Akash Samaroo
Lead Editor-Politics
akash.samaroo@cnc3.co.tt
Opposition Leader Pennelope Beckles says the Privy Council’s judgment has established a clear constitutional standard against which the Government’s decision to declare Maloney a closed area under the Special Operations Act must now be measured.
In a statement yesterday, Beckles said while the People’s National Movement (PNM) respected the ruling upholding the 2011 State of Emergency, the judgment also reinforced the safeguards governments must observe when restricting citizens’ constitutional rights.
“The Privy Council has set the standard. Maloney must be measured against it,” she declared.
Beckles pointed to the Board’s finding that an emergency must be “sudden, immediate and likely to be short-lived,” arguing that extraordinary powers should not replace ordinary law enforcement.
She questioned why Maloney residents were entering their eighth night under curfew without an announced end date or what she considered an adequate public explanation for the restrictions.
According to Beckles, police had already arrested suspects connected to the November 9 shooting within three days, raising questions about what continuing threat justified maintaining the curfew.
She also argued that the Special Operations Act lacked safeguards comparable to those governing the 2011 emergency, including parliamentary scrutiny and time limits.
“The Opposition supports every lawful effort to take gunmen off the streets of Maloney. We will not accept a whole community treated as suspects with no reasons given and no end in sight,” she said.
Beckles called on the Government to publish the grounds for declaring Maloney a closed area, establish an end date, bring the relevant orders before Parliament for debate and guarantee detainees access to legal representation.
She also reminded residents that the Opposition’s People’s Counsel initiative was providing free legal assistance to individuals who believed their rights had been violated during the ongoing security operations.
The Opposition Leader’s interpretation comes as the Special Operations Act faces a separate constitutional challenge in the High Court, with the legality of its provisions and their application yet to be determined.
