JavaScript is disabled in your web browser or browser is too old to support JavaScript. Today almost all web pages contain JavaScript, a scripting programming language that runs on visitor's web browser. It makes web pages functional for specific purposes and if disabled for some reason, the content or the functionality of the web page can be limited or unavailable.

Wednesday, July 9, 2025

Sedition or Robber Talk?

by

2140 days ago
20190829
Editorial

Editorial

The Sedi­tion Act, un­used in the past, is now emerg­ing a vi­tal in­stru­ment of the po­lice. What is not clear is whether the T&T Po­lice Ser­vice is act­ing on its vo­li­tion or is re­spond­ing to a pub­lic com­plaint. Sat Ma­haraj made state­ments which were con­sid­ered “sedi­tious” and led to a search at the ra­dio sta­tion where those com­ments were made. Court ac­tion was re­quired to” force” the TTPS to pro­duce a search war­rant which ought to have been pre­sent­ed as a mat­ter of rou­tine. No charge has been made in that mat­ter to date. Yes­ter­day, the Min­is­ter of Na­tion­al Se­cu­ri­ty dis­closed at the post-Cab­i­net press con­fer­ence that at least one charge of sedi­tion would be laid against trade union leader and politi­cian Wat­son Duke.

A sedi­tious in­ten­tion is de­fined in sec­tion 3 (1) claus­es a to e of the act. Clause c is a catchall de­f­i­n­i­tion; “to raise dis­con­tent or dis­af­fec­tion amongst in­hab­i­tants of Trinidad and To­ba­go.” The crit­i­cal is­sue, there­fore, is to de­ter­mine a per­son's in­tent.

There are a num­ber of points to be con­sid­ered.

First, who is the com­plainant, or are the po­lice act­ing in their own right? The po­lice ser­vice has its hands full deal­ing with the crime surge, the spi­ralling mur­der rate in par­tic­u­lar. There is al­ready a se­vere back­log of cas­es in the courts, where post­pone­ments are the norm due to the non-ap­pear­ance of po­lice of­fi­cers. Is it that the po­lice are now pa­trolling the air­waves as part of an ex­er­cise in “to­tal polic­ing” or fol­low­ing a pol­i­cy of “no bro­ken win­dows?” If that is the case, sure­ly there are more im­por­tant ar­eas re­quir­ing at­ten­tion.

Sec­ond, was the of­fence com­mit­ted in a pub­lic broad­cast­ing space? If yes, then this is the province of the Telecom­mu­ni­ca­tions Au­thor­i­ty (TATT), which has wide pow­ers, not the least of which would be the pow­er to sus­pend a broad­cast­er's op­er­a­tions. Giv­en its broad pow­ers, TATT would hard­ly need a search war­rant.

Third, is it ap­pro­pri­ate for the an­nounce­ment to be made by the Min­is­ter of Na­tion­al Se­cu­ri­ty? The Min­is­ter could give no de­tails of MP Mar­lene Mc­Don­ald's ar­rest or charges which were even­tu­al­ly re­leased by the po­lice. The Po­lice Ser­vice is meant to be sep­a­rate from the Ex­ec­u­tive branch, lest it be tempt­ed to ex­ceed its pow­er and thus threat­en the de­mo­c­ra­t­ic rights of cit­i­zens.

Union lead­ers and politi­cians are of­ten giv­en to rhetoric on pub­lic plat­forms, which would not be con­sid­ered ac­cept­able in ra­tio­nal and con­sid­ered dis­course, es­pe­cial­ly at elec­tion time. Pro­fes­sor Rose-Marie Belle An­toine, Law Dean at UWI St Au­gus­tine, has cau­tioned that “sedi­tion can be used as a po­lit­i­cal tool since it is not amongst our es­tab­lished norms,” George Or­well warned that "threats to free­dom of speech, writ­ing and ac­tion, though of­ten triv­ial in iso­la­tion, are cu­mu­la­tive in their ef­fect and, un­less checked, lead to a gen­er­al dis­re­spect for the rights of the cit­i­zen." Is this a new po­lice ini­tia­tive?


Related articles

Sponsored

Weather

PORT OF SPAIN WEATHER

Sponsored