JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Moonilal on South Quay housing:

It's an election gimmick that will never materialise

by

Anna-LIsa Paul
2244 days ago
20190519
Roodal Moonilal

Roodal Moonilal

An­na-Lisa Paul

An elec­tion gim­mick that will nev­er ma­te­ri­alise. This was how for­mer hous­ing min­is­ter Dr Roodal Mooni­lal de­scribed Gov­ern­ment’s an­nounce­ment that they in­tend­ed to con­struct 204 apart­ments at South Quay, Port-of-Spain, as part of its con­tin­u­ing ef­fort to ad­dress the ur­gent de­mand for pub­lic hous­ing.

On Fri­day, Hous­ing Min­is­ter Ed­mund Dil­lion signed the US $71 mil­lion con­tract with Chi­na Gezhou­ba Group In­ter­na­tion­al En­gi­neer­ing Com­pa­ny Lim­it­ed (CG­GC) for the de­sign, build and fi­nanc­ing of four high-rise build­ings con­tain­ing 133 three-bed­room and 71 two-bed­room apart­ments at POS; and five high-rise build­ings con­tain­ing 120 three-bed­room and 115 two-bed­room apart­ments at La­dy Hailes Av­enue, San Fer­nan­do.

Con­struc­tion is ex­pect­ed to be­gin short­ly, with phase one set to span two years.

It is hoped that by the end of 2020, at least 5,000 low-cost homes would have been con­struct­ed via this project.

Claim­ing such promis­es were “cal­cu­lat­ed” and “po­lit­i­cal in na­ture”, Mooni­lal said, “These an­nounce­ments and fan­cy pic­tures are be­ing tak­en from web­sites and they are trans­pos­ing it. This is re­al­ly an elec­tion gim­mick to show the peo­ple that they will build some­thing in the fu­ture, but there is ab­solute­ly noth­ing in place for any type of mega-de­vel­op­ment that they are speak­ing about.”

Ex­press­ing con­cern that state projects were be­ing done with­out prop­er land ac­qui­si­tion pro­ce­dures be­ing fol­lowed, Mooni­lal point­ed to con­tin­u­ing de­vel­op­ments such as the Kay Don­na Over­pass and the To­co High­way as ex­am­ples of where the au­thor­i­ties had failed to fol­low prop­er pro­to­cols.

He re­it­er­at­ed, “They are just us­ing pic­tures be­cause they have no achieve­ments to show.”

Mooni­lal, re­fer­ring to the Peo­ple’s Part­ner­ship’s term in of­fice, said, “Where­as we could have shown schools, fire-sta­tions, po­lice sta­tions, hos­pi­tals…they are just go­ing on the In­ter­net and find some build­ings to put up and de­cide, this will be POS and San Fer­nan­do.

“There is ab­solute­ly no plan­ning, no pro­jec­tion, no vi­sion, no source of fi­nanc­ing.”

Mooni­lal said when the PP ad­min­is­tra­tion as­sumed of­fice in 2010, they con­tin­ued with pre­vi­ous plans from the Patrick Man­ning led-ad­min­is­tra­tion which in­volved the re-de­vel­op­ment of East POS and the port de­vel­op­ment at Beetham.

“These are projects that were in the pipeline for many years and we were con­tin­u­ing in that line,” he said.

Mooni­lal ac­cused the Peo­ple’s Na­tion­al Move­ment (PNM) of mov­ing away from this mod­el, pre­fer­ring city-scape type build­ings.

“I want to as­sure the peo­ple that none of this will hap­pen. It cer­tain­ly can­not hap­pen in 12 months. It is just try­ing to fool the peo­ple in an elec­tion year.”

Con­cerned that Chi­nese con­trac­tors were be­ing en­gaged for this par­tic­u­lar kind of project, Mooni­lal said, “T&T has an abun­dance and sur­plus of home con­struc­tion ex­perts and con­trac­tors who pro­duce high-qual­i­ty work all over the Caribbean. There are sev­er­al of them and it is very dis­turb­ing that the PNM Gov­ern­ment would iden­ti­fy a con­struc­tion com­pa­ny that has been in some trou­ble with the World Bank Group.”

Dis­miss­ing the need to en­gage for­eign con­trac­tors to con­struct lo­cal hous­ing units, Mooni­lal said, “We have the equip­ment, we have the labour force, we have the tech­ni­cal ca­pac­i­ty to do the work. You should en­gage for­eign con­trac­tors in projects where you may not have the do­mes­tic ca­pac­i­ty such as in port build­ing and hos­pi­tal con­struc­tion, cer­tain­ly not in hous­ing.”

“This is a ret­ro­grade and back­ward step that will fur­ther push out lo­cal busi­ness­es, lo­cal labour and lo­cal cap­i­tal for­ma­tion so this is an ex­treme­ly back­ward ap­proach by the Gov­ern­ment to en­gage Chi­nese con­trac­tors for home con­struc­tion.”

He claimed lo­cal firms would not ben­e­fit as the Chi­nese nor­mal­ly bring in their own equip­ment and labour, with pre­cious lit­tle left for the lo­cal mar­ket.

In Au­gust 2013, In­de­pen­dent Lib­er­al Par­ty leader Jack Warn­er pre­sent­ed a pack­age of good­ies to res­i­dents in East POS which in­clud­ed food, land, gov­ern­ment con­tracts, jobs in the pro­tec­tive ser­vices, and hous­es as part of his par­ty’s promise to im­prove their lives.

The World Bank Group and CG­GC

On May 29, 2015, The World Bank Group an­nounced the de­bar­ment of Gezhou­ba No 1 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd, the Gezhou­ba No 5 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd, and the Gezhou­ba No 6 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd and their af­fil­i­ates for a pe­ri­od of 18 months.

In ad­di­tion, Chi­na Gezhou­ba Three Gorges En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd and its af­fil­i­ates were al­so de­barred for a pe­ri­od of six months.

Chi­na Gezhou­ba Group Co Ltd al­so re­ceived a Let­ter of Rep­ri­mand which was valid for six months dur­ing which the group re­mained el­i­gi­ble to par­tic­i­pate in World Bank-fi­nanced ac­tiv­i­ties.

The sanc­tions were part of a Ne­go­ti­at­ed Res­o­lu­tion Agree­ment be­tween the World Bank and Chi­na Gezhou­ba Group Co Ltd, and its four sub­sidiaries; name­ly: Gezhou­ba No 1 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd, Gezhou­ba No 5 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd, Gezhou­ba No 6 En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd, and Chi­na Gezhou­ba Three Gorges En­gi­neer­ing Co Ltd.

The set­tle­ment fol­lows the ac­knowl­edg­ment of mis­con­duct by these en­ti­ties in three bank-fund­ed projects in the Peo­ples Re­pub­lic of Chi­na in re­la­tion to wa­ter con­ser­va­tion, earth­quake re­cov­ery, and flood man­age­ment.

The agree­ment signed be­tween the World Bank and Chi­na Gezhou­ba Group Co Ltd took note of the ex­tent of co­op­er­a­tion that the group and its sub­sidiaries' demon­strat­ed and the ex­tent of proac­tiv­i­ty and re­me­di­al ac­tion tak­en by the com­pa­nies to en­sure that this mis­con­duct does not re­cur.

Un­der the terms of the Agree­ment, Gezhou­ba No 1 En­gi­neer­ing Com­pa­ny Lim­it­ed, Gezhou­ba No 5 En­gi­neer­ing Com­pa­ny Lim­it­ed and Gezhou­ba No. 6 En­gi­neer­ing Com­pa­ny Lim­it­ed com­mit­ted to co­op­er­at­ing with the World Bank In­tegri­ty team and were al­so re­quired to adopt a Cor­po­rate Com­pli­ance Pro­gram con­sis­tent with the World Bank Group In­tegri­ty Com­pli­ance Guide­lines.


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored