Former police commissioner Gary Griffith has denied he was responsible for leaking the 2019 Special Branch report on People's National Movement Minister Foster Cummings - and says his personal view is that the intelligence report shouldn't be seen as an avenue to discredit anyone.
Addressing the issue in an interview on I95FM yesterday, Griffith said it was strictly an intelligence report and not an evidential one and there is a difference between intelligence and evidence.
Cummings has denied the report's contents of alleged issues focusing on two companies he's allegedly linked with.
United National Congress Senator Jayanti Lutchmedial, who revealed the report last week, challenged Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley to say why - if he had the information - his PNM screening team approved Cummings to contest the 2020 general elections and later made him a minister.
PNM sources claimed Rowley "mentioned" the matter at a recent General Council.
Yesterday, Griffith said accusers who felt he was involved were giving him "too much credit," as it wasn't something he'd do.
But Griffith slammed alleged leaks of several reports by "Government officials." He detailed the Stanley John Report on the T&T Police Service FUL issue, the Barrington report on the same issue, a Finance audit of the TTPS and information given to the former Police Service Commission. He said the situation showed the "hypocrisy" of the National Security Minister in his comments about "concern" over the leaked Special Branch (SB) report.
Griffith said he was aware of the Special Branch report but dozens of people in unit would have drafted the report before it got to him and he also handed it to several Government officials - plus he claimed there was infighting in the PNM.
On different types of reports, he said there were information reports like the Barrington report. But he said there were also intelligence reports where there was enough information to be deemed credible to warrant further probe to ascertain if there's clear/present danger, or if there's a crime, or further proof was needed to clear the person of anything; and then one had evidence.
In a situation like that, he said it was mandatory for him to forward any such information to the PM. He said the SB reports to the PM and the latter could direct the SB to investigate anything and that was dangerous. He said both PNM and UNC refused to change that format.
Wrong SB report on Al-Rawi
Whether the Special Branch report in question was an evidential report or intelligence, Griffith said it was "strictly intelligence" and it was unfortunate acting Police Commissioner Mc Donald Jacob "talked utter nonsense" about saying there were different grades of intelligence. Griffith said it seemed Jacob had now become a spokesperson for the PNM and needed to stop trying to be one.
He said when such reports get to the CoP, it is the highest level of intelligence report.
However, he said in his personal view, this report was no more than an intelligence report and this shouldn't be seen as an avenue to discredit anyone "...because intelligence report is just that - it is no fact, no evidence, it is nothing to accuse anyone."
"Maybe the Prime Minister was correct not to have acted because that is all it is."
He claimed the PM told him on several occasions before that some reports submitted by the Special Branch and "nothing was the same."
Griffith reiterated that the Special Branch report in question was indeed the highest grade.
"It is ... but that doesn't mean that that makes it authentic to the point of fact or evidence and what is spoken about the person must be perceived that they're culpable or (the person) is deemed a person of interest.
"That's all it is - it's only an intelligence report and intelligence reports at times could be totally inaccurate."
Griffith recalled that there was a report that went to the PM on former AG Faris Al-Rawi with "damning accusations." Griffith said when he investigated, it was done by a Special Branch member who "tried to mislead the PM."
He added, "That's to show you how serious this is ... when you have these reports, sometimes you may need to take it with a pinch of salt."
He said he wasn't there to defend Rowley or Cummings but was only saying it was an intelligence report. He insisted that as an intelligence report, "once it got to me" it was of the highest grade. But the highest grade doesn't mean it's authentic and confirmed. There's a difference between intelligence and evidence."
Griffith said in the "same way" Rowley "rightly so," may have disregarded it, as "it didn't say anything to make the person culpable and was based on perceived hearsay," he questioned why Rowley didn't do the same with the Barrington report. He said that was a double standard.
Illegal guns coming/going via legal ports
On another matter concerning claims by National Security Minister Fitzgerald Hinds that there are 12,000 guns at large, Griffith told the T&T Guardian that was a foolish comment.
"How can you pinpoint the number unless you know where the weapons are?"
Griffith said several containers leave T&T's ports annually without being accounted for and one alone could have 10,000 illegal firearms.
"So we don't know and therein lies the problem ...," he said.
But he said administrations didn't do the right thing, since in UNC's time, if someone had a sidearm, it was no bail for three months and now if one had an assault weapon that can kill 35 in three seconds, it's being said those people had a right to bail.
He said the PNM likewise "deliberately" didn't implement the Border Protection Unit he'd drafted. He said that is critical, as the vast majority of illegal guns aren't coming through illegal ports but via legal ports of entry.
He said both parties- PNM and UNC - when in Government all continued to be the catalyst towards what caused the problem with gang violence when they continued giving gangs big state contracts. That ranged from Lifesport to CEPEP, URP, East PoS and Colour Me Orange.
From his time as minister to being in the T&T Police Service, Griffith said he'd told this to Government officials but they refused to desist as they believed if you feed gangs, it would cause them to stop.
"But it does not," he said.
