The legal dispute between the Police Service Commission (PolSC) and former police commissioner Gary Griffith has taken yet another turn.
Guardian Media has learnt that on April 22, 2022, chairman of the Police Service Commission Judith Jones received a pre-action protocol letter by the legal team representing Griffith.
The letter, titled: “Proposed legal proceedings between Gary Griffith and the Police Service Commission for relief in Public Law,” was sent by Griffith’s lawyers in relation to the commission’s denial of his Freedom of Information Act request and the commission’s refusal to provide Griffith with a copy of a report conducted on the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service’s Firearm Section by retired Justice Stanley John.
Griffith’s attorneys, Avory Sinanan SC, Larry Lalla, Ajay Baball and Suren Ramsingh, alleged that the August 2021 Merit List for the appointment of a substantive Commissioner of Police was submitted to the President but was unceremoniously and possibly unconstitutionally withdrawn by then PolSC chairman Bliss Seepersad.
According to the letter, the commission’s response to a FOIA request from Griffith, that it could not provide a justification for the list’s withdrawal as the incident took place prior to the appointment of the current membership, was unacceptable and a sign of continued injustice carried out against Griffith.
Griffith’s attorneys also claimed he was unfairly and unjustly treated by the PolSC’s decision to withhold the John report, calling the denial unreasonable and in breach of natural justice as protected under the Constitution.
“An unbiased and objective consideration of such records as the Commission has been able to maintain or preserve…will undoubtedly demonstrate to the neutral and impartial observer that Mr Griffith has been the victim of unfair and unjust treatment at the hands of the Commission,” the letter stated.
“We do not make this assertion lightly, but find support for such contention against the backdrop of a series of events that culminated in the commission’s refusal of Mr Griffith’s Freedom of Information Request.”
Griffith filed a FOIA request seeking details of the events leading up to and the commission’s basis for the appointment of John as an investigator; the commission’s withdrawal of the finalised August 2021 Merit List for the appointment of a substantive Commissioner of Police; the circumstances surrounding the preparation of the Stanley John report and the ‘apparent condonation and/or indifference’ by the PolSC to the leaking of the John report to the press.
The legal team said their client expressed serious concerns about the power and constitutionality of the Police Service Commission to appoint Justice John as an investigator.
According to the letter, Griffith’s legal team accepts the constitutionality of the PolSc to exercise disciplinary control over police officers and to delegate its functions, but maintained that the delegation must be with the approval of the Prime Minister and must be to a member of the PolSC itself or the Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner of Police.
“There is no evidence to suggest that the approval of the Prime Minister was sought and obtained for Mr John’s appointment as “investigator” but even more glaringly and egregiously, Mr John is not a member of the PolSC and nor does he answer the description of Commissioner of Police or Deputy Commissioner of Police or a Police officer above the rank of superintendent,” the pre-action protocol letter to PolSC chairman Jones stated.
Griffith’s legal team believes Griffith ought to have been supplied with the allegations upon which the Police Service Commission launched its investigation into claims of corruption in the issuance of Firearm User’s Licenses.
The report was prepared by Rear Admiral Hayden Pritchard and Senior Supt Arthur Barrington.
