JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, July 9, 2025

Permell wins judgment against TCL

by

2055 days ago
20191123
Peter Permell

Peter Permell

derek.achong@guardian.co.tt

Readymix (West In­dies) Ltd mi­nor­i­ty share­hold­er Pe­ter Per­me­ll has won his le­gal chal­lenge over the share price of­fered by Trinidad Ce­ment Lim­it­ed (TCL) when it ac­quired a ma­jor­i­ty stake in the com­pa­ny in 2017. 

De­liv­er­ing a judge­ment at the Hall of Jus­tice in Port-of-Spain, yes­ter­day morn­ing, High Court Judge, Eleanor Don­ald­son-Hon­ey­well, ruled that the fair mar­ket val­ue of the shares was $13.42 as op­posed to the $11 or US$1.62 orig­i­nal­ly of­fered by TCL. 

The share price set by Don­ald­son-Hon­ey­well on­ly ap­plies to the 26,400 shares owned by Per­me­ll as he was the on­ly mi­nor­i­ty share­hold­er who opt­ed to chal­lenge TCL’s of­fer. 

Ac­cord­ing to the ev­i­dence in the case, when TCL be­gan the take over in March 2017, it held 8,531,977 shares or a 71.1 per cent stake in the com­pa­ny. 

Fifty-three of the com­pa­ny’s 496 mi­nor­i­ty share­hold­ers in­clud­ing Cli­co, RBC Trust, Unit Trust Cor­po­ra­tion (UTC) and Re­pub­lic Bank Lim­it­ed took up TCL’s of­fer. 

Fol­low­ing the close of the bid, 39 oth­er mi­nor­i­ty share­hold­ers of­fered a fur­ther 1,577,207 shares, leav­ing TCL with over 90 per cent share of the com­pa­ny. 

Un­der the T&T Se­cu­ri­ties and Ex­change Com­mis­sion Take-Over By-Laws, the com­pa­ny was re­quired to of­fer to buy-out the re­main­ing share­hold­ers in­clud­ing Per­me­ll, who lat­er de­cid­ed to chal­lenge the share price of­fered by TCL. 

At a pre­lim­i­nary stage in the case, the par­ties had le­gal ar­gu­ments on which of them should be re­quired to pay for an in­de­pen­dent val­u­a­tion of the com­pa­ny re­quired to de­ter­mine the fair mar­ket val­ue of the shares. 

Don­ald­son-Hon­ey­well even­tu­al­ly or­dered that TCL foot the bill. 

Don­ald­son-Hon­ey­well’s as­sess­ment of the fair mar­ket price of the shares was based sole­ly on the in­de­pen­dent val­u­a­tion the court even­tu­al­ly re­ceived. 

As a sec­ondary is­sue in the case, Per­me­ll was ask­ing the court to or­der in­ter­est to be paid on the val­u­a­tion, which took ef­fect from the date of the fil­ing of the law­suit. 

As Don­ald­son-Hon­ey­well dis­agreed with the con­tention, she on­ly or­dered TCL to pay 75 per cent of Per­me­ll’s le­gal costs for bring­ing the law­suit. 

In a brief in­ter­view af­ter the judge­ment was de­liv­ered, Per­me­ll said he was pleased as the case set a le­gal prece­dent for lo­cal and re­gion­al merg­ers and ac­qui­si­tions. 

He claimed that TCL had ini­tial­ly at­tempt­ed to set­tle the case but he de­cid­ed to take it to tri­al for there to be a ju­di­cial de­ter­mi­na­tion on the is­sue. 

“I re­al­ly did this be­cause the ju­rispru­dence in the area is scarce...This is a small vic­to­ry for me but a large one for mi­nor­i­ty share­hold­ers not just here but for the whole Caribbean,” Per­me­ll said. 

Per­me­ll was rep­re­sent­ed by Ron­nie Bisses­sar and Varin Gopaul-Go­sine, while Cather­ine Ram­nar­ine and Miguel Vasquez rep­re­sent­ed TCL.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored