Derek Achong
Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
A hardware company has lost its final appeal over losing its $1.3 million deposit for a failed property purchase.
In a judgment delivered late last week, five Law Lords of the United Kingdom-based Privy Council dismissed Dindial’s Hardware Ltd’s appeal against Teresa de Silva.
The legal dispute was connected to a property in Maraval.
In October 2016, de Silva entered into a contract with Abdul Latif Kazim to purchase the property for US1.5 million.
Under the terms of the contract, de Silva paid a US$100 deposit and Kazim agreed to complete the deal after the probate of the will of a deceased relative, who owned it.
A month later, de Silva entered into a contract with the company to sell the property for $13 million and complete the sale by February 2017.
The company was informed of the previous contract with Kazim and paid her a ten per cent deposit.
In March 2017, the company sought to terminate the contract one basis that de Silva had no title to the property and sought a refund of the deposit.
De Silva sought to rely on the completion notice principle under conveyancing law as she claimed that the company was required to notify her of a revised completion date before seeking to terminate the contract for breaching it (revised deadline).
The company’s case was upheld by a High Court Judge, who found that it was entitled to take the action it did.
The Court of Appeal eventually overturned the decision. It found that de Silva had acquired a legal right to the property through her contract with Kazim and the completion notice principle applied.
In determining the case, the board agreed with the Court of Appeal.
Lord Michael Briggs found the completion notice principle applied as the company knew that de Silva’s ability to complete the deal was dependent on the completion of the probate process.
“The result is that, since Mrs de Silva did not suffer from the type of fundamental absence of title to which the no title principle applies, there was nothing to displace her right to have time for completion made of the essence by a notice to complete, before the expiry of which Dindial could not (as it did) purport to treat the November contract as at an end,” Lord Briggs said.
Lord Briggs also rejected submissions raised by the company in the Privy Council but not before the local courts.
He found that the company could not claim that de Silva would not have been able to complete the transaction with Kazim due to issues with obtaining foreign exchange locally.
“Quite apart from the question whether she had any other source of finance, the assertion that TT dollars can be difficult to exchange for US dollars in Trinidad does not prove itself. It would need to be made good by evidence,” Lord Briggs said.
He also pointed out that the company could not claim equitable relief from the forfeiture of the deposit as it should have first raised the issue before the Appeal Court.
“The result is that it is simply far too late for the question of equitable relief from forfeiture to be raised for the first time before the board,” he said.
The company was represented by Terrence Bharath, SC, and Reza Ramjohn.
De Silva was represented by Seenath Jairam, SC, Jerome Rajcoomar and Shantal Jairam.
