Only 27 per cent of Trinidadians have confidence in the judiciary.
That’s according to a North American Caribbean Teachers Association (NACTA) opinion poll conducted in Trinidad last month.Tobago was not polled.
The poll interviewed 520 respondents at random to represent the demographics of the population.
According to pollster Vishnu Bisram, people attribute the low level of confidence in the judicial system to the problems facing Chief Justice Ivor Archie.
In releasing the poll findings, Bisram said respondents felt that the CJ’s actions seeking political favors for friends have compromised the independence of the judiciary as a separate branch of government.
He said people felt that the CJ had brought the judiciary into a state of disrepute and that it would be best if he were to demit office to restore some level of confidence in the court.
There was also the view from some people, according to Bisram that a judge should serve in the court for a limited period so as to reduce the chance of him or her being compromised.
The 27 per cent confidence in the judiciary according to NACTA, is lower than the 31 per cent of the population who approve of the performance of the government, but much higher than the 17 per cent among those who have faith in the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ).
According to Bisram the poll found that people have greater faith in the local appeal court system than the CCJ, and that if a referendum were to be held on whether the nation should assent to the CCJ as its final court of appeal, replacing the Privy Council, the vote would fail by a landslide.
Based on the findings of the poll NACTA has concluded that no T&T lawyer, including those who practice before the court, have expressed any support for the court.
Bisram said lawyers feel if the CCJ’s decision were allowed an appeal at the Privy Council in London, many of its rulings would have been overturned. Some lawyers say the CCJ’s judges have not developed strong courage to reject political influence of their elected bosses.
Accordig to the NACTA findings, peopledon’t have confidence in the CCJ to render impartial rulings.
Those opposed to the CCJ said the court is highly politicized and tend to render political decisions rather than issue rulings based on rule of law and constitutionalism.
The NACTA poll concluded that because of the low very low level of confidence in the CCJ, it is extremely unlikely that Trinidad and Tobago would assent to the CCJ any time soon as its final court of appeal.
The poll interviewed 5
