The Maloney Buildings Housing Development within Policing District 2 was designated a “closed area” under a Special Operations order on November 10th. The stimulus was a shooting incident in the car park of the Housing Development Corporation development. Video of this criminal activity was shared on Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar’s Facebook page. While there were no fatalities, Commissioner of Police Allister Guevarro said the decision was taken following receipt of intelligence that detected an escalating and dangerous situation involving gangs.
A defining feature of the localised measures is a 9 pm-5 am curfew. The T&T Defence Force is also on the ground. Guevarro asserted that residents had expressed gratitude for feeling safe for the first time in a long time. He was unapologetic for taking what he considered reasonable and lawful measures to protect residents. President Christine Kangaloo herself would have been satisfied that the measures were necessary before signing the order.
After the security forces rolled in, PM Persad-Bissessar’s Facebook page proclaimed that “not a single gang member had the courage to take on the brave men and women of the police and defence forces” because “fake bad man meet real bad man.”
This reminded me of the “Everyone is gangster till a real gangster shows up” meme circulating as commentary on El Salvador President Nayib Bukele’s deployment of 2,500 troops in Haiti after four people went missing. Bukele has been credited with the “State of Exception” crackdown on gangs and the drastic drop in the homicide rate in his country. However, his administration has also been accused of human rights abuses, with 93,000 warrantless arrests, hundreds of disappearances, torture, along with the persecution of independent journalists. Bukele’s El Salvador holds the top spot for the highest rate of incarceration in the world, with 2% of its population behind bars.
Does our national security apparatus want to copy from that playbook?
A T&T delegation recently had to defend our Government’s human rights record before a working group of the UNHRC in Geneva. Our recent multiple states of emergency are considered a threat to human rights. It is apparent that our protective services cannot yet curb the crime scourge without resorting to techniques that are rejected in developed countries.
American journalist H.L. Mencken once said that “the average man does not want to be free. He simply wants to be safe.”
I pondered this when I read that Felicity councillor Sundar Jookoo was calling for a “ZOSO” following an incident where a Venezuelan cyclist shot at a house in his area of responsibility. Does the average law-abiding citizen want their neighbourhood to be closed? I remember the Prime Minister saying that only United National Congress-controlled constituencies would be selected for Special Operations whenever triggering conditions arose.
Arouca/Maloney MP Camille Robinson-Regis and some Maloney residents were not as welcoming as councillor Jookoo. They questioned the closure of their area in contrast to non-declarations after the recent shooting of two women at a Couva spa and a prominent lawyer in Charlieville.
The T&T Police Service probably has information that gang members are active in the Maloney area. Some would ask if the selection was politically motivated. Are the people of this strongly PNM area being victimised? The PNM Opposition will definitely campaign on this perspective. Is the innocent majority appreciative of the restrictions? What is the economic impact? How long will Maloney be closed? Nine people have been arrested, and one firearm has been seized since the closure began. Have the threats been neutralised? What will determine if the mission is accomplished? Particular arrests? Expiration of a specific period?
Regardless, Maloney is the Closed Area pilot which will help shape the future implementation of this strategy. Will a UNC-controlled area be selected next to confirm non-discrimination? Will there be other closed areas declared for Christmas and Carnival? These upcoming periods are when the population tends to engage in liberal merriment. Will efficient systems be established to access curfew passes? On which grounds will they be granted? Medical and legitimate employment, perhaps? What would be the penalties for false declarations by those providing certification to access curfew permits?
In the midst of these very hefty national security considerations, the Ministry of Defence was forced to release a disclaimer regarding “misleading AI-generated videos” “making the claim that the Minister of Defence has been engaged in sexual misconduct.” I am bewildered that this ministry has not gotten the TTPS to arrest the individual responsible for spreading these alleged falsehoods. This sends the message that slander and/or libel will go unpunished. It could also be interpreted that the allegations contain some truth if their defence is a mere media release.
The Opposition brought a Private Member’s Motion last Friday concerning the governance of state enterprises and state-controlled institutions, alleging corruption and poor management. Government MPs generally defended themselves by deflecting to the indiscretions of “former” PNM government ministers. I have always felt that we should strive to do better, not just resort to “do so, eh like so.”
I am yet to hear a clear denial of the Opposition’s allegations that certain friends, family, financiers and companions were installed in influential positions, several of whom have had difficulty in executing their duties effectively. If these allegations cannot be disproved, the argument is weak. It also suggests that there are not enough competent, experienced UNC people to fill these positions. This Government’s apparent inclination for PNM-origin insulation is expected to continue otherwise.
