Derek Achong
A private hospital and a specialist doctor have lost their final appeal over being held liable for medical negligence and ordered to pay millions of dollars in compensation over the death of the husband of former finance minister Karen Nunez-Tesheira.
Delivering a judgement, a short while ago, five Law Lords of the United Kingdom-based Privy Council dismissed two connected appeals brought by Gulf View Medical Centre Limited and anesthesiologist Dr Crisen Jendra Roopchand.
In the appeals, the hospital and Dr Roopchand were claiming that former High Court Judge and current Appeal Court Judge Vasheist Kokaram and the Court of Appeal got it wrong when they upheld Nunez-Tesheira's lawsuit against them.
Lords Reed, Sales, Hamblen, Stephens and Pentland, who presided over the appeal, dismissed all seven grounds raised before them.
"There are no grounds for the Board to go behind such concurrent findings as to the cause of the deceased's death," they said.
Nunez-Tesheira's husband Russell, an insurance executive, died at age 54 after undergoing a transurethral resectioning operation to his prostate at the hospital on April 13, 2004.
During the procedure, an instrument is inserted up the patient’s urethra to remove the section of the prostate that is blocking urine flow.
Two hours after the procedure, Tesheira was found to be bleeding excessively, prompting doctors to perform a secondary operation and emergency blood transfusions. Tesheira died on the operating table.
Nunez-Tesheira filed the lawsuit claiming the hospital and the two doctors who did the procedure — urologist Dr Lester Goetz and Dr Roppcand were negligent in her husband’s death.
In 2011, Justice Kokaram dismissed the lawsuit at a preliminary stage after Nunez-Tesheira failed to meet two successive deadlines he set for filing her evidence against the three parties.
While appealing the decision, Nunez-Tesheira came to a settlement with Dr Goetz which saw him being removed from the lawsuit without accepting liability.
Nunez-Tesheira eventually won in the Court of Appeal and the lawsuit was reinstated.
In March 2015, Justice Kokaram ruled in Nunez-Tesheira's favour.
In assessing almost $18 million in compensation for Tesheira’s family less the ex-gratia payment already made by Dr Goetz, Kokaram considered the salary and benefits he would have accrued if he had continued to work at Clico, where his last annual bonus before his death was almost $4 million.
Justice Kokaram's decision was eventually upheld by the Court of Appeal, which reversed some of his findings but ruled that he decided the overall case correctly.
The hospital and Dr Roopchand then filed a separate lawsuit seeking to have Dr Goetz pay a percentage of the compensation they were ordered to pay.
Their ancillary case was eventually rejected by a High Court Judge and the Court of Appeal.
The Privy Council's decision in the case brings Nunez-Tesheira's over decade long legal battle over her husband's death to a close and means that she can finally receive her compensation.
The compensation is expected to be greater that what was initially assessed by Justice Kokaram over seven years ago as the hospital and DR Roopchand will be required to pay interest for the period, they were challenging the outcome of the case.
Nunez-Tesheira is currently a candidate for political leader in the upcoming People's National Movement (PNM) internal elections.
Gulf View was represented by Mary O'Rourke, KC, David Boyle, and Joseph Prince, while Katherine Deal, KC, represented Dr Roopchand.
Douglas Mendes, SC, led Nunez-Tesheira's legal team.
