carisa.lee@guardian.co.tt
The Opposition is calling for Police Commissioner Erla Harewood-Christopher to apologise to the nation for assessing her performance in the first hundred days on the job as “excellent.”
“What she should have said is that this is a work in progress, I am trying my hardest, I will stick to the job,” Opposition Senator David Nakhid said during a media conference at the Office of the Opposition in Port-of-Spain, yesterday.
Yesterday marked the 100th day since Harewood-Christopher was appointed as Police Commissioner by the Police Service Commission (PSC) on February 3.
During the T&T Police Service Sports and Family Day on Saturday, Harewood-Christopher rated her performance as excellent.
Nakhid, however, said such an assessment is borne out of the statistics and if the CoP rate herself as excellent, then “then we have to say anybody that comes under the jurisdiction of this Government or involved in this Government, they become delusional.”
“She has shown us she is now completely delusional and she should apologise to the nation for making that statement,” he said.
He added, “I remember one Prime Minister previously stating that it is not so much about the crime, is about the perception of crime and the feeling you get. He now heads this Government, so the feeling about crime in this country is one where we are in a very dark place.”
He noted, however, that Harewood-Christopher has shown she is not completely delusional and should say she’s sorry.
Former National Security Minister and former police commissioner Gary Griffith shared a similar view about the CoP’s rating.
He said it is very unfortunate that at a time when crime is the number one concern and public trust and confidence in the police is dwindling rapidly, Harewood-Christopher would give herself such an assessment.
“If you try to commend yourself and you really see this as being excellent, in a situation where the ratio for her is the highest spike in crime in the history of Trinidad and Tobago and you see this as being excellent, we really going into quicksand,” Griffith said.
However, he said police commissioners should never assess themselves.
“I would never rate myself, I will let the data and staff do the talking and let the public do the talking,” Griffith said.
The former commissioner, who served in the position from 2018 to 2021, said from the moment he heard Harewood-Christopher promise to reduce the murder rate by June 2023, he told her it was infeasible.
“I inherited a gradual spike in crime annually for four years before I came to CoP, and it took me over a year to get that turnaround…It is going to be impossible,” he said.
Similarly, former acting police commissioner McDonald Jacob, who gave himself a B-plus for his performance in 2022, said it’s the Police Service Commission’s responsibility to evaluate commissioners.
He did not want to comment on Harewood-Christopher’s 100-day on-the-job milestone but commended her attitude towards the job.
“So, if she believes she’s doing an excellent job, I’m glad she has that level of confidence,” he said.
Jacob also called on police officers to continue supporting the Commissioner and on non-governmental organisations (NGOs), as well as Government agencies, to continue doing their work because the police need their help.
“So, I’m asking that whether it’s 100 days, whether 300 days, I just constantly pleading for these government agencies to continue aggressively doing work on the ground…To help with the social aspect that will assist the police service in the work they are doing,” Jacob explained.
He also called on the police to continue working with international partners, noting that some of the crime the country is facing is transnational crime.
This transnational aspect is why criminologist Darius Figuera said it is totally unreal to expect Harewood-Christopher to bring a drastic change to the landscape of crime in T&T in such a short time.
However, Figuera added that it’s not time to play politics with the whole position of her rating and understand what she is up against and the time she has been in office to act upon it.
“Time because remember, she came into office after we had the rivers of blood commencing and 2022 has been an all-time record, so she has been plunged into the deep end,” he said.
He said the CoP has to find her bearing, fully come to grip with the reality and then react.
“So, I expect that her rating of excellent is that she has been engaged with the whole process now of putting in place the response to reduce the criminality that is taking place in this country,” Figuera said.
A criminologist with 45 years’ experience, Figuera said social control has now collapsed in this country and there is no boundary place. He said in an environment like that, the TTPS is too small in its manpower size to apply hardcore policing and regain control over the criminal element.
“You will need a TTPS with a contingent of 30,000,” he said.
“The persons who feel they can put a hard line to this and bring this under control, they living with Alice down the rabbit hole,” he added.
Meanwhile, criminologist Professor Ramesh Deosaran said he would give her a year before assessing her, but noted she should be more careful when making such utterances.
“No I see it, she made the statement on the run and I think it’s more of a metaphor. To me, I haven’t taken that, forgive me for being too serious, because she jokingly laughing and telling the press excellent,” he said.
Professor Deosaran said self-assessment is part of a valid human resource measure, but it must be accompanied by other measures. He said on one hand, Harewood-Christopher and the TTPS need support but on the other hand, there is a disturbing escalation of murders, home invasions and public fear of crime.
“She also have to draw into her plans the conditions that drive the home invasions and the brutal murders that we are witnessing, not to judge and CoP, in his/her first 100 days, is very challenging if you looking for any quick crime reduction,” he explained.
He called on the public and the police to continue the support because she has not showed any significant improvement in the detection rate and needs to show a renewed and more effective system of public communication and partnership.
“If a year finishes and she doesn’t reach that point, she will be subjected to excessive scrutiny, she has to deal with the question of gang activities…and praedial larceny is on the loose,” he said.
Last Tuesday, ahead of her 60th birthday (retirement age for the TTPS), the Government extended Harewood-Christopher’s tenure by a year.
