JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Friday, July 25, 2025

Benjamin, Abdulah ask Shamfa: What did you sacrifice?

by

Gail Alexander
1029 days ago
20220929

There has been loud back­lash fol­low­ing Min­is­ter of Sports Sham­fa Cud­joe’s crit­i­cism of Bud­get 2023 crit­ics.

Both Op­po­si­tion UNC MP Michelle Ben­jamin and Move­ment for So­cial Jus­tice (MSJ) leader David Ab­du­lah have de­nounced Cud­joe’s re­cent re­marks, with Ben­jamin even call­ing for Cud­joe to apol­o­gise.

At a Tacarigua com­mu­ni­ty cen­tre func­tion on Wednes­day, Cud­joe re­port­ed­ly lashed out at crit­ics of the Bud­get, say­ing there were some peo­ple who “nev­er worked a day in their lives and were still re­ceiv­ing a pen­sion, as the safe­ty net re­mained strong” and that “peo­ple want­ed eve­ry­thing right now.”

Ben­jamin said the state­ments were “un­be­liev­able, un­couth, cold and cal­lous and an out of touch rant on cit­i­zens’ sac­ri­fice.”

Ben­jamin said, “The Min­is­ter is talk­ing about sac­ri­fice. While she may be able to swipe her card and buy any­thing her heart de­sires, ba­sic food items are be­yond the reach for the av­er­age cit­i­zen be­cause of Gov­ern­ment’s dra­con­ian poli­cies, where the on­ly plan is to make the rich get rich­er with noth­ing trick­ling down to the poor, ex­cept of course hav­ing to pay for their bad de­ci­sions.”

She called on Cud­joe to apol­o­gise.

“In­stead of talk­ing down to cit­i­zens, the Min­is­ter for Sport and Com­mu­ni­ty De­vel­op­ment should come to com­mu­ni­ties and ex­pe­ri­ence first-hand the suf­fer­ing of fam­i­lies who are suf­fer­ing. The Min­is­ter owes it to the pop­u­la­tion to is­sue a clear and un­equiv­o­cal apol­o­gy.”

Ben­jamin al­so deemed Cud­joe’s re­marks, a “clear in­di­ca­tion of Gov­ern­ment’s dis­dain for av­er­age, hard­work­ing cit­i­zens and true pa­tri­ots.”

“Is the Min­is­ter say­ing the home­mak­ers, women who spent time build­ing the fam­i­ly, and prepar­ing the doc­tors, lawyers, teach­ers and sport­ing per­son­al­i­ties we have to­day, that they de­serve less? If any­thing, they de­serve more. Were it not for them and their labour of love, many of those in po­si­tions of pow­er and au­thor­i­ty to­day wouldn’t have been where they are.”

Mean­while, MSJ leader Ab­du­lah asked the Min­is­ter, “Did you sac­ri­fice your tax-free car Sham­fa?”

Ab­du­lah said he was “to­tal­ly dis­gust­ed by the ar­ro­gance of the PNM Gov­ern­ment.”

He added, “From Prime Min­is­ter to Sham­fa Cud­joe, their ut­ter­ances are sim­ply get­ting more and more peo­ple ex­treme­ly an­gry.”

Ab­du­lah said the Prime Min­is­ter, “as usu­al, be­rat­ed cit­i­zens for not mak­ing the right choice” on ve­hi­cles, time to leave home so as to not be in traf­fic and burn fu­el and for not be­ing dis­ci­plined enough to make work-from- home a re­al op­tion.

He added, “Then it was Min­is­ter Cud­joe’s time to heap scorn on the pop­u­la­tion. ‘Why is it so hard to sac­ri­fice’ she asked. First­ly, the MSJ, like so many peo­ple, asks – what have you sac­ri­ficed re­cent­ly Ms Cud­joe? Did you and your par­lia­men­tary col­leagues give up your perk of a tax-free ve­hi­cle?

“If not, when last did you buy a new car, tax free? And how much did you sell the pre­vi­ous one for? You have your salary, a trav­el­ling al­lowance and oth­er al­lowances. You have a dri­ver to take you around. Did you sac­ri­fice any of these? Did you take a pay cut?”

Ab­du­lah con­tin­ued, “But what about the sin­gle moth­er who works as a se­cu­ri­ty guard – 12 hours dai­ly, with­out over­time; and who has to hus­tle pub­lic trans­port very ear­ly to get to work for 6 am be­cause if she’s late her pay will be de­duct­ed, and she doesn’t get home till af­ter 8 pm. Are you say­ing this work­er, who hasn’t had a wage in­crease in years isn’t mak­ing a sac­ri­fice?”

He al­so raised sev­er­al oth­er ex­am­ples, as he ques­tioned Cud­joe over who was mak­ing a sac­ri­fice.

Ab­du­lah end­ed his mes­sage to Cud­joe by ques­tion­ing her lack of care.

“Your ar­ro­gance is tru­ly dis­gust­ing and the lack of care for the peo­ple whom you were elect­ed to serve can no longer be tol­er­at­ed. And this goes for many of the oth­er min­is­ters who take their cue from their leader.”


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored