On the issue of the presence of US naval forces in Caribbean and Venezuelan waters, let us acknowledge a topsy-turvy multi-polar world in which power matters more, principles mean less and expectations are being recalibrated daily as complex geopolitics plays out.
Let’s take non-interference. Is Ukraine a case of non-interference? Is Gaza a case of non-interference? Do Hamas and other terrorists interfere? What should we call state-sponsored cyber-attacks? Nearer to home, was Grenada a case of non-interference during the Maurice Bishop years and after his execution in 1980? Will anything in Haiti get better without interference?
Positive interventions to help Venezuela forward took place in collaboration with the Maduro regime. In spite of Maduro’s excesses, a country like Norway, known for promoting dialogue and making peace, got involved. An accord for free and fair elections was signed in Barbados. But there was no free and fair election. All that followed from Maduro was repression and increased militarisation at home, and increased aggression against his neighbours—Guyana, Colombia, Brazil.
The election came and went. Maduro was declared winner by the electoral authorities. Up to now, no tally sheet has been provided. Opposition members and supporters have been jailed. Opposition leaders who had an election stolen from them live in exile. At the OAS, Caricom could not agree to a collective call for the election tally sheet!
Kamla Persad-Bissessar, as Opposition leader, consistently took a stand against Maduro, distancing herself from the Dr Keith Rowley government for ten years. This time, our Prime Minister had to decide: Maduro or Trump in the square off? Consider pending tariff negotiations with the US and OFAC licences to make Venezuela gas possible. Guyana is a Caricom country we can do business with and Maduro is the aggressor. Maduro may not last and most Venezuelans want him out. Five million have fled his oppression. T&T needs help with gangs, borders, drugs and guns. So, the Prime Minister made a calculated choice in T&T’s interest.
Venezuelan criminals hop from Venezuela to Colombia, to T&T, to Guyana and, across the Americas. Should somebody put a stop to this? Governments from Jamaica southwards cannot cope with gangs, drugs, gangsterism, murders, violence and criminality. Gangster-dominated Haiti is the extreme regional case.
The motivating factors for the United States may not be pure. Venezuela owns 19% of the world’s oil reserves. Chevron is pumping oil from Venezuela and every drop goes to the US. So, there is aggressive self-interest at work.
There may also be a defensive self-interest. Guyana is now the oil capital of our part of the world. Venezuela’s claims on Guyana’s Esequibo region is as much a claim on territorial land as it is on oil resources. Exxon Mobil, the largest energy company in the world, is the dominant player, with collaborative ties to US President Donald Trump. President Irfan Ali’s government in Guyana faces a threat from Azrudeen Mohammed, who is vying for Guyana’s presidency and who has been sanctioned by the US Treasury Department for gold smuggling and tax evasion. Both Venezuela and Guyana are gold producers. Gangster operations often connect drugs and gold to the transnational underworld. The US, given its interest in ExxonMobil, Guyanese oil and the election outcome on Monday, is perhaps being preemptive. Exxon’s presence in the deep waters of T&T make common cause.
Aggression by Maduro on Guyana’s border could impact on the Guyanese election, as could destablisation initiatives by Venezuelan gangs who may have their electoral preference in Guyana.
So, the military presence in this region, of US naval forces, may well be prompted by both offence and defence.
What about the notion of the Caribbean and Latin American region as a Zone of Peace? This can be traced back to a 2014 CELAC meeting in Cuba in which 23 countries were present. Does Venezuela’s military aggression toward Guyana contribute to creating a Zone of Peace?
And what is sovereignty these days, and who can guard it, in this age of power, force and military might?
Abuse of power within countries and use of power against other countries is becoming the norm. The tone is being set for more aggressive geopolitical behaviour. Power is the new principle; force facilitates conformity and acquiescence. Arbitrariness trumps rationality. The space for moral authority is being obliterated. The old rules by which the world lived post-WWII are gone.
In the new frontier of American hemispheric assertion, T&T is in the middle and has to find her way. Caricom must reason together to cohere.