The Finance Ministry and National Insurance Board (NIB) are currently examining recommendations to gradually increase the pension age from 60 to 65 and add the self-employed to the National Insurance system to help sustain NIB’s fund.
This was confirmed on Wednesday in statements by acting permanent secretary in the Finance Ministry and executive director of NIB Niala Persad-Poliah when officials of the ministry and NIB management were interviewed by Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee (PAC).
They were questioned on NIB’s audited financial statements (2014 to 2020).
Chairman of the committee Dave Tancoo, Roger Munroe, Amery Browne, Paula Gopee-Scoon, Charisse Seepersad, Ayanna Webster-Roy and Jearlean John raised queries.
Persad- Poliah said as of 2020 NIB’s customer base was just shy of 600,000 and beneficiary recipients, approximately 204,000.
Benefits expenditure paid over the period was $5.3 billion at June 2020. Contribution income was $4.6billion . Total assets at June 2020 was $28.9 billion
Speaking about NIB’s growing deficit amid a limiting population of contributors due to T&T’s ageing population, Persad-Poliah noted the 9th and 10th actuarial reviews which projected that from 2013 contribution income would no longer be sufficient to support benefit payments.
With the growing gap between expenditure and the ageing population and people living longer , expenditure over 2017-20 grew from $4.7 billion to $5.3 billion compared to contribution income of $4.6 billion.
Persad-Poliah said NIB used investment income to support benefit payments. But in the last two years even contribution and investment income combined was insufficient to support benefits plus administrative expenditure.
Consequently, NIB used investment plus cash equivalent to support the deficit. That’s projected to continue ahead.
Persad-Poliah said the 10th review projected NIB’s fund is sustainable but reform is urgently needed. NIB laid out steps for reform which are in the review.
She said the review recommended gradual increase in the retirement age from 60 to 65 over that time, adjustment of the contribution rate from 13.2 per cent and other levels to 16 per cent and freezing of the minimum ( $3,000) pension.
“In furtherance of those recommendations we’ve been meeting the ministry and sharing with them what the recommendations are. We’ve also lobbied key stakeholders– Government, business and labour.”
NIB’s Chief Operating Officer (Business Services) Feyaad Khan said the last review showed T&T has 3.2 contributors supporting each pensioner. That will decline to one over the next 50 years in the absence of reform.
“By changing the retirement age, you’ll have people contributing for longer so there’ll be an uptick in the contribution income and benefits will be paid for a shorter period of time,” he said.
Khan said this suggestion has been presented “time and time again as the most impactful step” to ensure sustainability of NIB’s system. Reviews also show that improving yield to NIB’s investment portfolios won’t improve handling the deficit.
Khan said the 2015 increase in NIS contributions to 13.2 per cent buffered NIB’s liquidity constraints.
But while changes are happening gradually, he added, NIB was cognisant of the fact the economy is facing challenges, care must be taken and consultative approaches also taken to implement reforms .
At this point Khan said, NIB continues actuarial reviews to provide more current information. Persad - Poliah said all recommendations from the 9th and 10th reviews were analysed and subject to stakeholder consultation. “And we’re meeting finance providing them with several scenarios and options for consideration and I’m aware it’s receiving positive consideration,” she said.
Lutchman said, “At this point what is engaging the ministry’s attention is moving the retirement age from 60 to 65– the approach must be consultative– and we’re also looking at the incorporation of the self-employed into the National Insurance system which would have been another recommendation engaging the ministry.”
Lutchman said the ministry is looking at the different scenarios including economic landscape, contributors and employees and “what kind of solution would be palatable.”
Lutchman said there was no specific timeline for implementation at this time since analyses are being done .
She said the minister would have also helped and analysed some “and would have reviewed some and asked questions” so she couldn’t say if it would be in the next two or six months.
She said the ministry received a report on bringing the self-employed onto NIB’s register. She said certain recommendations are being analysed at this point .
She said that given the report was done in 2020 and COVID impacted the economy assumptions would have been made, “to put forward the recommendations, we’re now looking at all the factors and they’re currently being assessed.”
Persad-Poliah added there are no immediate plans to dispose of NIB’s current assets to pay NIS benefits.
