Among the scores of news releases received this past week was one from the People’s National Movement’s (PNM’s) Tobago Council that raised more than a few eyebrows within the media fraternity.
The release announced that the Council will undergo the nomination process for internal elections today, between the hours of 10 and 5 pm.
The second paragraph, however, is something we haven’t seen from any political party before:
“All media houses and media personnel are hereby informed of the following; (i) No permission is given to cover the nomination process (2) No permission is given for any media house or media personnel to attend the nomination process and (3) Information would subsequently be corresponded to the media.”
That the Tobago PNM Council does not see the public relations disaster it is creating through this, is in itself a reason why the party’s Tobago arm is drastically in need of reform.
Following the resounding 14-1 election defeat in December and at a time when the party needs to convince supporters and others of its strength to rebound, it seeks instead to cloak the change process but shutting out any opportunities for independent media personnel to meet and engage with those vying to form the next executive.
As bizarre as the media release is, we’d be the first to admit that the media does not have untrammelled rights to anyone’s business, including internal party affairs. And to manage that, party organisers could easily tell nominees to channel all public comments through the existing executive instead of directly engaging with the media—something to be frowned upon but admittedly remains their right.
But to tell the media they’re not allowed to show up and capture photos, video, and report from outside the party’s compound on the happenings, is not something we’d expect from a party that oversaw the drafting of our Constitution that speaks to freedom of the press.
And it’s simply the last thing one should expect from an established organisation like the PNM.
What can possibly be there to uncover that the PNM does not want its supporters and the public to know? What can possibly be happening behind the scenes during a democratic nomination operation, that calls for the process to be conducted in a clandestine, non-transparent manner? And does the party believe that the public’s trust in the outcome of the process should be hinge only on a statement with a public relations spin?
By their actions, the party has now shifted the focus from the nomination of candidates to the deeper question of why it’s not being done openly.
The media would do well to pursue this angle by turning up and asking questions of the party from a public space without venturing onto the party’s compound where they are not welcomed.
We resist the urge to believe that the beating the party took has made it coward and afraid—a PNM Council once-beaten suddenly becoming twice shy.
The party has repeatedly boasted of its strength, resilience and of a structure that is more solid than others. And yet here they are hiding from the public amid the very process that is supposed to reflect their fortitude.
Something’s certainly rotten in the state of the Tobago PNM and those who lead the party will do well to fix it long before nominations turn into an actual election process.
