gas, trans­port, and elec­tric­i­ty sub­si­dies; and in­creas­es in pub­lic sec­tor pay.

In such dif­fi­cult cir­cum­stances, gov­ern­ments usu­al­ly ‘fudge’ a set­tle­ment among claimants, dic­tat­ed in part by per­ceived po­lit­i­cal strength and the vo­cif­er­ous­ness of their claims. The un-sus­tain­abil­i­ty of these set­tle­ments is bru­tal­ly ex­posed over time. I cite the 1980s, an­oth­er pe­ri­od of en­er­gy sec­tor de­cline. In the build up to the 1986 gen­er­al elec­tion, the Pub­lic Ser­vices As­so­ci­a­tion (PSA) de­mand­ed a 15 per cent salary in­crease. By 1987, the coun­try’s eco­nom­ic cir­cum­stances were such that the Gov­ern­ment was com­pelled to im­pose a ten per cent salary cut. More re­cent­ly, from 2014-2018 Bar­ba­dos’ dire fis­cal sit­u­a­tion dic­tat­ed that the Gov­ern­ment lay off al­most 4,000 pub­lic sec­tor work­ers, ap­prox­i­mate­ly 25 per cent. It has been proven world­wide that on­ly sus­tained high pro­duc­tiv­i­ty growth of the whole econ­o­my can in­su­late against such un­sat­is­fac­to­ry out­comes.

In­ter­na­tion­al com­par­isons, though not con­tex­tu­alised, can be in­struc­tive. The share of pub­lic sec­tor em­ploy­ment as a per­cent­age of the to­tal labour force is 25.9 per cent in T&T; 12.5 per cent in Brazil; 12 per cent in the Do­mini­can Re­pub­lic and 11.8 per cent in Mex­i­co. In­ter­na­tion­al­ly, Sin­ga­pore sets en­vi­able stan­dards for high pay and pro­duc­tiv­i­ty. Sin­ga­pore’s pub­lic ser­vants are on­ly 4.5 per cent of their to­tal labour force and are very well paid com­pared with Trinidad and To­ba­go’s. The base salary of a Sin­ga­pore Per­ma­nent Sec­re­tary is just un­der $300,000 (TT) per month, with ad­di­tion­al per­for­mance-re­lat­ed pay ben­e­fits. A T&T Per­ma­nent Sec­re­tary re­ceives by com­par­i­son a base salary of just un­der $50,000 (TT) per month with min­i­mal per­for­mance ac­count­abil­i­ty.

How­ev­er, there are ma­jor pro­duc­tiv­i­ty dif­fer­ences be­tween these two coun­tries that ex­plain the salary dif­fer­en­tials. In the first in­stance, Sin­ga­pore em­ploys 66 per cent few­er pub­lic ser­vants per capi­ta than T&T. More­over, Sin­ga­pore’s GDP per capi­ta is US$59,000 com­pared with T&T’s US$18,000. Fur­ther, it should not es­cape our at­ten­tion that over many years of tight fi­nances, the T&T Gov­ern­ment has stuck to a pol­i­cy of ‘no re­trench­ment’ in the pub­lic ser­vice.

In my own pub­lic life, I have wit­nessed a con­tin­u­ing in­abil­i­ty to im­ple­ment nec­es­sary pub­lic sec­tor re­form. I was a mem­ber of Patrick Man­ning’s first Cab­i­net in 1991 when the PM led a de­ter­mined ef­fort in re­form. The man­age­ment ex­pert, the late Gor­don Drap­er, was re­cruit­ed in­to the Cab­i­net to lead this mis­sion of pub­lic ser­vice re­form. Gor­don con­fessed that the re­mote Pub­lic Ser­vice Com­mis­sions and their con­sti­tu­tion­al lock un­der­mined his ef­forts to build ac­count­abil­i­ty in­to the Ser­vice.

Sim­i­lar­ly, I wit­nessed a sys­tem in the Min­istry of En­er­gy and En­er­gy In­dus­tries in which our tal­ent­ed young na­tion­als were re­cruit­ed on short-term con­tracts. In­evitably, many of the bright­est re­cruits sought job sta­bil­i­ty at in­ter­na­tion­al firms, and their ser­vice and ex­per­tise are now lost to the coun­try.

The 2020 Road Map Com­mit­tee Re­port placed con­sid­er­able em­pha­sis on the digi­ti­sa­tion of pub­lic ad­min­is­tra­tion (The Es­ton­ian Mod­el) to mod­ernise and im­prove pro­duc­tiv­i­ty in the pub­lic ser­vice. Im­ple­men­ta­tion has been steady, but too slow to meet the ur­gency of to­day. My main point here is that the forces of fis­cal grav­i­ty, the need for pro­duc­tiv­i­ty gains and the de­mands for high­er wages are now in stark con­fronta­tion.

The present in­sti­tu­tion­al struc­tures were not de­signed to pro­mote pro­duc­tiv­i­ty or ef­fi­cien­cy in ser­vice de­liv­ery to the pub­lic. Col­lec­tive bar­gain­ing, con­cil­i­a­tion and an In­dus­tri­al Court serve large­ly to re­cy­cle di­min­ish­ing pe­tro­le­um rents. These in­sti­tu­tions can­not in the long term guar­an­tee the de­liv­ery of a liv­ing wage. A new In­dus­tri­al Pol­i­cy is re­quired: made up of sev­er­al com­po­nents such as new di­rec­tions for the econ­o­my with high pro­duc­tiv­i­ty growth po­ten­tial; up­skilling of thou­sands of pub­lic ser­vants; na­tion­al adop­tion of ac­count­able work prac­tices fea­tur­ing re­wards for per­for­mance. We al­so need to end elit­ist priv­i­lege where­by, for ex­am­ple, doc­tors “ful­ly” em­ployed in the pub­lic ser­vice are al­so al­lowed their pri­vate prac­tices.

In a few weeks, Trinidad and To­ba­go will cel­e­brate 60 years of In­de­pen­dence. Sure­ly, that is time enough to re-ex­am­ine some of the pro­vi­sions of our In­de­pen­dence Con­sti­tu­tion and the re­lat­ed in­sti­tu­tion­al arrange­ments that shack­le suc­cess and in­no­va­tion. I would like to hope that such a re-ex­am­i­na­tion be guid­ed by an ethos of sin­cere col­lab­o­ra­tion rather than the pre­vail­ing pos­ture of hos­tile con­fronta­tion. Such a change in at­ti­tude would be wor­thy of cel­e­bra­tion.

Commentary


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored