Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley "played his hand" and lost, says former Police Commissioner Gary Griffith.
This, after the Attorney General's Office yesterday stated that there will be no publication authorised by the State or its agencies of the T&TPS Firearms Unit Audit Report or any summary of that "unless and until" all persons who may be adversely affected by the report's findings are afforded the opportunity to comment and make representations on any such findings.
And consideration is being given by Government to having such affected persons report back to the Prime Minister - or such other persons as the PM may direct.
The AG's Division stated that the audit report or any summary of it will not be laid in a manner so as to prejudice "its value as an investigative audit report."
This was among the reply yesterday from the Attorney General's Legal Division to Griffith's attorney Larry Lalla, who wrote Rowley on August 29 asking the PM to "hold his hand" on laying the report's executive summary in Parliament.
The report involved an audit of the TTPS' Firearms Department and its licensing regime, operations and portfolio and the firearm users' licences that had been legally issued and distributed in T&T. It was done by retired ACPs Wellington Virgil and Raymond Craig, retired Inspector Lennard Charles and others.
Rowley recently said the report was "disturbing" and made for "very very troublesome" reading. He'd indicated its executive summary would be laid in Parliament.
Lalla, in his letter to Rowley, signalled intention to seek High Court judicial review to quash the report due to "flagrant unacceptable breaches of natural justice to Griffith." It was noted Griffith wasn't asked to respond on the report.
Lalla asked Rowley for a written undertaking by last Friday to "hold his hand" on laying the summary in Parliament, which resumes Friday. If Rowley didn't comply, Lalla said he'd seek injunction to restrain laying of the summary.
A reply subsequently received from Tenille Ramkissoon, Director, Legal at the AG's Office, sought more time beyond last Friday's deadline. Lalla offered until yesterday.
Ramkissoon's reply received yesterday stated, "The Honourable Prime Minister and the Attorney General have given careful consideration to the contents of your letter and the Attorney General has been directed to respond thereto.
"Although it is proposed that the audit report or any summary thereof will eventually be laid in Parliament, it is not proposed that same be laid until and unless the matters stated below are actioned, by reason of which it is not proposed to lay the audit report or any summary thereof in Parliament at this time.
"Consideration is being given as to whether there are persons adversely affected by findings in the audit report who have not had an opportunity to comment and make representations on the matters giving rise to those findings and, if there are such persons, as to what steps ought to be taken in relation to them and the audit report and its summary.
"Consideration is also being given as to whether in such a case, before the State or any of its authorities discloses the report or its summary, an appropriate person or body of persons should review the audit report and invite all persons who might be adversely affected by any findings in the report and its summary to comment and make representations on any such findings as may affect them."
Ramkissoon added, "Consideration is further being given to having that person (or body of persons) report back to the Honourable Prime Minister or such other persons as the Honourable Prime Minister may direct, on that person’s review and such representations. Thereafter, a decision could be made as to what steps, if any, ought to be taken on the report or its summary.
"The Attorney General is of the opinion that fairness and the law demand that before there be any publication of the report or its summary, all persons who may be adversely affected by the findings therein should be afforded the opportunity to comment and make representations on any such specific findings.
"Accordingly, the Attorney General assures you and your client that, if and insofar as such persons have not been provided with such an opportunity, there would be no publication authorized by the State or its agencies of the audit report or any summary thereof, unless and until all persons affected by findings therein are given that opportunity. Further, the audit report or any summary thereof will not be laid in a manner as to prejudice its value as an investigative audit report."
Ramkissoon added," ... As before, we reserve all of our rights and make no admissions with respect to anything stated or implied in your letter dated August 29, 2022."
Good sense prevailed - Griffith
Ex-Police Commissioner Gary Griffith said yesterday's letter from the Attorney General's Office "just shows the incompetence of the Prime Minister's attorneys."
" ... In not knowing you can't just witch-hunt in your desperation to take down someone - there must be natural justice. The Prime Minister and his attorneys obviously forgot the same thing what happened in Landate, where they had a similar situation where they decided to go in a certain direction without speaking to the individual accused.
"This is the third or fourth time an audit is being done by politicians, this is not a banana republic. You can't have politicians handpicking people and these people who have no law enforcement authority and can just go and write reports littered with 'it is alleged/rumoured' or 'we've heard' and use that as an avenue to smear the character of others. Producing political assassination through handpicking people and calling it an audit report is unacceptable, this is about the third or fourth, Barrington, Stanley John - up to now, no one has spoken to me prior to them completing a report."
He added, "In this last report, you hired three former police officers with over 100 years of police investigations and not one of them had the common sense or training to understand you cannot do an audit and submit something without speaking to the individual who was in charge at the time. That shows incompetence at the highest level. They wasted taxpayers' money and time and the Prime Minister was trying to use this in the cloak of Parliament to hide to be able to report something that was littered with lies, rumour and allegations," Griffith claimed.
"Good sense has prevailed and by this letter, it's shown this was a deliberate witch-hunt without proper process and just like the Stanley John report, none of this can in any way be used in any forum because it was done in an improper manner by hiring civilians to be involved in an investigation."
Attorney Larry Lalla was concerned since he claimed the letter from the AG's office, "seemed to indicate" the Prime Minister "would have" investigatory power, which he doesn't have.
